posted by O-Trap

This sounds like a Jeter stat line, but I'm not sure you could say he aged quickly.

Robbie Alomar, maybe?

Also Jeter blew past/hit all those numbers except steals I think. 

But Robbie seems correct. Went from top-5 MVP in Cleveland to basically out of the league in a year and a half. He wasn’t the same player following Cleveland in 2001.

posted by O-Trap

This sounds like a Jeter stat line, but I'm not sure you could say he aged quickly.

Robbie Alomar, maybe?

Jeter got to those numbers though

Alomar it is....I left out the 10 gold gloves wouldn’t made obvious

Question #197

This former offensive stud had a huge season at age 31, yet another top 5 MVP....through age 31 he was only a few HR shy of 400, nearly 1300 RBI....he was destined for 575 or so HR and 1800-1900 RBI....and pushing near 3000 hits. He never got anywhere near any of those numbers and the sure fire HOFer dropped off pretty hard and career ended not many years later.

Name this non-HOFer

posted by Ironman92

Question #197

This former offensive stud had a huge season at age 31, yet another top 5 MVP....through age 31 he was only a few HR shy of 400, nearly 1300 RBI....he was destined for 575 or so HR and 1800-1900 RBI....and pushing near 3000 hits. He never got anywhere near any of those numbers and the sure fire HOFer dropped off pretty hard and career ended not many years later.

Name this non-HOFer

First though was Carlos Delgado, until the second part. Pretty sure he was never pushing 3000 hits

Shawn Green? Soriano?

Ryan Howard?

posted by Laley23

First though was Carlos Delgado, until the second part. Pretty sure he was never pushing 3000 hits

This guy didn’t either but would’ve had he played as long as most guess/expect

posted by Laley23

Shawn Green? Soriano?

Good guesses but no

posted by Laley23

Ryan Howard?

Never would’ve touched near 3000 or probably not 2409 but HR/RBI fits....but no

Justice? I can’t go back much further than early-mid 90s for guys that ended up not great. 

posted by Laley23

Justice? I can’t go back much further than early-mid 90s for guys that ended up not great. 

Nope.....started about same time as Justice

posted by Laley23

First though was Carlos Delgado, until the second part. Pretty sure he was never pushing 3000 hits

Delgado had 3 seasons 114+ rbi from age 33-36....he fell short a year maybe 2 of my expectations

The answer had over 125 HR at age 23

Dale Murphy

posted by Al Bundy

Dale Murphy

Nope but he did fall off quick right at 400.....

Answer started his career about the time Murphy fell off

Joe carter

Albert Belle

posted by Al Bundy

Joe carter

Nope but you are getting there

posted by Al Bundy

Albert Belle

Great guess....but no, virtually the same player and also not a real nice guy

posted by Al Bundy

Albert Belle

Belle started almost exactly same time as the answer but was a few years older. Belle had the huge age 31 year but played 2 more years and they were also big years

Juan Gonzalez

Juan Gone?

Juan Gone?

posted by Al Bundy

Juan Gonzalez

Yep