Peyton is not the GOAT

• GOONx19

  

  ernest_t_bass;1573310 wrote:If Justin Verlander were a QB, he'd easily be #1. Have you seen his arm? Incredible.

  Missing Don Kelly.
• Heretic

  

  ccrunner609;1573328 wrote:no reps will be given

  I neg rep'd you over $20. Again. A process that likely will continue until you're back to being in the red.
• thavoice

  Heretic;1573414 wrote:I neg rep'd you over $20. Again. A process that likely will continue until you're back to being in the red.

  Just put him on a payment program.
  Dollar a year for 20 years, or until the browns win the SB, whichever comes first.
• Lovejoy1984

  

  Wondered how this thread had so many posts....now I know.
  
  Peyton is greatest Regular Season QB in history.
• DeadliestWarrior34

  

  Hoping this thread would be about Peyton Hillis.
• pmoney25

  

  I agree. Brady >Manning
• lhslep134

  

  Don't know where I stand on Brady/Manning because I have no idea how much value to attribute to Bellicheck.
  
  It's even more than what he did with Cassel, I mean there are quarterbacks he's had on his roster who go on to better things elsewhere and in no small part because of the value of what they gleaned from BB (like Hoyer). Dude takes his QB's seriously, there's a reason there's a market for his backups, and proof of how terrible Tebow is if not even BB wants him.
  
  That to me is amazing: teams that wait/save a roster spot or two for when BB makes his week 3 and week 4 cuts in the preseason.
  
  So that also shows you how much I think of Brady if I think that highly of BB and still don't place Peyton ahead.
• Lovejoy1984

  

  ccrunner609;1573632 wrote:no Dan Marino is the greatest regular season QB

  Wanna put $20 on it?
• Classyposter58

  

  Anyone wanna debate this now? I love what Colin Cowherd said, his constant adjustments at the line causes his teams to be overly tight in big games. He tries to do too much and it cost them
• ernest_t_bass

  

  Classyposter58;1575791 wrote:Anyone wanna debate this now? I love what Colin Cowherd said, his constant adjustments at the line causes his teams to be overly tight in big games. He tries to do too much and it cost them

  Jesus, how do you pin that lop sided loss on one man?
• Automatik

  

  Because stupid...
• like_that

  

  ernest_t_bass;1575802 wrote:Jesus, how do you pin that lop sided loss on one man?

  STOP. Stafford is obviously the greatest QB in NFL history. His 2 career wins over teams with an above .500 record says so.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  like_that;1575811 wrote:STOP. Stafford is obviously the greatest QB in NFL history. His 2 career wins over teams with an above .500 record says so.

  Incredible talent.
• sleeper

  

  Classyposter58;1575791 wrote:Anyone wanna debate this now? I love what Colin Cowherd said, his constant adjustments at the line causes his teams to be overly tight in big games. He tries to do too much and it cost them

  Swap Peyton and Russel and the Broncos still get blown out.
• Tiernan

  Swap Peyton for Montana and the Broncos still get blown out.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  Tiernan;1575837 wrote:Swap Peyton for Montana and the Broncos still get blown out.

  Swap Russel with Tiernan, and the Seahawks QB gets pulled over for a DUI on the way home.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  Tiernan;1575837 wrote:Swap Peyton for Montana and the Broncos still get blown out.

  
• thavoice

  Classyposter58;1575791 wrote:Anyone wanna debate this now? I love what Colin Cowherd said, his constant adjustments at the line causes his teams to be overly tight in big games. He tries to do too much and it cost them

  I dont know about that. It kinda looked like he made less adjustments on the fly yesterday.
• queencitybuckeye

  Classyposter58;1575791 wrote:Anyone wanna debate this now? I love what Colin Cowherd said, his constant adjustments at the line causes his teams to be overly tight in big games. He tries to do too much and it cost them

  Was last week not a big game? The week before that? Teams are supposed to completely change what they do all season for a "big game"?
  
  Cowherd gets paid very well to offer outside the box opinions. They don't need to make sense. This one does not.
• Tiernan

  Swap Peyton for ETB and Peyton becomes the middle school teacher making <$40K / yr.
  
  
  ...and then he kills himself.
• Classyposter58

  

  I just don't think the GOAT with incredible offensive weapons should be shut down like that. I know it was lopsided but it didn't have to be that bad
• ernest_t_bass

  

  Classyposter58;1575853 wrote:I just don't think the GOAT with incredible offensive weapons should be shut down like that. I know it was lopsided but it didn't have to be that bad

  The O-Line was TERRIBLE.
• thavoice

  I wouldnt say it was terrible, but it didnt play very good at all.
  It wasnt anything fancy either on Seattle's part. Didnt seem to be exotic blitzes, or overloading a side, or those "amoeba" style you see at times when everyone is standing up at the line and you dont know who is coming. The exotic and overloading blitzes he picks up pretty good and audibles the protection.
  
  This was just simply the DL beating their guy one on one. Hats off to seattle. They did what I didnt think they could do and that is totally throttle that offense.
  

  ernest_t_bass;1575855 wrote:The O-Line was TERRIBLE.

• lhslep134

  

  I agree thavoice
• Rotinaj

  

  Montana is the GOAT and Manning is top 5. Sure does suck to be him!