"ALL-NFL" Mock Draft?

• Sonofanump

  NNN wrote:

  Sonofanump wrote: I'll draft on who has best ability not who had the best supporting cast?

  Bradshaw would be there far ahead of Aikman and especially Theismann, so your comment is intriguing.
  
  You also failed to list any of the pre-1955 QBs, who certainly had to have a great deal of overall ability. Consider that Benny Friedman, Sammy Baugh, Arnie Herber, and Cecil Isbell all played with a ball that looked more like a watermelon than a football. All also had to play both sides of the ball, as did Sid Luckman and (in the AAFC) Otto Graham.

  Baugh, Luckman and Bradshaw in that order were the last one's I cut on my list.
• KnightRyder

  

  Sonofanump wrote:

  KnightRyder wrote:

  Sonofanump wrote: How many teams? If I had a top 4 pick, I would go QB. I am sure you could come up with a lot more premier running backs.
  
  Young- Let's find him a helmet that prevents concussions
  Manning
  Elway
  Marino
  
  Next five maybe late in the first round
  Unitas
  Moon
  Favre
  Warner
  Kelly
  
  The middle of the road guys
  Tarkenton
  Staubach
  Fouts
  Brady
  Mcnabb
  Starr
  Theisman
  Dawson
  Aikman
  Simms

  those guys are all good, but i find it odd that terry bradshaw is no where on that list

  I'll draft on who has best ability not who had the best supporting cast?

  did bradshaw have a good supporting cast? yes , but how good were they? when bradshaw was injured or left a game due to injury, the chances of beating the steelers went up dramatically. people act like any qb could have succeeded with that cast. i'm not buying that. i seen bradhsaws back up come in a do nothing with the same cast of players.
• Sonofanump

  IMHO Bradshaw was the 21th best QB to start a team with. I'll take 20 QBs ahead of him.
• justincredible

  

  Mangold