O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
18,909
posts
Joined
Nov 2009
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
Mon, Apr 13, 2020 6:14 PM
posted by Al Bundy
Jeff kent
Yep. In 2000, Jeff Kent won the MVP and Silver Slugger, despite Bonds finishing better than him in all the listed categories. His case was the only one where the better stats were all held by the SAME teammate.
Jeff Kent
3 more.
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
18,909
posts
Joined
Nov 2009
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
Mon, Apr 13, 2020 6:15 PM
posted by Ironman92
It’s question 46 and I added to it...but first yours
I'm excited. :D I was going to put a twist on it as well, so I'm curious what yours is.
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
18,909
posts
Joined
Nov 2009
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
Mon, Apr 13, 2020 6:17 PM
posted by Al Bundy
Bonds?
Nope. Every time Bonds won, he led his team in homers (though one year, Bonilla was close)
posted by Laley23
Matt Holiday?
Never won MVP.
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
18,909
posts
Joined
Nov 2009
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
Mon, Apr 13, 2020 6:18 PM
posted by Laley23
Cal Ripken?
Good guess, but he led his team in HRs that year.
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
18,909
posts
Joined
Nov 2009
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
Mon, Apr 13, 2020 6:20 PM
posted by Laley23
Kent has to be one with Bonds.
Yep. Bundy barely beat you to this one, and his situation was definitely unique.
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
18,909
posts
Joined
Nov 2009
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
Mon, Apr 13, 2020 6:22 PM
posted by Ironman92
Terry Pendleton?
Didn't win the Silver Slugger.
posted by Al Bundy
Barry Larkin?
He's in Cooperstown.
posted by Laley23
Pudge? Tejada?
Ivan is in the Hall. Tejada didn't win the Silver Slugger.
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
18,909
posts
Joined
Nov 2009
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
Mon, Apr 13, 2020 6:23 PM
posted by Ironman92
Mookie Betts
Good question
Too late. Only between 1990 and 2010.
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
18,909
posts
Joined
Nov 2009
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
Mon, Apr 13, 2020 6:28 PM
posted by Al Bundy
Pendleton?
Didn't win the Silver Slugger.posted by Al Bundy
Mo Vaughn?
Was #1 on his team in HRs and slugging.
posted by Ironman92
Mauer
Pedroia
Rollins
You've got two more here. Jimmy Rollins in 2007 and Dustin Pedroia in 2008.
Mauer not only led his team in OBP and SLG during his MVP campaign, but the league as well. But he DIDN'T lead in HRs, and he DID have starters with fewer SOs. This was the best guess that isn't right.
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
18,909
posts
Joined
Nov 2009
O-Trap
Chief Shenanigans Officer
Mon, Apr 13, 2020 6:31 PM
posted by Laley23
Ichiro?
GOT IT! That was the last one. Ichiro won ROY, MVP, and Silver Slugger his first year, despite not leading his team in any of those metrics.