Archive

Tribe @ Reds (Series Thread)

  • SportsAndLady
    Votto is good...BP>Kipnis
  • wes_mantooth
    SportsAndLady;1197357 wrote:Votto is good...BP>Kipnis
    Votto is good, but you can gladly keep BP....I am def ok with that.
  • hoops23
    wes_mantooth;1197362 wrote:Votto is good, but you can gladly keep BP....I am def ok with that.
    #cosign
  • justincredible
    Back to the original argument of drafting Votto first, then Kipnis. I draft Votto first, then Cueto.
  • wes_mantooth
    justincredible;1197372 wrote:Back to the original argument of drafting Votto first, then Kipnis. I draft Votto first, then Cueto.
    I would draft Valdez 1st...even though I only watched the first 4 innings, he was obviously the best player on the field.
  • Footwedge
    Lonnie showing why it is clear that the tribe needs Hannahan back...the sooner the better.
  • Laley23
    justincredible;1197372 wrote:Back to the original argument of drafting Votto first, then Kipnis. I draft Votto first, then Cueto.
    Where is Cueto gonna play? Since you know, the stipulations excluded pitchers.
  • Rotinaj
    Rotinaj;1197353 wrote:Votttttttttooooooooo
    +1
  • justincredible
    Laley23;1197381 wrote:Where is Cueto gonna play? Since you know, the stipulations excluded pitchers.
    I DIDN'T SEE THAT PART LEAVE ME ALONE!

    Fine, I'll draft Votto twice.
  • wes_mantooth
    Does the tribe have their shitty relievers in since Acta always mails it in when they are down a few?
  • se-alum
    Footwedge;1197380 wrote:Lonnie showing why it is clear that the tribe needs Hannahan back...the sooner the better.
    Wasn't Chisenhall highly touted? Did he just not pan out?
  • Laley23
    This is where the Tribe has sucked all year. When they have to go to the 'Pen without a lead.

    Sipp and Accardo tonight. Smith, Pestano, Perez and Hagadone are the only 4 I trust. Perez and Pestano are only available with leads/ties and the other two are almost the same. We cant keep close games close when we are losing.
  • hoops23
    wes_mantooth;1197390 wrote:Does the tribe have their shitty relievers in since Acta always mails it in when they are down a few?
    As soon as Tony Sipp came in I knew it was over.
  • hoops23
    se-alum;1197397 wrote:Wasn't Chisenhall highly touted? Did he just not pan out?
    lol, he's still young. His defense still needs work but his bat has been "ok".. I think he'll be fine. He doesn't have much big league experience under his belt.

    Jack is just an awesome defensive 3B and was off to a good start with the bat.
  • Laley23
    se-alum;1197397 wrote:Wasn't Chisenhall highly touted? Did he just not pan out?
    He hasnt even been given a chance to not pan out. He got a call up last year and has been up for 3 weeks this year.

    He hasnt been good yet, and Hannahan is a GG fielder, who was hitting .297 this year. But, Chiz can still be good.

    And yes, he was highly touted. If I recall, behind Kipnis and Pomeranz in our system.
  • Rotinaj
    justincredible;1197387 wrote:I DIDN'T SEE THAT PART LEAVE ME ALONE!

    Fine, I'll draft Votto twice.
    But if you take Votto twice would you hit them back to back???? Remember the rule w lefties!!!
  • wes_mantooth
    se-alum;1197397 wrote:Wasn't Chisenhall highly touted? Did he just not pan out?
    Yeah he was....I honestly don't see it, he has never done anything that really makes you think he could be an all star or anything
  • hoops23
    wes_mantooth;1197411 wrote:Yeah he was....I honestly don't see it, he has never done anything that really makes you think he could be an all star or anything
    And this is true as well. He's had a couple of nice games, but he hasn't strung anything together. I don't see all star or anything in him, but he should be a solid 3B..

    He has a hole in his swing that needs fixed first.
  • wes_mantooth
    I am def concerned with getting swept with the pitching we have going in this bandbox. On a fun note, i will be staying in Cleveland Saturday night and watching two games against the Pirates. I plan on getting blackout drunk, so that should be fun.
  • se-alum
    hoops23;1197404 wrote:lol, he's still young. His defense still needs work but his bat has been "ok".. I think he'll be fine. He doesn't have much big league experience under his belt.

    Jack is just an awesome defensive 3B and was off to a good start with the bat.
    Are you always this defensive? I was simply asking a question that I honestly didn't know the answer to.
  • justincredible
    Rotinaj;1197408 wrote:But if you take Votto twice would you hit them back to back???? Remember the rule w lefties!!!
    No way. Gotta break him up.
  • justincredible
    se-alum;1197428 wrote:Are you always this defensive? I was simply asking a question that I honestly didn't know the answer to.
    I didn't really read it as defensive.
  • se-alum
    Rotinaj;1197408 wrote:But if you take Votto twice would you hit them back to back???? Remember the rule w lefties!!!
    No way, gotta put a righty between them, any righty, any righty will do.
  • Laley23
    se-alum;1197434 wrote:No way, gotta put a righty between them, any righty, any righty will do.
    Maybe Cueto??
  • Laley23
    In any event. Tomorrow should be fun. Tomlin will most assuredly serve up about 5 HRs in that park. So theres that.