Ohio Chatter DEV

Skyhook79

http://www.nba.com/2011/news/05/09/2010-11-all-defensive-teams/index.html?ls=iref:nbahpt2

Kobe and Garnett tie the record with 9 times on the 1st Team. Only NBA Head coaches vote on this, and you can't vote for your own players, so its quite an honor.

karen lotz

Can't wait to see him "locking someone down" in the WCF.

SportsAndLady

"so its quite an honor."

Lol, right..

GOONx19

I can't remember who it was that tried to tell me Russell Westbrook was a better defender than Rondo, but Rondo is without question one of the top 3 all-around point guards in the league. This is the second straight year he had the second highest vote count.

Pick6

Rondo and Paul are the top 2 defending PGs IMO

GOONx19

Nevermind, found the thread.

hoops23;738857 wrote:The only PG who is right there with Westbrook is Rose.

Rose is the main guy on his team, but he doesn't have a Durant on his team either. Westbrook lead OKC while Durant was injured earlier in the year and he's a more complete PG than Rose.

He's the best defensive PG, best rebounding PG, he's just as good of a scorer as Rose and he's a bit better at getting his team involved.

GOONx19;738997 wrote:I would argue that Rondo is better defensively and as a rebounder. He's second in the league in steals, can guard a much wider range of players, and averages 11.4% of Boston's rebounds, to Westbrook's 10.7%. He's also a much better passer.

hoops23;739846 wrote:No, just no.

Sorry, Rondo is not in the discussion. It's Rose and Westbrook vs everybody else..

Rondo is a very good defender and rebounder, but he's not better than Westbrook.

GOONx19;739906 wrote:How can you say he's not in the discussion? I agree Rose is best. But Rondo is without a doubt a better defensive player than Westbrook. TWENTY-THREE of the the head coaches in the NBA voted him as the best defensive guard in the league last year, and four voted him to second team. Westbrook only got three second place votes, zero first.

sleeper;740039 wrote:LOL what? I'm not a Celtics fan, but Rondo is easily in the discussion behind Rose right now. Westbrook is a great player and top 5, but I don't even have him above CP3 or DW. He's 5th.

dat dude

GOONx19;763601 wrote:Nevermind, found the thread.

lol

DeyDurkie5

lol boom hoops

SportsAndLady

Wow hoops..that's embarrassing

Hb31187

Kobe is on the 1st team?

Common man, its not a lifetime achievement award

Skyhook79

Hb31187;763843 wrote:Carmelo's not on the team again?

Fixed for you.

thedynasty1998

GOONx19;763591 wrote:I can't remember who it was that tried to tell me Russell Westbrook was a better defender than Rondo, but Rondo is without question one of the top 3 all-around point guards in the league. This is the second straight year he had the second highest vote count.

Rondo is a good player and an elite PG, but he's not a top 3 PG. He has been a liability on offense for the Celtics, and yes prior to the injury.

I will say Rondo is the best PG for the current Boston team, but he's not top 3 overall.

lhslep134

GOONx19;763591 wrote:Rondo is without question one of the top 3 all-around point guards in the league.

You're seriously an IDIOT if you think that it's unquestionable that Rondo is a top 3 PG. Get those Blue and White glasses off. At least acknowledge it's questionable, which is very much so is.

1. CP3 (doesn't need explained, but he proved it against Lakers)
2. D-Will (2nd team all NBA last year, didn't get worse)
3. Rose (league MVP)

And I'd argue Westbrook is a better overall player due to his offensive ability than Rondo. It's not like Westbrook can't guard or rebound, but it is true that Rondo can't score from beyond 13 feet.

Skyhook79

lhslep134;763932 wrote:You're seriously an IDIOT if you think that it's UNQUESTIONABLE that Rondo is a top 3 PG.

1. CP3 (proved it against Lakers)
2. D-Will
3. Rose (league MVP)

And I'd argue Westbrook is a better overall player due to his offensive ability than Rondo. It's not like Westbrook can't guard or rebound, but it is true that Rondo can't score from beyond 13 feet.

I wouldn't use the Lakers as a your #1 point. JJ Barea abused the Laker guards. Also the keywords are "all around" pg. Rondo is near the top when you take everything into consideration.

Laley23

You can be the best all around player at something without being the best. Jack of all trades, master of none (though Rondo is a master of D and reb, and passing).

lhslep134

Laley23;763944 wrote:You can be the best all around player at something without being the best. Jack of all trades, master of none (though Rondo is a master of D and reb, and passing).

He's not a jack of scoring. He's a very below average scorer. In a competition judging all around talent, I'm sorry, but the inability to score eliminates Rondo.

lhslep134

Skyhook79;763938 wrote:I wouldn't use the Lakers as a your #1 point. JJ Barea abused the Laker guards.

JJ Barea had Dirk Nowitzki and Jason Terry as scoring options. Hornets had who? Paul had to single handedly keep them in the series and he did. If you're trying to discredit Paul's dominance against the Lakers you're insane.

lhslep134

Skyhook79;763938 wrote:Also the keywords are "all around" pg. Rondo is near the top when you take everything into consideration.

Also my point was that it's not unquestionable that Rondo is top 3. Some people might have him there, I don't, because he can't score.

Also, give me reasons why Rondo is better than Cp3, D-Will, or Rose? It's easy to just discredit what I say, let's see you back up why Rondo is a top 3 overall PG (I'm looking at you Goon).

Commander of Awesome

lhslep134;763932 wrote:You're seriously an IDIOT if you think that it's unquestionable that Rondo is a top 3 PG. Get those Blue and White glasses off.

1. CP3 (proved it against Lakers)
2. D-Will (2nd team all NBA last year, didn't get worse)
3. Rose (league MVP)

And I'd argue Westbrook is a better overall player due to his offensive ability than Rondo. It's not like Westbrook can't guard or rebound, but it is true that Rondo can't score from beyond 13 feet.

Wow shocker, frodo134being an arrogant pompous jerk.

lhslep134

http://www.thesportspundits.com/2011/04/nba-top-5-point-guards.html

Very objective analysis, and uhm, Rondo isn't top 3.

http://basketball.realgm.com/src_playerrankings.php?season=2010-2011&filter=pg&highlight=

When floor impact counter is adjusted for 40 minutes, Rondo goes from #4 to #5.

lhslep134

http://basketball.realgm.com/src_playerrankings.php?season=2010-2011&filter=pg&highlight=

When floor impact counter is adjusted for 40 minutes, Rondo goes from #4 to #5.

september63

These are usually based "more" on career than single season. I dont see how Garnett is on this first team.

Laley23

lhslep134;763951 wrote:Also my point was that it's not unquestionable that Rondo is top 3. Some people might have him there, I don't, because he can't score.

Also, give me reasons why Rondo is better than Cp3, D-Will, or Rose? It's easy to just discredit what I say, let's see you back up why Rondo is a top 3 overall PG (I'm looking at you Goon).

He isnt better. But I think he is the more well rounded PG. If you put them all in a skills competition, and defense, rebounding, passing, and scoring were all judged. Rondo would probably come out on top.

Again, that doesnt make him the best. He is not a better player than some others, because scoring is more valuable than some other things out of a PG. But he can easily be considered the most well rounded PG.

lhslep134

Laley23;763998 wrote: But he can easily be considered the most well rounded PG.

How??? He can't score. That is a crucial element to being well rounded: scoring, passing, rebounding, defense. If someone doesn't have one of those attributes how can you say he's the all around best?

If this was a who is the best rebounding, passing, and defensive point guard, it's Rondo by a significant margin. But scoring ability is more crucial out of a PG than rebounding or defense, because there's always bigs to help rebound or play help defense.

IF Rondo could actually score, I think Boston would be almost unbeatable and they'd be up 3-1 on Miami instead of down. But when you can basically leave Rondo by himself outside of 13 feet, in a playoff game, because he can't hurt you from there, that's frigging pathetic.

GOONx19

lhslep134;763951 wrote:Also my point was that it's not unquestionable that Rondo is top 3. Some people might have him there, I don't, because he can't score.

Also, give me reasons why Rondo is better than Cp3, D-Will, or Rose? It's easy to just discredit what I say, let's see you back up why Rondo is a top 3 overall PG (I'm looking at you Goon).

People have already explained why he's a great ALL-AROUND point guard. It wasn't meant to imply he was top 3 OVERALL, though he very well may be. It's not always a point guard's job to score.

Anyway, to answer your question, Rondo is not better than Derrick Rose or Chris Paul.

But Rondo is better than Deron Williams because among point guards:

Williams is 3rd in assists, to Rondo's 2nd.
Williams is 10th in rebounds, to Rondo's 5th.
Williams is 13th in steals, to Rondo's 2nd.
Williams is 3rd worst in turnovers, to Rondo's 5th.
Williams is 17th in FG%, to Rondo's 6th.

The two things Williams are better at are 3 point percentage and scoring. Williams averages 9 points more per game, but shoots 5 more shots per game, including 4 more threes.

Archive

NBA All defensive Team announced