American Idol

• WebFire

  tuskytuffguy wrote: Shioban is the shiznit. And for the record, it ain't a screech, it's a high note. You want screech, go listen to Courtney Love, that's screech. People dissed Lambert all last season for screeching. Wrong, that's a high note. Mariah Carey has it, Adam Lambert has it, and Shioban Magnus has it. That's a godamn gift.
  
  Oh, and I'd bang Shioban in a heartbeat.

  Wrong. Shiobhan's is a screech. The rest you were correct about. She CAN hit a good high note, but then she takes it too far and turns it into a screech.
• vball10set

  Nashley25 wrote: ...I think the final two are Sox and Lee with Sox winning.

  +1...I've said the same thing for the last 4 weeks
• zambrown

  

  I wasn't impressed with Lee last night. He may have settled down in the second half, but the 1st half was ALL over the place pitch wise. Don't get me wrong, he's not in any danger tonight, but that was by far his worst performance for me.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  Nashley25 wrote: I don't know why but in some weird twisted way I find Shioban hot. With that said I think the final two are Sox and Lee with Sox winning.

  The only reason I think Shioban is remotely attractive is because of the outfit she wore on last week's Wednesday (elimination) episode. Her legs looked pretty sweet!
• bigdaddy2003

  

  I don't find her that attractive. I just find her weird lol.
• Little Danny

  

  I have this feeling Chrystal will not win. I totally see a Chris Daughtery scenerio coming up where she makes it to the top three or four and then looses unexpectantly. Chrystal has the potential to make record companies a lot of money, and I think if she is locked into an Idol contact for the next couple of years she would not make as much as she otherwise would.
  
  I think Big Mike goes home tonight. He should have gone a couple weeks ago and everyone else that's left has a huge voting block so he is the odd man out.
• vball10set

  ^^^it'll either be him or Siobhan--IMO
• THE4RINGZ

  

  Sox has built up enough goodwill with the voters to overcome a weak performance last night.
  
  My guess fir who goes tonight: Big Mike or Aaron.
  
  My hope for who goes home: Shibon
• tuskytuffguy

  Oh well, my top two are Crystal and Shioban. Lee bores me to no end.
• coyotes22

  

  THE4RINGZ wrote: Sox has built up enough goodwill with the voters to overcome a weak performance last night.
  
  My guess fir who goes tonight: Big Mike or Aaron.
  
  My hope for who goes home: Shibon

  THIS!!!!
• HitsRus

  

  I think Casey goes home tonite. He and Lee compete for the same votes, and between the two he's the runner up. When he goes, it'll boost Lee to #1. I think Bowersox has been coasting...and she is going to need to pick it up to win. Make no mistake about it...she's really good...but she's been the same every week, and I think it'll get stale with voters.
  
  Predicted order of finish...updated 4/27
  Lee
  Crystal
  Shioban
  Mike
  Aaron
  Casey
• WebFire

  Time to reshuffle the order Hits. But you were so close.
  
  SEE YA SHIOBAN!!!
• sonofsam

  

  Who got kicked? Shioban?
• HitsRus

  

  Well the one with the best pipes is gone, but why is that a surprise? So we get to here Kelly another week....or two. Yawn.
• sonofsam

  

  HitsRus wrote: Well the one with the best pipes is gone, but why is that a surprise? So we get to here Kelly another week....or two. Yawn.

  who was kicked??
• sonofsam

  

  bump... Anyone? Anyone know who got the boot tonight?
• THE4RINGZ

  

  Shibon is gone
• ZeroCool

  just goes to show ya the best singer doesnt always win. its just a popularity contest. hated to see siobjan go. show will be boring now.
• Sonofanump

  I have never heard of Elliston before. I must have been to every other town in Ottawa county but that one.
• WebFire

  ZeroCool wrote: just goes to show ya the best singer doesnt always win. its just a popularity contest. hated to see siobjan go. show will be boring now.

  Uhhh...ok. :huh:
• killdeer

  

  Siobhan should have been gone 5 weeks ago.
  'Bout time.
  Bein' cute and quirky does not equal great singer/performer.
  Good luck to her, though.
• september63

  

  She had a decent voice, but when she did her extreme vocals it became a screaming match. She has talent but perhaps tried too hard.
• coyotes22

  

  killdeer wrote: Siobhan should have been gone 5 weeks ago.
  'Bout time.
  Bein' cute and quirky does not equal great singer/performer.
  Good luck to her, though.

  Youre kidding right?
  
  She was NASTY!!!!
  
  the fuck was she wearing Tuesday night, a couch cushion, a curtain?
• gut

  Anyone else think it was really creepy the nerdy 17 yr old sang a Shaniah love song to his mom?
  
  I think Big Mike is just way overrated. Was real impressed with Casey this week. I think Casey, Lee and Crystal will have nice careers. The rest will be forgettable, although Siobhan might find a niche singing painful goth songs.
• brutus161

  

  Siobhan's singing made me want to punch babies.