I guess a lot of mine were guys that were better than average but on the latter part of their career showed moments of greatness or excitement I enjoyed.

Mine: 

Baseball: Adam Dunn, Andrew Jones, Gary Sheffield, Rey Ordonez, Deion Sanders

Football: Michael Vick

Basketball: Chris Jackson (Mahmoud Abdul-Raul) Manute Bol, Mark Eaton

Sean Casey 

posted by justincredible

Sean Casey 

 

I’m a rare Reds fan that doesn’t miss him at all.

Travis Fryman, Asdrubal, Donyell Marshall, Drew Gooden, Kellen Winslow Jr.

I really liked watching the early 2000s Pistons that were chock full of slightly above average players.

NBA (not average, but never dominant stars):

• Mitch Richmond 
• Peja 
• Rik Smits
• Antonio Davis
• Allen Houston
• Cuttino Mobley
• Michael Redd
• Eddie Jones 

MLB:

• Fausto Carmona (well, his 1 season)
• Bobby Higginson
• Ron Gant
• Jhonny Peralta (I might be his single defender on here)
• Tim Salmon
• Vlad (obviously great, but there has NEVER been another baseball player I would watch a random game for. My favorite non-Indian ever) 

A bit above the average level for sure.

You names several I agree with for sure...I’ll add Jimmy Jackson

Tim Salmon? Nice career but kind of a yawn

Baseball: Chris Sabo,Ron Oester,Rob Dibble,Norm Charlton,Randy Myers,Paul Sorrento,Toby Harrah,Buddy Bell,Paul Assenmacher,Charlie Nagy

Basketball: Sidney Moncrief,Dick Snyder,Campy Russell,Jim Brewer,Jim Chones.

Football: Dave Logan,Gary Collins,Steve Grogan,Hanford Dixon,Frank Minnifield

NBA

Vinnie Johnson

Young Shawn Kemp

posted by cat_lover

Basketball: Dick Snyder,Campy Russell,Jim Brewer,Jim Chones. 

Football: Dave Logan,Gary Collins,Hanford Dixon,Frank Minnifield

I'm gonna leave your baseball alone for now. 

I took out a name from each of your other categories. 

And say to you: outstanding picks!

https://youtu.be/qXGRNGWNk0I

This dude had Tourette’s and his story pretty incredible if you ever get a chance to read his story

https://youtu.be/OARoyYN3Ce0

I’ll add Bobby Phils to the basketball list

posted by Ironman92

Tim Salmon? Nice career but kind of a yawn

First rookie card I ever owned. Lol

posted by Laley23

First rookie card I ever owned. Lol

Lol, had a lot of those

Scoonie Penn. 

Aaron Harang

posted by cat_lover

Baseball: Chris Sabo,Ron Oester,Rob Dibble,Norm Charlton,Randy Myers,Paul Sorrento,Toby Harrah,Buddy Bell,Paul Assenmacher,Charlie Nagy

Basketball: Sidney Moncrief,Dick Snyder,Campy Russell,Jim Brewer,Jim Chones.

Football: Dave Logan,Gary Collins,Steve Grogan,Hanford Dixon,Frank Minnifield

Love me some Dave Logan. One of only three players to be drafted by the NBA, MLB & NFL.

NBA: Glenn Rice, Daniel Gibson, Larry Sanders, AV

MLB: Albert Belle

NFL: Aaron Shea, Andra Davis, Kernard Lang, Leigh Bodden, Lee Suggs, Jerome Harrison, Peyton Hillis, Kevin Johnson

Wayne Chrebet

Brad Smith, Leon Washington, Jerricho Cotchery

posted by justincredible

Sean Casey 

 

Human rain delay.

posted by Commander of Awesome

NBA: Glenn Rice, Daniel Gibson, Larry Sanders, AV

MLB: Albert Belle

NFL: Aaron Shea, Andra Davis, Kernard Lang, Leigh Bodden, Lee Suggs, Jerome Harrison, Peyton Hillis, Kevin Johnson

Belle was a stud though

Bernie kosar.   Even tho I hated the browns it was fun watching him.

Levon Kirkland.

Bobby Phills

NFL: Bernie Kosar (last good QB the Browns had and, yes...he was average)

NBA: World B Free (above average but that rainbow jumper)...all-time favorite Cav

MLB: Lenny Barker (actually named a Beagle after him)

posted by Ironman92

Belle was a stud though

Fine, give me Bob Wickman, Pronk!, and Grady Sizemore then.