Similar Plays...2 different Calls...A Super Bowl and National Title was Decided

• Footwedge

  Of course I am talking about yesterday's 4th down play in the end zone and the PI on the Krenzel to Gamble pass on 4th down.
  
  In slow mo...they are both infractions. In game time speed, both can be left go.
  
  It;s amazing how simiklat those 2 plays were.
• Sonofanump

  No.
• bases_loaded

  

  In slow mo and live both are penalties.
• Footwedge

  Typo in title....."were". There...otherwise my thread would end up in the HOF.
• Footwedge

  :thumbdown:

  Sonofanump;1381638 wrote:No.

  No what? This should be good.
• Commander of Awesome

  

  IPOTW
  
  Congrats, this award hasn't been given out in quite some time.
  
  (Also in contention for ITOTW)
• Pick6

  

  NOTHING TO SEE HERE
  [video=youtube_share;5-C8NZU-EqI][/video]
  
  OR HERE
  [video=youtube_share;Gu4cu10-rhk][/video]
  
  What a fucking joke. And I didnt give a shit who won the game.
• GoChiefs

  

  Commander of Awesome;1381652 wrote:(Also in contention for ITOTW)

  
  http://www.ohiochatter.com/forum/showthread.php?39123-Florida-Ravens
• sleeper

  

  The OL was told to hold. The worst that happens is a safety anyway.
• sleeper

  

  And sorry, but calls are missed in every game. Maybe the 49ers shouldn't have played like shit in the 1st half and let freaking Jacoby "can't hack it in Texas" Jones run it back on them.
• Pick6

  

  sleeper;1381664 wrote:The OL was told to hold. The worst that happens is a safety anyway.

  So a ref shouldnt ref because the OL was told by his coach. GTFO. Also, it did make a difference. It allowed at least 4 extra seconds to run of the clock because nobody could get to the punter.
• sleeper

  

  Pick6;1381668 wrote:So a ref shouldnt ref because the OL was told by his coach. GTFO. Also, it did make a difference. It allowed at least 4 extra seconds to run of the clock because nobody could get to the punter.

  The ref should ref, but I'm saying it had no impact on the game. If they call holding, it only benefits the Ravens.
• lhslep134

  

  Pick6;1381668 wrote:Also, it did make a difference. It allowed at least 4 extra seconds to run of the clock because nobody could get to the punter.

  Actually no it didn't.
  
  Let's analyze...
  
  No holding penalty: 8 seconds run off the clock, result of the play is a safety
  Holding penalty is called: 8 seconds run off the clock, result of the play is a safety.
  
  There WAS holding, but it didn't matter if it got called or not because the clock wouldn't have stopped.
• Tiernan

  Nothing similar about those two calls. One was for a team that deserved to win the other was for a bunch of miscreants that should be exterminated from the human race.
• Pick6

  

  lhslep134;1381688 wrote:Actually no it didn't.
  
  Let's analyze...
  
  No holding penalty: 8 seconds run off the clock, result of the play is a safety
  Holding penalty is called: 8 seconds run off the clock, result of the play is a safety.
  
  There WAS holding, but it didn't matter if it got called or not because the clock wouldn't have stopped.

  You're right. Not sure what I was thinking, because they were obviously instructed to hold. Still doesnt change the fact it couldnt have been more obvious and should have been called.
• hasbeen

  

  Tiernan;1381690 wrote:Nothing similar about those two calls. One was for a team that deserved to win the other was for a bunch of miscreants that should be exterminated from the human race.

  
  Just sucks that the miscreants won and the deserving lost.
• Sonofanump

  Pick6;1381668 wrote:So a ref shouldnt ref because the OL was told by his coach. GTFO. Also, it did make a difference. It allowed at least 4 extra seconds to run of the clock because nobody could get to the punter.

  I was unaware that holding stops the clock. Tell me moar!
• Sonofanump

  Footwedge;1381647 wrote::thumbdown:
  
  No what? This should be good.

  No.
• Pick6

  

  Sonofanump;1381726 wrote:I was unaware that holding stops the clock. Tell me moar!

  I knew it didnt stop the clock. Keep defending the shoddy ref job, though. Looks good.
• Sonofanump

  Pick6;1381730 wrote:I knew it didnt stop the clock. Keep defending the shoddy ref job, though. Looks good.

  So do you know the difference between holding in the end zone and stepping out of the endzone?
• Pick6

  

  Sonofanump;1381733 wrote:So do you know the difference between holding in the end zone and stepping out of the endzone?

  Yeah. Keep avoiding the fact that the referees literally quit doing their job and that a player shoved a ref and nothing was done about it please.
• Sonofanump

  Pick6;1381738 wrote:Yeah. Keep avoiding the fact that the referees literally quit doing their job and that a player shoved a ref and nothing was done about it please.

  Excellent.
• Pick6

  

  Sonofanump;1381740 wrote:Excellent.

  Thought so.
• Footwedge

  Sonofanump;1381729 wrote:No.

  I figured.
• Sonofanump

  Pick6;1381742 wrote:Thought so.

  Good job. Glad to help.