American Idol

• bartsimpson

  About damned time...these two should have been the first two to leave the finals. Unbelievable that they made it this long.
  
  Not saying who since some of you may not have watched it yet....you'll have to look it up,
  
  HINT: It's on the front page of Yahoo right now....
• bigdaddy2003

  

  bartsimpson wrote: About damned time...these two should have been the first two to leave the finals. Unbelievable that they made it this long.
  
  Not saying who since some of you may not have watched it yet....you'll have to look it up,
  
  HINT: It's on the front page of Yahoo right now....

  I agree about Andrew Garcia but not about Katie Stevens. The nerdy kid should have left along with Garcia.
• pkebker

  I disagree. Andrew definitely had some talent, his problem is he tried too many risks that weren't his style. When he played his style of music, he was really good. The two that I think need to leave are Tim and Aaron. They both suck and won't have any chance on making a good record.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  pkebker wrote: I disagree. Andrew definitely had some talent, his problem is he tried too many risks that weren't his style. When he played his style of music, he was really good. The two that I think need to leave are Tim and Aaron. They both suck and won't have any chance on making a good record.

  His voice has no range. He's one dimensional. He sounds the same on every song. See: Chad Kroger.
• THE4RINGZ

  

  I cannot believe Garcia lasted as long as he did. Just goes to show it is more of a popularity contest rather than a true talent competition.
  
  I will miss Katie, I thought she was good. Much better than a couple of those hacks still on the show.
  
  But it really is a competition between Bowersox and Casey. Those two will be the final two. They are both pretty good.
  
  ETB, I'll bet you were happy to see your eye candy Adam Lambert back on stage last night. I imagine you were using were like fabulous, and yummy while he was performing.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  Ringz... What about Lee DeWyze? Think it will come down to the two you mentioned and him for final three?
  
  As far as the popularity contest... They way I see it, it is NOT a singing competition. Here is why... AMERICA votes. If it were a singing competition, then the judges would pick who stays and goes. With the people voting, it just shows who is the most marketable. Garcia sucked, but I'm sure he would sell records b/c people like him.
• THE4RINGZ

  

  I am not too sure about Lee being in the final three. I think he is good, but doesn't seem as marketable. The most marketable one up there (other than the two mentioned) is that Aaron kid. He is the next Justin Beiber, young, cute, and those tween girls will eat his shit up. Obvioulsy that is why he is still around, every 12 year old girl in America texts votes in for him because he is so dreamy.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  I'm still yet to figure out who this Justin Beiber kid is. Haven't heard any of his songs yet.
• THE4RINGZ

  

  I am not really sure who he is either, all I know is my girls are all into him. From what I can gather from the numerous Teen Beat pictures on their wall he is some hairless little twit with some huge following, His music makes fingernails running down a chalkboard sound good.
• Little Danny

  

  As mentioned before, this is a popularity contest. Lee Dewyze and Bowersox should be the final two, but it is all based on the teen voting. I would not be surrpised to see Lee get voted off a few weeks earlier than he should---- he just does not have the bubblegum style and a the pretty boy face the teens go for.
  
  The final two I predict will be Bowersox and Shioban. Seems like a lot of people think she is wonderful and unique (I am not one of them).
• Scarlet_Buckeye

  

  Putting all the personal crap aside relative to Adam Lambert, that guy can SING! Wow. Great performance.
• THE4RINGZ

  

  I thought Adam Lambert was the best singer/performer last season. And I don't care if he is a goth gay man, but that song last night was horrible.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  The song Lambert did isn't terrible, but his performances are too whiney. Just sing... quit acting like you're watching your dog die while you're singing.
• vball10set

  bigdaddy2003 wrote:
  I agree about Andrew Garcia but not about Katie Stevens. The nerdy kid should have left along with Garcia.

  this..and I think it'll come down to Crystal & Lee..jmo
• osu45804

  

  l still think big mike has the best voice & personality of anyone left
• WebFire

  osu45804 wrote: l still think big mike has the best voice & personality of anyone left

  To each his own I guess. I think Mike has an ok voice, but he really isn't that good.
• thedynasty1998

  

  osu45804 wrote: l still think big mike has the best voice & personality of anyone left

  I have the same feeling about Big Mike that I have towards Tim Tebow, that I feel like I should like them because they seem like genuine people, but I can't stand them because they just seem fake.
• THE4RINGZ

  

  I like Big Mike, good voice, good personality, great back story. Just not sure how marketable he is in the long run.
• fish82

  

  Teflon Tim is going to shock the world.
• Little Danny

  

  Big Mike has a better voice than Crystal?? Please. That girl can sing her butt off.
  
  Big Mike will be lucky to have a Reuben Studdard type of career.
• THE4RINGZ

  

  Rueben has a career in the music business? News to me.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  I can't STAND Tim Urban. I can't see him as a solo artist in ANY way/shape/form. Hell, not even as a front man. Only place he belongs is in a boy band.
• SnotBubbles

  Does anyone else think that Siobhan is terrible? I can't stand anything about her. If I was in to punching women in the face....I'd punch her in the face.
  
  
  
  
  
  She's like a cross bread between a Howler Monkey and a vampire.
  [size=xx-large]+[/size]
  
  [size=xx-large]=
  [/size]
  
• ernest_t_bass

  

  What I hate the most about Siobhan is that she whines to the judges when she's done. Just SHUT UP already.
• THE4RINGZ

  

  She is more than a little odd that's for sure, I don't know why she keeps getting the votes.