Jazz Guard Deron Williams to the Nets?

• sleeper

  

  Lebron
  Durant
  Wade
  Howard
  CP3
  Kobe
  Melo
  Gasol
  Dirk
  Williams
  
  Top 10 in the NBA.
• Laley23

  

  sleeper;688970 wrote:Lebron
  Durant
  Wade
  Howard
  CP3
  Kobe
  Melo
  Gasol
  Dirk
  Williams
  
  Top 10 in the NBA.

  
  The guy who might win MVP cant crack the top 10?
• karen lotz

  

  Laley23;688984 wrote:The guy who might win MVP cant crack the top 10?

  
  
  Huh? His name is at the top of the list.
• karen lotz

  

  I know what you are saying, but Rose needs to produce like he is for more than half of a season to take that next step.
• trep14

  Commander of Awesome;688543 wrote:LBJ
  Durrant
  CP3
  Williams
  Kobe
  Pau Gasol
  Dwade
  Derrick Rose
  Blake Griffin
  Howard
  Dirk
  Al Hortford
  LaMarcus Aldridge
  Paul Pierce
  Tim Duncan
  Amare'
  then I'd list Melo.
  
  Not exactly in that order but I'd put Melo at the bottom of that list.

  
  That's all you need to do to back up the IPOTW nomination. Fail. Pwned.
• SQ_Crazies

  

  1. LeBron
  2. Durant
  3. D-Wade
  4. Howard
  5. CP3
  6. Melo
  7. Kobe
  8. Amare
  9. Gasol
  10. Dirk
  
  He's not top 10. After 10, he's in the next 10 somewhere probably but I could definitely name some more guys I'd take before Williams. There is a reason this deal went down AFTER the Nets tried to get Melo.
• sleeper

  

  Laley23;688984 wrote:The guy who might win MVP cant crack the top 10?

  
  He's having a great season, no doubt, but he's not one of the top 10 players in the league. Lebron will probably win the MVP anyway.
• trep14

  SQ_Crazies;689002 wrote:1. LeBron
  2. Durant
  3. D-Wade
  4. Howard
  5. CP3
  6. Melo
  7. Kobe
  8. Amare
  9. Gasol
  10. Dirk
  
  He's not top 10. After 10, he's in the next 10 somewhere probably but I could definitely name some more guys I'd take before Williams. There is a reason this deal went down AFTER the Nets tried to get Melo.

  
  No Rose? I think Rose has definitely played his way into the top 10 of NBA players this year. I would take him before Dirk, Gasol, Amare, CP3 or Melo. Just imo.
• SQ_Crazies

  

  Ew. No. Over CP3 or Melo? You're high. Dirk, Gasol, Amare--eh, I could see how you could have that opinion. But no way in hell is he better than CP3 or Melo. I don't think he's top 10 but he was part of that group I mentioned that I might take over Williams. Personally, I like Rondo better than Rose.
• stroups

  

  I'll play
  
  1. LeBron
  2. Durant
  3. D-Wade
  4. Howard
  5. Kobe
  6. Rose
  7. Melo
  8. CP3
  9. Amare
  10. Dirk
  
  Really the first five are kind of set for me then you could exchange the rest and just outside would be D. Williams, Gasol, the celtic 3, Griffin, Nash ect....
• Commander of Awesome

  

  SQ_Crazies;689023 wrote:Ew. No. Over CP3 or Melo? You're high. Dirk, Gasol, Amare--eh, I could see how you could have that opinion. But no way in hell is he better than CP3 or Melo. I don't think he's top 10 but he was part of that group I mentioned that I might take over Williams. Personally, I like Rondo better than Rose.

  
  http://hangtime.blogs.nba.com/2011/01/18/has-rose-passed-d-will-as-best-pg/
  
  AND Ryen Russillo of NBA Today disagress with you. LMAO way to prove you're a dipshit and dont know the NBA.
  
  http://espn.go.com/espnradio/player?rd=1#/podcenter/?id=6134967&autoplay=1&callsign=ESPNRADIO
• SQ_Crazies

  

  Wow, way to prove you're a dipshit. Who gives a flying fuck what Russillo thinks, he's no more (and probably less) qualified on this issue than I am. And I could find an article or a blog that supports Gerald Wallace being a top 5 player in the league or some stupid shit like that. You aren't proving anything.
• trep14

  SQ_Crazies;689023 wrote:Ew. No. Over CP3 or Melo? You're high. Dirk, Gasol, Amare--eh, I could see how you could have that opinion. But no way in hell is he better than CP3 or Melo. I don't think he's top 10 but he was part of that group I mentioned that I might take over Williams. Personally, I like Rondo better than Rose.

  
  I highly doubt that I'm the only one out there who would take Rose over CP3 or Melo.
• SQ_Crazies

  

  Maybe not.
• september63

  

  Count me in for taking Williams, CP3 or Rose over Melo, if i am starting a team from scratch.
• Mulva

  

  CP3 is either getting too much love, or D-Will and Rose aren't getting enough love by some on here. If Paul is top 5, there is no chance in hell that Rose and Williams are both outside of the top 10.
• SQ_Crazies

  

  Are we ranking players or talking about who we would take to start a team with? It wouldn't matter for me, but I just want some clarification.
• SQ_Crazies

  

  Mulva;689078 wrote:CP3 is either getting too much love, or D-Will and Rose aren't getting enough love by some on here. If Paul is top 5, there is no chance in hell that Rose and Williams are both outside of the top 10.

  
  Nah. They're all very good, but all have weaknesses. CP3 is easily the most complete package.
• Jester

  

  Commander of Awesome;688941 wrote:Way to back up your fail. lol nice self pwn idiot.

  My fail? That's your list dumbass. Way to make yourself look like a douche.
• Jester

  

  Top 10 (in no order)
  Kobe
  LBJ
  Wade
  Melo
  Durant
  Amare
  Rose
  CP3
  Howard
  Gasol
• SportsAndLady

  

  SQ_Crazies;689079 wrote:Are we ranking players or talking about who we would take to start a team with? It wouldn't matter for me, but I just want some clarification.

  
  You are just now asking this? After attacking other people's lists several times?
• jordo212000

  

  trep14;689073 wrote:I highly doubt that I'm the only one out there who would take Rose over CP3 or Melo.

  
  I wouldn't take Rose over Melo, but I would take him over CP3. A lot of people think Rose could be the league MVP this season
• lhslep134

  

  Commander of Awesome;688932 wrote:So he only plays half the game. Thanks for proving my point, nice fail.

  
  No, he plays defense when he needs to. If he didn't, Denver wouldn't have been so close to coming out of the West the past few years.
  
  The defense argument is so fucking dumb. The fact that COA is using it should tell you all you need to know. If these guys absolutely couldn't play defense they wouldn't be in the league. But when it actually matters (4th quarter) Carmelo can play average-above average defense. Who cares if he doesn't give it 100% in the 1st or 2nd quarter? A first half NBA lead is the most worthless lead in sports.
• trep14

  jordo212000;689153 wrote:I wouldn't take Rose over Melo, but I would take him over CP3. A lot of people think Rose could be the league MVP this season

  
  Yeah, I mean I would still take Rose over Melo, but I'll give you that I would have a harder time taking Rose over Melo than I would taking Rose over CP3.
• SQ_Crazies

  

  Nobody would have taken Rose over CP3 early in the season. But it's easy to forget about him when he plays on a middle of the road (at best) and you hear about Rose all year. The only reason he's getting MVP hype is because they have to build hype for someone not named LeBron--who is the obvious MVP of the league.
  
  There is a reason the Knicks and Nets moved on Melo, then Williams was the 2nd choice. And the reason why the Knicks would rather have CP3 than Williams. Not to mention, look what it was going to cost to get Melo vs. Williams.