NFL MVP

• 2kool4skool

  

  Two questions:
  
  Who is your vote for?
  and
  Who do you think will actually win?
• Cleveland Buck

  

  Ahtyba Rubin. No one gets blown off the ball as well as he does.
• Rotinaj

  

  Either Vick or Brady wins. I'm gonna go with Brady.
• ptown_trojans_1

  

  Brady, no question.
• BigAppleBuckeye

  

  Brady, but Vick is certainly closing the gap. Huge game for him today in a crucial divisional game.
• Iliketurtles

  

  Brady. I feel that Rivers, Vick, and Foster are up there as well.
• lhslep134

  

  ptown_trojans_1;606891 wrote:Brady, no question.

  
  Can't say it's "no question" between Brady and Vick, especially after today. Vick single handedly brought them back from the jaws of defeat.
• Hb31187

  

  If Brady struggles tonight, after that show Vick just put on....its gonna be very close.
• Skyhook79

  

  lhslep134;606949 wrote:Can't say it's "no question" between Brady and Vick, especially after today. Vick single handedly brought them back from the jaws of defeat.

  
  
  He was a major factor but he didn't do it single handedly. The onside kick and Jackson's punt return, Vick wasn't involved at all, and those were the 2 most important plays of the game.
• ZombieKiller

  Peyton Hillis
• End of Line

  

  Vick but, Brady will win it.
• bigdaddy2003

  

  Thomas Brady.
• GoChiefs

  

  Vick, although, it's glad to see ZombieKiller come around finally.
• thedynasty1998

  

  Didn't think anyone would even join the discussion with Brady, but Vick certainly threw his name in there with his play yesterday. It's still Brady's, but at least the voters have someone else to consider now.
  
  Brady has been incredible! And I hate the argument about switching teams and predicting results, but I can't imagine Brady with Macklin and Jackson. Although neither would really fit what New England is doing this year.
• Raw Dawgin' it

  

  thedynasty1998;607983 wrote:Didn't think anyone would even join the discussion with Brady, but Vick certainly threw his name in there with his play yesterday. It's still Brady's, but at least the voters have someone else to consider now.
  
  Brady has been incredible! And I hate the argument about switching teams and predicting results, but I can't imagine Brady with Macklin and Jackson. Although neither would really fit what New England is doing this year.

  
  Brady would destroy teams with those two...when randy moss was sane he threw 50tds...tom brady MVP and add his 4th ring this year while you're at it
• Nate

  My vote would go to Vick but Brady is doing excellent also and I wouldn't be upset if he won it either and I hate the man.
• hoops23

  

  It's a 2 man race between Vick and Brady. Right now, I'd lean towards Vick.
• Leonardo

  

  Tom Brady
• Con_Alma

  Brady might be playing the best football of his professional career right now and he's playing better than anyone else. I would vote for him.
• jordo212000

  

  Vick
  
  But I'd have no issue with Brady winning either.
• lhslep134

  

  Skyhook79;607124 wrote:He was a major factor but he didn't do it single handedly. The onside kick and Jackson's punt return, Vick wasn't involved at all, and those were the 2 most important plays of the game.

  
  Jackson's punt return didn't bring them back from the jaws of defeat, the game was tied. Even if the Giants win in overtime you can make the case for Vick for MVP from everything transpired before the punt.
  
  The onside kick helped, but without Vick they don't score the touchdown before it or the 2 touchdowns afterwards. Yesterday was an MVP type performance. Is he the MVP? No, but I just think its absurd to say it's undoubtedly Brady's.
• september63

  

  Tom Brady. The fact that Vick has multiple athletic playmakers to throw to, while Brady doesnt should be considered as well.
• like_that

  

  Vick is def my fantasy football MVP.
• Skyhook79

  

  lhslep134;608171 wrote:Jackson's punt return didn't bring them back from the jaws of defeat, the game was tied. Even if the Giants win in overtime you can make the case for Vick for MVP from everything transpired before the punt.
  
  The onside kick helped, but without Vick they don't score the touchdown before it or the 2 touchdowns afterwards. Yesterday was an MVP type performance. Is he the MVP? No, but I just think its absurd to say it's undoubtedly Brady's.

  
  
  
  Without the punt return there was a chance the Eagles lose the game. Without the onside kick there are not 2 TD's after wards.
  Vick is the Comeback player of the Year and Brady is the MVP and is undoubtedly.
• OhioStatePride2003

  Brady and Vick are both very deserving of the award, but my vote would go to Vick. I personally don't think that Philly is even in the playoff discussion of Kolb started every game for the Eagles this year. What Michael Vick has done this year is remarkable. Imagine if the Eagles go on to win the Super Bowl this year - that's the kind of stuff people make movies out of. I honestly think (as long as there's no major collapse on Vick's part) that it's Vick's to lose. Brady is certainly deserving though, and while I can't stand the Ugg wearin' princess, I wouldn't be upset if he was awarded the MVP over Vick. The show that Vick put on against the Giants is something that diehard NFL fans will tell their grandsons about 30-40 years from now. Never have I seen anything like what Vick did against New York - simply amazing.