Archive

Peyton is not the GOAT

  • mtp2013
    Until he can win in cold weather, Brady is better. I hate the Patriots, but that's the honest truth.
  • thavoice
    Footwedge;1577605 wrote:Peyton is the GOAT in my book.
    and your book can be found in the fiction section of the library....
  • dwccrew
    ccrunner609;1573632 wrote:no Dan Marino is the greatest regular season QB
    How? Peyton has almost all regular season records.
    lhslep134;1573668 wrote:Don't know where I stand on Brady/Manning because I have no idea how much value to attribute to Bellicheck.

    It's even more than what he did with Cassel, I mean there are quarterbacks he's had on his roster who go on to better things elsewhere and in no small part because of the value of what they gleaned from BB (like Hoyer). Dude takes his QB's seriously, there's a reason there's a market for his backups, and proof of how terrible Tebow is if not even BB wants him.

    That to me is amazing: teams that wait/save a roster spot or two for when BB makes his week 3 and week 4 cuts in the preseason.

    So that also shows you how much I think of Brady if I think that highly of BB and still don't place Peyton ahead.
    I think one thing that hasn't been addressed and doesn't get as much attention as it should is Spygate and the effect it had on the Pats winning.
    Tiernan;1575986 wrote:Montana, Brady, Elway, Starr, Bradshaw, Aikman, Kelly...then MAYBE Peyton.
    Tiernan;1576128 wrote:But I digress...the discussion was QBs and because they were WINNERS both Unitas and Namath are ahead of Marino. Stats are stats, they look good on paper but I've never seen a stat sheet hanging in a trophy case. You gotta put hardware behind the glass before you are truly one of the immortals.
    Just stop. You contradict yourself in all your posts. I'm not sure if you're just trolling or if you really believe the crap you are posting. If it's the latter, god have mercy on your soul.
  • thavoice
    dwccrew;1578884 wrote:How? Peyton has almost all regular season records.



    I think one thing that hasn't been addressed and doesn't get as much attention as it should is Spygate and the effect it had on the Pats winning.






    Just stop. You contradict yourself in all your posts. I'm not sure if you're just trolling or if you really believe the crap you are posting. If it's the latter, god have mercy on your soul.
    That is brought up at times by some people, and the more and more I think of it the more validity I give to it.

    Especially after the SB when the Seahawks caught on to some of the hand signals and calls PM made at the LOS. Now, it is one thing to know what is coming, and another thing to stop it and Seattle had the personnel to do so.

    I still dont think it had much to do with it though. I think it has more to do with just how difficult it is to win it all in the NFL. Hell, look what Billycheck and TB did this year with those stiffs at WR/TE they had.