posted by Ironman92

Not HOF

posted by Ironman92

Gwynn is one

posted by Ironman92

Ozzie Smith?

These are two of the three.

posted by Ironman92

Jeter

Only 14 All-Star games.
 

posted by Ironman92

Winfield?

12 All-Star games.
 

posted by Laley23

Robbie? Boggs?

Each made 12 All-Star games.
 

posted by Ironman92

Carew?

18 All-Star games, but he won the MVP in '77.

Gwynn fits.  Never won the MVP, though he finished top-10 in MVP voting seven times.

Ozzie fits.  15-time All-Star, but he not only never won the MVP, he only finished top-10 in voting once in his 19-year career.

The last one actually finished top-10 in MVP voting NINE times.  Never won it.  That has to suck.

posted by O-Trap

Only 14 All-Star games.
 

posted by Ironman92

Winfield?

12 All-Star games.
 

posted by Laley23

Robbie? Boggs?

Each made 12 All-Star games.
 

posted by Ironman92

Carew?

18 All-Star games, but he won the MVP in '77.

 

Stupid .388

posted by O-Trap

Gwynn fits.  Never won the MVP, though he finished top-10 in MVP voting seven times.

Ozzie fits.  15-time All-Star, but he not only never won the MVP, he only finished top-10 in voting once in his 19-year career.

The last one actually finished top-10 in MVP voting NINE times.  Never won it.  That has to suck.

Time frame?

Brooks won one ...Yaz won 1 hmmm

posted by Ironman92

Stupid .388

LOL!
 

posted by Ironman92

Time frame?

Entire career is post 1950s.

Clemente? Kaline? Billy Williams?

posted by Ironman92

Clemente? Kaline? Billy Williams?

You got it.

The recently late Al Kaline was an 18-time All-Star who finished in the top-10 in MVP voting nine times without ever winning it.

posted by O-Trap

You got it.

The recently late Al Kaline was an 18-time All-Star who finished in the top-10 in MVP voting nine times without ever winning it.

Dang

Oh Goddamnit, I had Al Kaline on brain and confused him with Alan Trammell.

posted by Laley23

Oh Goddamnit, I had Al Kaline on brain and confused him with Alan Trammell.

LOL  Well, he had the longevity.  Man played for 20 years.

Question #59:

Which post-1960s (entire career) HOF pitcher pitched for over 20 years and only managed to make two All-Star games?

Hint: There were two years he missed the All-Star game but still finished top-5 in Cy Young voting.

posted by O-Trap

Question #59:

Which post-1960s (entire career) HOF pitcher pitched for over 20 years and only managed to make two All-Star games?

Hint: There were two years he missed the All-Star game but still finished top-5 in Cy Young voting.

Sounds Sutton-like

Gaylord Perry

Fergie Jenkins

Bert Blyleven

posted by Ironman92

Sounds Sutton-like

Gaylord Perry

Fergie Jenkins

Bert Blyleven

Door #4 wins it.  Bert Blyleven only made the ASG twice in a 22-year career.  Craziness.

posted by O-Trap

Door #4 wins it.  Bert Blyleven only made the ASG twice in a 22-year career.  Craziness.

But ended career 3rd on all-time K list I think (at the time)

posted by Ironman92

But ended career 3rd on all-time K list I think (at the time)

I knew it was high.  If it's that high, that's nuts.

Question #60:

Here's a fun one.  A post-1980s HOF slugger who won 2 MVP awards, and who finished top-10 in MVP voting seven other times only made the All-Star game 5 times in a career that lasted 18 years.

First guess is Frank Thomas

Yount.

posted by Ironman92

First guess is Frank Thomas

Damn.  That was too easy.

I couldn't believe he only made 5 ASGs.

posted by Ironman92

First guess is Frank Thomas

This sounds correct.

posted by O-Trap

Damn.  That was too easy.

I couldn't believe he only made 5 ASGs.

1st base was loaded

posted by Ironman92

1st base was loaded

That's true.  Still, the man won multiple MVPs.  I would have thought that would count for more.  Just a weird time to play the position, I guess.