Indians @ Reds--Game 3--2:30 first pitch

• Laley23

  

  SportsAndLady;403273 wrote:Chase Utley, though not having his greatest year, is still better than Choo.
  
  .276
  11
  37

  
  I honestly didnt think he hit 2nd. However, Choo this year and last has comparable stats, I would still consider Utley better though. Utley and Pedroia.
• SportsAndLady

  

  Laley23;403280 wrote:Yes, but the argument can easily still be made for Choo

  
  I am not denying Choo's ability. He is a very good player.
• Laley23

  

  SportsAndLady;403271 wrote:Gaby Sanchez:
  .302
  8
  34

  
  No.
• Laley23

  

  SportsAndLady;403269 wrote:Billy Butler:
  .322
  7
  38

  Id take Choo still, but Butler doesnt hit in the 2 hole. At least not that I am aware of.
• SportsAndLady

  

  Laley23;403284 wrote:I honestly didnt think he hit 2nd. However, Choo this year and last has comparable stats, I would still consider Utley better though. Utley and Pedroia.

  
  He might not. I just looked at today's lineup and he was batting 2nd.
• SportsAndLady

  

  Laley23;403286 wrote:No.

  
  Why not? He is a highly touted prospect, and like Santana, has been MVP of a league (AA).
• Laley23

  

  SportsAndLady;403289 wrote:He might not. I just looked at today's lineup and he was batting 2nd.

  
  Just looked it up. He started hitting in the 2 hole 12 days ago, lol. I guess when your team sucks on offense you shift shit around.
• SportsAndLady

  

  Laley23;403288 wrote:Id take Choo still, but Butler doesnt hit in the 2 hole. At least not that I am aware of.

  
  You're right, he doesn't. I don't know why I thought he did.
  
  If he did though, he would have an argument.
• Laley23

  

  SportsAndLady;403290 wrote:Why not? He is a highly touted prospect, and like Santana, has been MVP of a league (AA).

  
  For the same reason I wouldnt say Santana is a top 3 catcher right now (not enough ABs. I usually like 500 before I make a solid opinion on someone). If at the end of the year the numbers are still there, then sure.
• Ironman92

  

  reverse posting worked again
• Footwedge

  wes_mantooth;403239 wrote:I think he is the only option the Tribe has to be an all star...no one else other than Talbot is doing anything what so ever.

  
  But only because crappy teams get a token picked. It's hard for me to label this guy as all that when he's hitting below 290. Last year, the entire Angels starting line up was hitting 3 bills plus at one point of the season (late in the year). Now don't get me wrong here. I love Choo. He"s a great outfielder and in my opinion, a tremendous base runner...which all counts. Moreover, if we had 8 Choos on the field at once, we could probably compete with Boston and NY.
• Laley23

  

  Footwedge;403371 wrote:But only because crappy teams get a token picked. It's hard for me to label this guy as all that when he's hitting below 290. Last year, the entire Angels starting line up was hitting 3 bills plus at one point of the season (late in the year). Now don't get me wrong here. I love Choo. He"s a great outfielder and in my opinion, a tremendous base runner...which all counts. Moreover, if we had 8 Choos on the field at once, we could probably compete with Boston and NY.

  
  His average has slipped, thats for sure. But the analysts at ESPN and MLBNetwork today were saying he should be on the All-Star team regardless. That he deserves it this season. I think sometimes we get biased TOWARDS our players, and sometimes we think the ARENT as good as they are.