Is it time for private schools to have theyre own playoffs in football

• Thinthickbigred

  If the catholic schools dont have an advatage then how come so many of these schools dominate the public schools? Last year they won 5 of 6 titles and they are only 10% of the total number of schools... Its simple to me but lets here it
• GoChiefs

  

  Thinthickbigred;889718 wrote:If the catholic schools dont have an advatage then how come so many of these schools dominate the public schools? Last year they won 5 of 6 titles and they are only 10% of the total number of schools... Its simple to me but lets here it

  
  Have you not been reading the thread???? That question has been answered half a dozen times.
• Thinthickbigred

  GoChiefs;889722 wrote:Have you not been reading the thread???? That question has been answered half a dozen times.

  I dont read it everyday and this is an ongoing around in circles thread .. Let me here why catholic schools dominate again pls
  I know people personnally that continue to say the catholic schools are more disceplened when playing say a Cleveland Glenville .. This one idiot I know thats the way he always comes across .. He is a radical catholic if you can believe that... I get tired of hearing his nonsense ..He is the biggest hypocrit Ive ever known ... The dude says some racist remarks all the time inferrring about the intellegence and the disciplen of city schools .. He has single handidly made me root vehemitly against the catholic schools ...I get sick of hearing all the BULL..
• Rocket08

  I think that speaks as much about you, as about him
  
  You're talking 1 guy
  
  Get a life
  
  But I will pray for you
• skank

  

  Rocket08;889993 wrote:I think that speaks as much about you, as about him
  
  You're talking 1 guy
  
  Get a life
  
  But I will pray for you

  
  
  Wow, Top notch recruiter....English Major....Now, Miracle worker? Is there anything you can't do?
• skank

  

  GoChiefs;889722 wrote:Have you not been reading the thread???? That question has been answered half a dozen times.

  
  
  No, not really, that question has been responded to....It hasn't been answered.
  
  Me personally, I could care less if they actually give an answer....I already know the answer.
• GoChiefs

  

  skank;890453 wrote:No, not really, that question has been responded to....It hasn't been answered.
  
  Me personally, I could care less if they actually give an answer....I already know the answer.

  It's been answered. You just didn't like the answer.
• skank

  

  GoChiefs;890466 wrote:It's been answered. You just didn't like the answer.

  
  
  Oh, I see, so if sherman tells you that rainbows are made from butterflies landing on the noses of puppies, you'd believe it?
  
  
  I thought you were too smart to get lured into their cult.
• Thinthickbigred

  GoChiefs;890466 wrote:It's been answered. You just didn't like the answer.

  See I like honesty not lies and misconception
• sherm03

  

  Thinthickbigred;889895 wrote:I dont read it everyday and this is an ongoing around in circles thread .. Let me here why catholic schools dominate again pls

  Why should anyone even respond to it again after you've said that you probably won't even read it? You didn't read it the first time you asked. So why should anyone answer you again?
  
  You want to know why? Go back through the thread and find it.
• GoChiefs

  

  skank;890467 wrote:Oh, I see, so if sherman tells you that rainbows are made from butterflies landing on the noses of puppies, you'd believe it?
  
  
  I thought you were too smart to get lured into their cult.

  No, I just don't whine and cry about a private school winning a football game and claim how 'unfair' it is.
• GoChiefs

  

  Thinthickbigred;890479 wrote:See I like honesty not lies and misconception

  Again, just because the answer doesn't fit your agenda, doesn't mean the answer is wrong.
• Thinthickbigred

  GoChiefs;890562 wrote:Again, just because the answer doesn't fit your agenda, doesn't mean the answer is wrong.

  I havent heard any answers... Id like to hear from a few people as to why catholic schools do so much better . Why they won 5 out of 6 titles last year and that is not out of the norm even though they are 10% of the schools ...Nobody answers .. Pleas bring me up an answer to that question
• GoChiefs

  

  Thinthickbigred;891391 wrote:I havent heard any answers... Id like to hear from a few people as to why catholic schools do so much better . Why they won 5 out of 6 titles last year and that is not out of the norm even though they are 10% of the schools ...Nobody answers .. Pleas bring me up an answer to that question

  What part of reread the thread do you not understand? It HAS been answered..multiple times.
• Dean Wormer

  Thinthickbigred;891391 wrote:I havent heard any answers... Id like to hear from a few people as to why catholic schools do so much better . Why they won 5 out of 6 titles last year and that is not out of the norm even though they are 10% of the schools ...Nobody answers .. Pleas bring me up an answer to that question

  Ok Thin let's try this again. Try to read this really slow so it sinks in. They were better athletes!!!!!
• aged jock

  Thinthickbigred;891391 wrote:I havent heard any answers... Id like to hear from a few people as to why catholic schools do so much better . Why they won 5 out of 6 titles last year and that is not out of the norm even though they are 10% of the schools ...Nobody answers .. Pleas bring me up an answer to that question

  I disagree that they're better athletes. My Alter Knights have played Big Red twice in state championship games in the last 5 years. Steubenville had better athletes the first game by far. In fact, the first two quarters Big Red blew Alter away. But Alter had a better TEAM. Alter hung in there, pressured Collaros, stopped runs and catches by unbelievable athletes, and almost won the game. The second game showed how valuable it is to have been there before. While the athletic scale was more equal, Alter's teamwork prevailed. If Big Red gets a great team from whatever athletes are there, why is it unfair for Alter to do the same?
  
  As many have said before, why do you expect the same percentage of the population of private schools to be winners as the percentage of the population of public schools? Many public schools, particularly in rural settings, are the only game in town. When you have no competition for students or athletes, you often settle for lower results. You win your league of local schools just like you and figure that's a good season. Then you play schools that have to scrape and work to compete with a lot of other schools that have to do the same. Is it any surprise that you get your head handed to you?
  
  There's no mystery here. And it's not unfair competition. A lot of times the loser is not used to the competition the winner has to survive. Other times it's two great teams, like Big Red and Alter. You, Thick, above many, should understand this.
• aged jock

  One other point. State championships tend to be heavily influenced by coaching. Coach Reno is certainly top notch, I'm sure you'll agree, Thinthick. It's a lot easier for a private school to hire and keep a great coach who plays the right players in the right positions than it is to hire a public school coach who can ignore the politics and play the best players where they should play. That's another factor that favors the high end private school successes.
• aged jock

  Thinthickbigred;889717 wrote:Im glad you consider a bunch of Steubenville kids all stars

  That 2006 Big Red team was certainly a bunch of all stars, wherever they came from.
• Al Bundy

  The better teams usually win. I know this goes against thinthickbigred's agenda, but Big Red has a great record against private schools in the last decade.
• Dean Wormer

  Al Bundy;891890 wrote:The better teams usually win. I know this goes against thinthickbigred's agenda, but Big Red has a great record against private schools in the last decade.

  Except Cardinal Mooney.
• Thinthickbigred

  Dean Wormer;891661 wrote:Ok Thin let's try this again. Try to read this really slow so it sinks in. They were better athletes!!!!!

  That part I agree with ... But How does 10% of the schools consistantly have better athletes if they dont recruit like a university?
• Thinthickbigred

  Al Bundy;891890 wrote:The better teams usually win. I know this goes against thinthickbigred's agenda, but Big Red has a great record against private schools in the last decade.

  Ive said this multiple times .. I am not speaking on Steubenville's behalf .. I am speaking for my poor little brothers who cant stand up to you Russians
• skank

  

  Of course they're better athletes, you get little Johnny from over here, he's the best at his school. You get little Billy from over here, he's the best at his school. You get little Braylon from over here....Get it?
• Rocket08

  And you don't?
• Al Bundy

  Rocket08;892258 wrote:And you don't?

  I was in Michigan for work last week and was talking with someone up there who received fliers for the Massillon combine. It's a good thing they don't recruit because who knows what they would do under those circumstances.