Heisman Race (Season long thread)

• Blanket

  Stiff Arm Trophy has their poll up for Week 3 (Had 68 Heisman Voters)
  
  #1 Denard Robinson (65 Votes) 96%
  #2 Terrelle Pryor (64 Votes) 94%
  #3 Ryan Mallett (63 Votes) 91%
  #4 Kellen Moore (61 Votes) 90%
  #5 Andrew Luck (57 Votes) 83%
  #6 Mark Ingram (58 Votes) 82%
• karen lotz

  

  ^^^^^^
  
  Did gibby get another new user name??
• Trueblue23

  

  karen lotz;500201 wrote:^^^^^^
  
  Did gibby get another new user name??

  Nah, I didn't see Brantley on that list hahah.
• OneBuckeye

  

  How could someone vote Mallet in the top 3 for Heisman after that debacle on saturday.
  
  My Top 3
  
  1. D. Rob
  2. Pryor
  3. K. Moore
• Trueblue23

  

  I agree with you OneBuckeye.
  
  IMO the top 3 are really close right now.
  
  1. Denard Robinson
  2. T. Pryor
  3. Kellen Moore
• karen lotz

  

  Trueblue23;500233 wrote:Nah, I didn't see Brantley on that list hahah.

  
  
  lol, I was more referring to the actual user name. Michael Jackson named his kid Blanket.
• Trueblue23

  

  Lol I know, I was making fun of him for swearing up and down that Brantley would get invited to NYC.
• krambman

  

  OneBuckeye;500243 wrote:How could someone vote Mallet in the top 3 for Heisman after that debacle on saturday.

  
  He still completed 66% of his passes for 357 yards (nearly a 10yards per completion) and a touchdown against the #1 ranked team in the country who's first in scoring defense and 28th in pass defense. On the season he's completing 69% of his passes, he has 1438 passing yards, and 10 TD's to 5 INT's and a .04 passer rating. I'm not saying he should be on the list, just that it's not completely outrageous if he is.
• karen lotz

  

  .04 passer rating? That might be the lowest I've ever seen, and you think he should be a Heisman contender??
• Trueblue23

  

  10/16, 277 yds, 3 TDs, ZERO interceptions.
  
  18 rushes, 218 yds, 2 TDs
  
  Denard is pretty damn good.
• Trueblue23

  

  Only player EVER to have TWO games with atleast 200 yds passing and rushing. EVER.
• wes_mantooth

  

  Pryor didn't really help his case today. I was listening to some sports talk the other day....one of the national guys said that Ingram's effort last week was enough to put him in the top 3.....
• -Society-

  

  Trueblue23;505210 wrote:Only player EVER to have TWO games with atleast 200 yds passing and rushing. EVER.

  
  That's great. Individual accomplishments are great. Go Mom!
• centralbucksfan

  Trueblue23;505208 wrote:10/16, 277 yds, 3 TDs, ZERO interceptions.
  
  18 rushes, 218 yds, 2 TDs
  
  Denard is pretty damn good.

  
  I'll agree, he is pretty damn good. And he is easily in front as far as Heisman. But he has yet to play even a decent defense. I need to see him do something against quality. But still...he i sputting up some amazing numbers.
• centralbucksfan

  wes_mantooth;505212 wrote:Pryor didn't really help his case today. I was listening to some sports talk the other day....one of the national guys said that Ingram's effort last week was enough to put him in the top 3.....

  
  I honestly don't see Pryor winning to be honest. Not unless he steps up and has some huge games down the stretch. He has improved greatly...but he still has a ways to go as far as throwing the ball consistantly.
• Azubuike24

  

  The Heisman is Mark Ingram's to lose RIGHT NOW, assuming Bama doesn't lose and he continues to roll as he has. With that said, Robinson's stats are insane. Ryan Mallett's are going to end up insane as well.
• gerb131

  

  Azubuike24;505227 wrote:The Heisman is Mark Ingram's to lose RIGHT NOW, assuming Bama doesn't lose and he continues to roll as he has. With that said, Robinson's stats are insane. Ryan Mallett's are going to end up insane as well.

  
  I agree. Ingram is a beast and will hang 150 on Florida today.
• centralbucksfan

  Azubuike24;505227 wrote:The Heisman is Mark Ingram's to lose RIGHT NOW, assuming Bama doesn't lose and he continues to roll as he has. With that said, Robinson's stats are insane. Ryan Mallett's are going to end up insane as well.

  
  Not if Robinson keeps putting up the numbers he is. Like Tebow his soph year. That being said, if Ingram has a big game vs Fla...he is certainly right there. But Robinson is on another planet right now.
• IggyPride00

  

  centralbucksfan;505246 wrote:Not if Robinson keeps putting up the numbers he is. Like Tebow his soph year. That being said, if Ingram has a big game vs Fla...he is certainly right there. But Robinson is on another planet right now.

  
  It's definitely Robinson's to lose and the Tebow sophomore year comparison is on the money. His numbers are so out of the this world right now that it will compensate for the fact Michigan won't be in the national title hunt which is the situation Tebow faced his sophomore year.
  
  Robinson is actually the leading rusher in the nation, and his passing statistics are above average. Voters have also stopped being hesitant to vote for underclassmen like they once were, so he is continues at anywhere near this pace it will be almost impossible not to give it to him. It's not his fault their defense may be the worst in the country, he can only control what the offense does and he is doing a bang up job of it.
• gerb131

  

  Robinson won't make it the whole season. He has left I think all but 1 game hurt against some cream puffs.
• Cleveland Buck

  

  It's a two man race between Robinson and Ingram. I think Ingram ends up winning it.
• Hb31187

  

  Lol Gerb, his opponents had NOTHING to do with him getting injured either time. It could of happened with me or you tackling him. He just landed hard and bruised his knee against BGSU and landed directly on that same knee today. Its not like some big 250lb linebacker rung his bell
• karen lotz

  

  Pryor got hurt today because it was a physical Big Ten game right?
• Cleveland Buck

  

  karen lotz;505268 wrote:Pryor got hurt today because it was a physical Big Ten game right?

  
  Yes. Even if a physical play didn't directly cause the injury, the accumulation of hits takes its toll and can cause you make an awkward cut or misstep to avoid another hit and you end up pulling something. It is the reason I hate that we have to run Pryor so much because the running backs that Tressel will allow off the bench are ineffective much of the time.
• 2kool4skool

  

  centralbucksfan;505220 wrote:I honestly don't see Pryor winning to be honest.

  
  But are you being honest?