NFL MVP

• lhslep134

  

  Skyhook79;608228 wrote:Without the punt return there was a chance the Eagles lose the game. .

  
  Pretty sure I addressed this in my post. Re-read.
• Raw Dawgin' it

  

  OhioStatePride2003;608861 wrote:Brady and Vick are both very deserving of the award, but my vote would go to Vick. I personally don't think that Philly is even in the playoff discussion of Kolb started every game for the Eagles this year. What Michael Vick has done this year is remarkable. Imagine if the Eagles go on to win the Super Bowl this year - that's the kind of stuff people make movies out of. I honestly think (as long as there's no major collapse on Vick's part) that it's Vick's to lose. Brady is certainly deserving though, and while I can't stand the Ugg wearin' princess, I wouldn't be upset if he was awarded the MVP over Vick. The show that Vick put on against the Giants is something that diehard NFL fans will tell their grandsons about 30-40 years from now. Never have I seen anything like what Vick did against New York - simply amazing.

  His performance against washington was better.
  
  Also, the NFL won't give him the mvp. Anytime he's brought up people think dog beater. Brady is the top QB in the league. Just add MVP and 2010/2011 Super Bowl Champion to his list of accomplishments this year.
• Commander of Awesome

  

  Raw Dawgin' it;609964 wrote:Also, the NFL won't give him the mvp. Anytime he's brought up people think dog beater.

  
  This is a good point, I know I think of his crime everytime I see him. Its between Brady and Rivers IMO.
• Ironman92

  

  Joan?
• Raw Dawgin' it

  

  I don't think Rivers will get MVP honors if they miss the playoffs
• OhioStatePride2003

  Raw Dawgin' it;609964 wrote:His performance against washington was better.
  
  Also, the NFL won't give him the mvp. Anytime he's brought up people think dog beater. Brady is the top QB in the league. Just add MVP and 2010/2011 Super Bowl Champion to his list of accomplishments this year.

  
  I agree, but the NFL took a huge step by even letting him back into the league. I don't think the public's perception of Vick is going to change whether he's the MVP or not. Both are deserving, but I think Vick is slightly ahead but that's just this guy's opinion.
  
  Rivers is one of my favorite players in the league. You take Rivers off that team, and San Diego is probably winless on the season. He's put up insane numbers without anyone to really throw to until Jackson returned. But without San Diego in the Chargers, there's no way Rivers wins.
• j_crazy

  

  Raw Dawgin' it;610135 wrote:I don't think Rivers will get MVP honors if they miss the playoffs

  
  he shouldn't even if they do. it's not like they play in a tough division. one good qb can win that division as we've seen year in and year out with rivers. hopefully the chiefs can pull it off so i don't have to put up with the norv turner blumpkin parade that goes on every year when they make the playoffs.
• queencitybuckeye

  Brady will win, and it won't be close.
• Manhattan Buckeye

  j_crazy;610327 wrote:he shouldn't even if they do. it's not like they play in a tough division. one good qb can win that division as we've seen year in and year out with rivers. hopefully the chiefs can pull it off so i don't have to put up with the norv turner blumpkin parade that goes on every year when they make the playoffs.

  
  Disagree, having Rivers on my fantasy team I was forced to track his performance - it is nothing short of shocking how well he's played with all of the injuries they have had and has the team in shape to make the playoffs - and the Chargers lost one game (against the Seahawks) due to special teams incompetence.
  
  I'm not the biggest Rivers fan, he's a bit too arrogant IMO, but what he's done this year is nothing short of outstanding. How one can lose Floyd, V-Jax, Gates, and Matthews for that many games and still produce and keep the team in competition is impressive.
• Laley23

  

  OhioStatePride2003;610297 wrote: Rivers is one of my favorite players in the league. You take Rivers off that team, and San Diego is probably winless on the season.

  
  That is true of a ton of QBs in the league though: Manning, Rivers, Cassell, Brady....
  
  Ironically, Vick is a guy who you CANT make the argument for based on how well Kolb played with that team when he was in.
• purple_rein

  Brady at this point.