Sparty Claiming Bucks Doctored Game Tape

• Tiernan

  The Detroit Free Press (fish wrap at best) is saying the MSU coaching staff is claiming OSU sent doctored game tape to them last week deleting key shift and formation segments. Urbie is more or less saying its complete BS.
  
  Sounds alot like sour grapes for losing to me. I always liked Dantonio and kinda surprised he would whine like this whether its true or not.
• se-alum

  

  Old news, but it boggles my mind that they still trade gametape.
• WebFire

  Tiernan;1284368 wrote:The Detroit Free Press (fish wrap at best) is saying the MSU coaching staff is claiming OSU sent doctored game tape to them last week deleting key shift and formation segments. Urbie is more or less saying its complete BS.
  
  Sounds alot like sour grapes for losing to me. I always liked Dantonio and kinda surprised he would whine like this whether its true or not.

  If Urbie is saying that, then someone is lying. MSU had already obtained new tapes that did show everything. And compared to the tapes distributed to other teams, they were doctored.
  
  I'm with se-alum though. With all the media available, why do they even need to do this? I guess it just makes it fair and consistent across the board to require it.
• LJ

  

  This has already been resolved through the ADs.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  LOL. Contact BTN and get game films. What a joke.
• bigkahuna

  And if they did?
  
  Other than being shady, is there any kind of penalty for this?
• vball10set

  ernest_t_bass;1284428 wrote:LOL. Contact BTN and get game films. What a joke.

  Or just DVR them to begin with...all of their games were broadcast anyway.
• sleeper

  

  se-alum;1284372 wrote:Old news, but it boggles my mind that they still trade gametape.

  This.
• bases_loaded

  

  vball10set;1284450 wrote:Or just DVR them to begin with...all of their games were broadcast anyway.

  Game film is a lot different..but I get your point
  
  Has anyone come down on MSU for the "just the wind knocked out of him" thing?
• WebFire

  bases_loaded;1284456 wrote:Game film is a lot different..but I get your point
  
  Has anyone come down on MSU for the "just the wind knocked out of him" thing?

  Is there any actual rule to be broken? Does he have an official concussion now?
• karen lotz

  

  vball10set;1284450 wrote:Or just DVR them to begin with...all of their games were broadcast anyway.

  
  There are slightly different camera angles in coaches film compared to what you'd see on dvr.
  
  MSU shouldn't have talked about it to the media if they had a complaint filed with the B1G, but if they sent full game films to osu and expected the same in return since that's what they've always done, there is no problem with them filing the complaint. Its not like the B1G is going to change the outcome of the game or anything.
• LJ

  

  karen lotz;1284466 wrote:There are slightly different camera angles in coaches film compared to what you'd see on dvr.
  
  MSU shouldn't have talked about it to the media if they had a complaint filed with the B1G, but if they sent full game films to osu and expected the same in return since that's what they've always done, there is no problem with them filing the complaint. Its not like the B1G is going to change the outcome of the game or anything.

  
  They never filed a complaint, the ADs settled it.
  
  http://www.freep.com/article/20120929/SPORTS07/120929031/michigan-state-ohio-state-game-film-complaint-big-ten?odyssey=mod%7Cnewswell%7Ctext%7CSports%7Cs
• karen lotz

  

  Ah, the first thing i saw on it said there was a complaint filed on Thursday and msu had talked to other teams to get the correct film.
• karen lotz

  

  http://tracking.si.com/2012/09/30/michigan-state-says-ohio-state-doctored-game-film/
  

  Michigan State filed a complaint to the Big Ten Conference saying Ohio State cut off pre-snap motions and shifts before plays on film of its previous four games, reports the Detroit Free Press.

• LJ

  

  karen lotz;1284486 wrote:http://tracking.si.com/2012/09/30/michigan-state-says-ohio-state-doctored-game-film/

  
  ??? That is in reference to the article i posted, lol
• WebFire

  From what I understood, they filed a complaint but were able to resolve it without the B1G's involvement.
• karen lotz

  

  LJ;1284489 wrote:??? That is in reference to the article i posted, lol

  
  Lol I know.
• karen lotz

  

  WebFire;1284490 wrote:From what I understood, they filed a complaint but were able to resolve it without the B1G's involvement.

  
  Yes.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  From what I gather, the AD's settled this. Amirite?
• WebFire

  ernest_t_bass;1284503 wrote:From what I gather, the AD's settled this. Amirite?

  But only after it was reported.
• Fly4Fun

  

  I heard MSU was like, WTF Urb, why you doctor the tape.
  
  Urb was like, Gene Smith, get off your lazy ass and go deal with this.
  
  AD's talked, cried, had make up sex. All was settled.
  
  OSU won game.
• Scarlet_Buckeye

  

  se-alum;1284372 wrote: it boggles my mind that they still trade gametape.

  This.
• bases_loaded

  

  How else would they get the entire 11 view of every play?
• Fly4Fun

  

  It's for the coaches tape which is different than what the TV audience sees.
  
  Anyways, not sure why this is a story after the fact other than someone trying to make an excuse for why Sparty lost.
• PoorLittleBoy

  I'm hoping this doesn't start a trend of trying to make Urbie look bad.