posted by Laley23

I dont think Gehrig ever got there. Mantle had to have. I think we have 3 (Williams, Mick, Ruth)

Mantle 1x

Killebrew did, I think.

Ruth 5x

Williams 6x

Need 1 more

Stan?

Need 1 more....don’t know if he liked beer or not but his name would be cool if he did 

posted by Ironman92

How do you spell Mays incorrectly? Lol

Because when you are an average player, your name isnt recognizable -- thus not easy to remember how to spell.

posted by O-Trap

Killebrew did, I think.

posted by Ironman92

Need 1 more....don’t know if he liked beer or not but his name would be cool if he did 

We post too fast for the question asker to keep up lol.
 

posted by Laley23

posted by Ironman92

Need 1 more....don’t know if he liked beer or not but his name would be cool if he did 

We post too fast for the question asker to keep up lol.
 

 

It’s weird because I waited several minutes after the question and no replies....walked out to garage and 60 seconds later 6 new posts appeared. I’ve messed up a few times but I’m putting this one on Justin if you don’t mind. Thanks

posted by Ironman92

It’s weird because I waited several minutes after the question and no replies....walked out to garage and 60 seconds later 6 new posts appeared. I’ve messed up a few times but I’m putting this one on Justin if you don’t mind. Thanks

Yeah, Ive made posts after a refresh (to make sure I am not duplicating an answer) and then after I post, there are like 9 new posts that didnt show up on the refresh. 

QUESTION #49

This post-1975 player never mad the Hall, but his rookie numbers would have made you think he would.

Rookie year: Led the league in innings pitched (192.1), complete games (11), and shutouts (8), all while posting a 13-7 record and a sub-2.50 ERA.

He would go on to notch only one 20-win season in his 17-year career, and he would go on to have more seasons with losing records than winning ones, though his overall winning % was still just a little over .500.

posted by O-Trap

QUESTION #49

This post-1975 player never mad the Hall, but his rookie numbers would have made you think he would.

Rookie year: Led the league in innings pitched (192.1), complete games (11), and shutouts (8), all while posting a 13-7 record and a sub-2.50 ERA.

He would go on to notch only one 20-win season in his 17-year career, and he would go on to have more seasons with losing records than winning ones, though his overall winning % was still just a little over .500.

Lead league in innings with 192?

Valenzuela in 1981 strike year?

Peavy?

posted by Ironman92

Lead league in innings with 192?

Valenzuela in 1981 strike year?

That's it.

posted by Laley23

Peavy?

Good guess too

194 innings would never lead....1994 I doubt anyone got to that many innings and 1995 I doubt that would lead but maybe. I went 1981 similar to 1994 but pitchers threw more

Still pissed about this one O-Trap. I hope this kept this great player from making the HOF. Nearly 400 HR, 1400 rbi tremendous outfielder

Ha, I was going to guess Valenzuela...thought he had a way better record to start career. Like Gooden (but not that good).

posted by Laley23

Ha, I was going to guess Valenzuela...thought he had a way better record to start career. Like Gooden (but not that good).

Gooden was insane....especially at 19

I plan on coming up with some more MVP related ones...but I need to get my other laptop. Comes down to effort at this point lol.

posted by Laley23

I plan on coming up with some more MVP related ones...but I need to get my other laptop. Comes down to effort at this point lol.

I welcome you guys adding yours. Little different angles and I like playing as much or more than I like asking them.

I'll do a semi-combined one. You guys should rifle through MOST of these quickly...Might be a few that trick you up.

QUESTION 50:

Since 1980, 16 players have had a run of 3 consecutive top-5 MVP finishes. 3 of them are in the HOF. Who are they? 

QUESTION 51: 

Who are the other 13?

I like #50

Schmidt?

Let’s get 50 before starting 51

Frank Thomas I’m decently sure

Griffey