Ohio Chatter DEV

karen lotz

Crimson streak;1000781 wrote:God I hope osu is number 2 no one wants to see that shit fest again

I do

Crimson streak

karen lotz;1000785 wrote:I do

Well good luck with that

jordo212000

karen lotz;1000785 wrote:I do

Why we already know who is better?

karen lotz

jordo212000;1000807 wrote:Why we already know who is better?

No, you know that LSU beat Bama in one game. By that logic, we already know Iowa State is better than Oklahoma State, right?

Crimson streak

karen lotz;1000819 wrote:No, you know that LSU beat Bama in one game. By that logic, we already know Iowa State is better than Oklahoma State, right?

Ok then if bama wins well bama only beat lsu in one game. Now what do you do? By that logic no one is the national champ

karen lotz

Crimson streak;1000831 wrote:Ok then if bama wins well bama only beat lsu in one game. Now what do you do?

Give Bama the BCS championship trophy?

jordo212000

karen lotz;1000819 wrote:No, you know that LSU beat Bama in one game. By that logic, we already know Iowa State is better than Oklahoma State, right?

LSU beat Bama in Bama? If we don't value that win, what win would you ever value in college football

SportsAndLady

karen lotz;1000785 wrote:I do

No you don't...no one wants to see it, you're just "that guy" who goes against everyone so you say you wanna see it.

No one...NO ONE..wants to see bama LSU again over okie state LSU

Crimson streak

karen lotz;1000834 wrote:Give Bama the BCS championship trophy?

But lsu already beat bama at bama? How is that fair to lsu?

2kool4skool

He's a Notre Dame fan, you can't blame him for not recognizing quality football. It's been two decades since he last saw it.

Rotinaj

I wouldn't mind seeing bama and lsu in rematch. Of course I'd rather watch ok st and lsu but I'll enjoy either.

dazedconfused

Rotinaj;1000864 wrote:I wouldn't mind seeing bama and lsu in rematch. Of course I'd rather watch ok st and lsu but I'll enjoy either.

this is my thinking as well. actually thought the first lsu/bame game was pretty compelling - just would be a little awkward for a title game rematch

jordo212000

karen lotz;1000819 wrote:No, you know that LSU beat Bama in one game.

If we pair these teams up again, you may as well get rid of the BCS. Proponents of the BCS say that every week is a playoff and that these match-ups serve as de facto semi-finals. Well? Bama should have already been eliminated?

lhslep134

jordo212000;1000882 wrote: Well? Bama should have already been eliminated?

Where does OSU's loss to Iowa State fit in, in your opinion, then?

Crimson streak

lhslep134;1000887 wrote:Where does OSU's loss to Iowa State fit in, in your opinion, then?

Osu deserves it more over bama. They played a better schedule have better wins. And most Importantly bama had there shot at lsu at home and lost

-Society-

lhslep134;1000887 wrote:Where does OSU's loss to Iowa State fit in, in your opinion, then?

That's a horrible arguement, even for a douchebag like you.

Mulva

Crimson streak;1000844 wrote:But lsu already beat bama at bama? How is that fair to lsu?

How is it fair to Alabama that losing to the consensus #1 disqualifies you from being a top 2 team, but losing to an average at best 6-6 team doesn't?

Out of curiosity, what if the tables were turned and Alabama had beaten LSU?

LSU would still have wins over Oregon, Arkansas, and West Virginia. Would you complain if they made the title game over OSU in that situation?

Crimson streak

Mulva;1000904 wrote:How is it fair to Alabama that losing to the consensus #1 disqualifies you from being a top 2 team, but losing to an average at best 6-6 team doesn't?

Out of curiosity, what if the tables were turned and Alabama had beaten LSU?

LSU would still have wins over Oregon, Arkansas, and West Virginia. Would you complain if they made the title game over OSU in that situation?

That's different bc lsu has a better resume over osu and lost on the road. Bama lost at home and osu has the better resume

jordo212000

Oklahoma State had a tougher schedule and had a few wins over top 10 teams. The game they lost happened right after a tragedy at their school. I will cut them some slack.

karen lotz

jordo212000;1000837 wrote:LSU beat Bama in Bama? If we don't value that win, what win would you ever value in college football

It does get value. It was a regular season win.

ohiotiger33

There is a reason it is called the Mythical National Championship. Playoffs are the only way to crown true champions.

karen lotz

SportsAndLady;1000843 wrote:No you don't...no one wants to see it, you're just "that guy" who goes against everyone so you say you wanna see it.

No one...NO ONE..wants to see bama LSU again over okie state LSU

I do want to see it. Best two teams should play for title. LSU and Bama.

karen lotz

2kool4skool;1000859 wrote:He's a Notre Dame fan, you can't blame him for not recognizing quality football. It's been two decades since he last saw it.

you are an osu fan and have a bias against the sec.

jordo212000

karen lotz;1000964 wrote: Best two teams should play for title. LSU and Bama.

Oklahoma State had a better SOS and wins against top 10 teams. How do you know Bama is better?

cats gone wild

jordo212000;1000922 wrote:Oklahoma State had a tougher schedule and had a few wins over top 10 teams. The game they lost happened right after a tragedy at their school. I will cut them some slack.

jordo212000;1000981 wrote:Oklahoma State had a better SOS and wins against top 10 teams. How do you know Bama is better?

For some reason, I can only find one team that OSU beat in the top 10, and they are ranked 10 (KSU). Bama has a win in the top 10 also (ARK) who's ranked higher. Bama killed Ark, while OSU barely beat KSU.

Archive

BCS talk