NFL replacement refs

• Automatik

  

  Ironman92;1279742 wrote:wtfl;dr

  It's sports related and a decent read. You can handle it.
• sportchampps

  Offensive pass interference ref blew it... It cost a team a game... Two bad calls in the end... The refs literally gave this game to Seattle. That was highway robbery
• Ironman92

  

  Automatik;1279790 wrote:It's sports related and a decent read. You can handle it.

  
  Ain't happening.
• Raw Dawgin' it

  

  After this game, the ravens/pats game, and the SF/Minn game - no reason the real refs shouldn't be signed by the time Baltimore and Cleveland kick off.
• Gblock

  for those who continue to say the rate of calls is the same, half of the calls i saw last night were away from the play and had no effect on the outcome.
• WebFire

  Gblock;1279895 wrote:for those who continue to say the rate of calls is the same, half of the calls i saw last night were away from the play and had no effect on the outcome.

  So?
• WebFire

  sportchampps;1279792 wrote:Offensive pass interference ref blew it... It cost a team a game... Two bad calls in the end... The refs literally gave this game to Seattle. That was highway robbery

  So the 8 sacks the Packers gave up had nothing to do with it?
• Gblock

  WebFire;1279921 wrote:So?

  those type of plays usually result in no calls
• WebFire

  Gblock;1279924 wrote:those type of plays usually result in no calls

  Depends on the penalty, but I don't entirely agree with this statement.
• Gblock

  WebFire;1279928 wrote:Depends on the penalty, but I don't entirely agree with this statement.

  did you watch the whole game?
• Sonofanump

  @Web & Gblock. Not sure which direction you guys are going with this, but I'll crime in. Safety or personal fouls alway should be called. I have no idea why defensive holding was called on the 7 yard hook when the ball was already being thrown 30 yards downfield.
• Gblock

  the direction im going is that the refs while they may be nice guys and are trying their best are in over their heads. they are providing substandard officiating. Not that I know many who defend them, but the ones that are use the frequency of calls to say that the game is essentially being reffed about the same. I beg to differ. I watched almost all of the games, and half of the times on the replay the announcers as well as everyone in my living room would say where was the holding/interference and that is even if the refs themselves agree with the call. in the baltimore game one ref calls offensive interference on torrey smith td catch and the other ref comes in and says no it wasnt interference and gave the touchdown.
  
  besides that there is no rhythm to the games and they take forever.
• IggyPride00

  

  From Peter King again:
  

  RT @SatansLollipop: After last night, only argument real refs need to make to Goodell is, "Do you want the Super Bowl to look like this?"

  Isn't that the truth, can you imagine what a nightmare that would be for the league? Hadn't thought about that.
• Cat Food Flambe'

  

  Gblock;1279895 wrote:for those who continue to say the rate of calls is the same, half of the calls i saw last night were away from the play and had no effect on the outcome.

  I'll chime in and state that I think many of the player are getting more aggressive in seeing what they can get away with, particularly out on the pass routes. There seems to be a lot more bumping and grabbing downfield.
  
  The calls still suck though - it's almost as if after every play you have stop and ask "OK, how are they gonna decide what to call on THIS play"?
• Sonofanump

  Gblock;1279964 wrote:the direction im going is that the refs while they may be nice guys and are trying their best are in over their heads. they are providing substandard officiating. Not that I know many who defend them, but the ones that are use the frequency of calls to say that the game is essentially being reffed about the same. I beg to differ. I watched almost all of the games, and half of the times on the replay the announcers as well as everyone in my living room would say where was the holding/interference and that is even if the refs themselves agree with the call. in the baltimore game one ref calls offensive interference on torrey smith td catch and the other ref comes in and says no it wasnt interference and gave the touchdown.
  
  besides that there is no rhythm to the games and they take forever.

  Good post.
• queencitybuckeye

  My issue is that we were being sold that one of the major problems is that the players are larger and the game far faster than the replacements are used to. While true, the problem at the end of last night's game was one of simple incomptence. The missed calls would be exactly the same at any level of ball, and the players were basically stationary. The "too big too fast" excuse doesn't wash.
• sleeper

  

  I actually enjoy the games better with the replacement refs. They seem to let the players play a little bit rather than calling every ticky tack penalty.
  
  It seems the players and the coaches are the ones disrespecting the game and making it worse than the actual referees. A $1,000,000 fine for bitching against the refs should do the trick.
• IggyPride00

  

  They seem to let the players play a little bit rather than calling every ticky tack penalty.

  Are you kidding?
  
  24 penalties for 245 yards last night combine.
  
  That is what you consider "letting them play"?
• Gblock

  after watching the last play in slow motion again i am flabbergasted that offensive pass interference wasnt called. he shoved him completely to the ground.
• queencitybuckeye

  Gblock;1280012 wrote:after watching the last play in slow motion again i am flabbergasted that offensive pass interference wasnt called. he shoved him completely to the ground.

  If anything, that miss is actually worse than the possession call.
• Gblock

  queencitybuckeye;1280014 wrote:If anything, that miss is actually worse than the possession call.

  xactly
• WebFire

  Gblock;1280012 wrote:slow motion

  We'd all be good refs, wouldn't we?
• WebFire

  sleeper;1279985 wrote: It seems the players and the coaches are the ones disrespecting the game and making it worse than the actual referees..

  I actually agree with this.
• Gblock

  WebFire;1280044 wrote:We'd all be good refs, wouldn't we?

  I actually think i could...but im not sure what my competence has to do with theirs. I didnt get hired by the nfl. I m not a doctor but if my hand gets cut off and sewn on backwards should i not complain because i dont know how to do surgery?
• sleeper

  

  IggyPride00;1279991 wrote:Are you kidding?
  
  24 penalties for 245 yards last night combine.
  
  That is what you consider "letting them play"?

  Well I don't see the refs out there holding players and hitting players at the whistle.