Is it time for private schools to have theyre own playoffs in football

• queencitybuckeye

  skank;587126 wrote:THIS, is what's hypocritical, You can't say team A would beat team B, if they didn't play....hence, the answer doesn't exist. Unless, you have a crystal ball.

  
  Big difference between speculating on what would happen vs. an outright distortion of fact, don't you think? Still waiting on the names of those Delphos "all-stars".
• tsst_fballfan

  

  aged jock;587099 wrote:Alter sends letters to any prospective student who has or might have interest in attending Alter. The contents of any letter talk about the great features of a school that starts with a religious culture, academic excellence, social activities, athletic opportunities, music and art. I get the Kettering Schools newsletter every couple of months, as does every resident of Kettering. Nothing wrong with any of that.

  
  oops my bad. I forgot to mention the jr lives 90 miles away from Alter. I also forgot to mention the jr has interest from multiple D1 colleges. :shrugs:
• skank

  

  queencitybuckeye;587136 wrote:Big difference between speculating on what would happen vs. an outright distortion of fact, don't you think? Still waiting on the names of those Delphos "all-stars".

  
  They didn't play....Therefore, the answer doesn't exist....Bottom line, Sorry, you're the one who made the rule, the least you can do is follow it.
• queencitybuckeye

  skank;587150 wrote:They didn't play....Therefore, the answer doesn't exist....Bottom line, Sorry, you're the one who made the rule, the least you can do is follow it.

  
  Fine, I'll stop and deal in facts only. You do the same and provide some proof of your allegations of creating. Bet you don't.
• Thinthickbigred

  queencitybuckeye;587081 wrote:Some other year, perhaps. This years DSJ team would have rolled you by 30.

  
  I dont think so ....Not early in the season .......We were riddled with injuries after week 2 ..I dont care anyway Ill play them we bit back ..they will sustain some damage believe that
• Thinthickbigred

  fish82;587082 wrote:At minimum.

  
  really ..I dont think you know very much ..You just talk alot ..bet you never even played.....
• Thinthickbigred

  tie vote right now ..I hope alot of people didnt vote yet until after the games ....proof is in the pudding.....
• Thinthickbigred

  queencitybuckeye;587105 wrote:DSJ is a better team than Steubenville. What's hypocritical about that?

  
  maybe ..maybe not ..... 1st game of the season my money is on us ......I know they are all the way across the state and play in a cow pasture ,but id like to have a crack at a few of them big bad MAC teams ....
• queencitybuckeye

  Thinthickbigred;587173 wrote:really ..I dont think you know very much ..You just talk alot ..bet you never even played.....

  
  Just high school and college. Sorry, didn't have the size, speed, or talent to play beyond that. Bet you were a star, though.
• Be Nice

  My fix for queeny....."Sorry, didn't have the size, speed, talent or brains to play beyond that".
• Thinthickbigred

  queencitybuckeye;587186 wrote:Just high school and college. Sorry, didn't have the size, speed, or talent to play beyond that. Bet you were a star, though.

  
  Good for you but I wasnt talking to you ..That was to Fish...you are misquoting me
• queencitybuckeye

  Thinthickbigred;587190 wrote:Good for you but I wasnt talking to you ..That was to Fish...you are misquoting me

  
  My bad.
• Alma_Parker

  Almost true, as in D-IV Hartley only lost to Elyria Catholic and Ironton this year. Weirdly enough, at least to the whiner brigade on here, nobody in Ironton is complaining to see Hartley as state champs. They won the game by 3 TDs and beat Ironton by a TD a couple weeks ago even though Ironton beat them by 3 TDs earlier in the regular season. Guess why the difference in the two games? Was it because Ironton is from a poor southern public school and Hartley from a big-city parochial school? Nope! It's because in the first game Ironton did in fact shut Key mostly down and forced four fumbles and made no errors. In the second game Key got somewhat back on track, Ironton fumbled twice late (after five in the prior twelve games). Hartley's coach, who seems to be first-class, made some nice adjustments and mixed up the backs more and had obviously been doing some homework. All the same stuff Coach Lutz did the years he beat folks like St. V-M and Mooney and DeSales in playoff games. It's what you do to win. In Ironton today they're celebrating a great year and taking their hats off to a terrific Hartley team. Being classy rather than thinking of how Portsmouth Notre Dame and Cardinal Strich have an unassailable advantage. I'm sure their doing the same thing at Kenton and Versailles and Orrville. Face it though, we are drifting towards a victim culture, where folks look for reasons somebody else (who is working hard) has it too easy. Maybe Jerry Springer or another daytime TV guy could do a segment on why publics 'can't win.'
• queencitybuckeye

  Be Nice;587189 wrote:My fix for queeny....."Sorry, didn't have the size, speed, talent or brains to play beyond that".

  
  Strong. I'm in awe.
• Be Nice

  I think "we all know" why publics can't win.
• skank

  

  Alma_Parker;587194 wrote:Almost true, as in D-IV Hartley only lost to Elyria Catholic and Ironton this year. Weirdly enough, at least to the whiner brigade on here, nobody in Ironton is complaining to see Hartley as state champs. They won the game by 3 TDs and beat Ironton by a TD a couple weeks ago even though Ironton beat them by 3 TDs earlier in the regular season. Guess why the difference in the two games? Was it because Ironton is from a poor southern public school and Hartley from a big-city parochial school? Nope! It's because in the first game Ironton did in fact shut Key mostly down and forced four fumbles and made no errors. In the second game Key got somewhat back on track, Ironton fumbled twice late (after five in the prior twelve games). Hartley's coach, who seems to be first-class, made some nice adjustments and mixed up the backs more and had obviously been doing some homework. All the same stuff Coach Lutz did the years he beat folks like St. V-M and Mooney and DeSales in playoff games. It's what you do to win. In Ironton today they're celebrating a great year and taking their hats off to a terrific Hartley team. Being classy rather than thinking of how Portsmouth Notre Dame and Cardinal Strich have an unassailable advantage. I'm sure their doing the same thing at Kenton and Versailles and Orrville. Face it though, we are drifting towards a victim culture, where folks look for reasons somebody else (who is working hard) has it too easy. Maybe Jerry Springer or another daytime TV guy could do a segment on why publics 'can't win.'

  Or better yet, maybe Maury Povich could do a show on who the kid belongs to.
• Be Nice

  queeny...thank you.
• queencitybuckeye

  Be Nice;587200 wrote:I think "we all know" why publics can't win.

  
  Because they're beat before the game even starts from the "no fair" attitude?
• Be Nice

  When everyone starts play'in by the same rules then and only then will people like myself not have an agenda. Game on.
• skank

  

  queencitybuckeye;587204 wrote:Because they're beat before the game even starts from the "no fair" attitude?

  
  Maybe so, here's your chain reaction
  
  Ursuline goes out and recruits areas (and beyond) talent
  Word gets out as to how good they are going to be
  After a couple of games, they destroy everyone, with said talent
  People begin to take notice
  They destroy the remaining portion of their schedule
  People are REALLY noticing their talent now
  People begin to think that, despite being D V, Ursuline can beat anybody, IN ANY DIVISION
  
  Now, go up and replace the word Ursuline with YOUR choice of Private school, it's universal, it works in all ways.
• queencitybuckeye

  Still waiting on proof that it works for Delphos. Where is it (again, remember where I taught you what the word rhetorical means)?
• queencitybuckeye

  Be Nice;587208 wrote:When everyone starts play'in by the same rules then and only then will people like myself not have an agenda. Game on.

  
  OK, then explain Delphos. 100% of their kids are local. Clearly, you'll need to find a different "unfair advantage" for them. What is it?
• fish82

  

  Thinthickbigred;587173 wrote:really ..I dont think you know very much ..You just talk alot ..bet you never even played.....

  Not much, just high school and a little college. Here's the funny thing...I lost twice in the semi-finals to those eeeeeevvvvilllll catholic bastages too. I'd think that someone from a school who has proven that publics can compete quite nicely with the privates would be far less whiny. Guess not.
• sherm03

  

  skank;587212 wrote:Maybe so, here's your chain reaction
  
  Ursuline goes out and recruits areas (and beyond) talent
  Word gets out as to how good they are going to be
  After a couple of games, they destroy everyone, with said talent
  People begin to take notice
  They destroy the remaining portion of their schedule
  People are REALLY noticing their talent now
  People begin to think that, despite being D V, Ursuline can beat anybody, IN ANY DIVISION
  
  Now, go up and replace the word Ursuline with YOUR choice of Private school, it's universal, it works in all ways.

  OK...let me give it a shot.
  
  Louisville St. Thomas Aquinas goes out and brings in students from surrounding areas
  Word gets out how they are going to be.
  After a couple of games, they are sitting at 2-3.
  People begin to take notice.
  They play out the rest of the season at 3-2.
  People are REALLY noticing their talent now.
  They don't make the playoffs...AGAIN...and spend another post season at home.
  
  Wait, that doesn't fit skank. I thought you said ANY private school would fit your mold and that it's universal.
  
  Let me try again.
  
  Cleveland Villa Angela St. Joe goes out and recruits areas (and beyond) talent
  Word gets out as to how good they are going to be
  After a couple of games, they are 2-3.
  People begin to take notice.
  They finish their remaining games 2-3...with an overall record of 4-6.
  People are REALLY noticing their talent level now.
  They don't make the playoffs.
  
  Damn...it didn't work again. What am I doing wrong here skank?
• skank

  

  Here's what I propose, remember the NFL Europe? On the uniforms of the players they wore the logos of the NFL team they were affiliated with? That's what we should make the parochials do. A kid from Ignatius, he was recruited from Brecksville, he wears a Brecksville Bees logo on his jersey.