Best College Football player EVER????

• tcby99

  Is it Archie? He won 2 Heismans
• OneBuckeye

  

  Guys off the top of my head
  
  Hershal Walker
  Barry Sanders
  Archie
• j_crazy

  

  orlando pace was one of the most dominant players i've seen in college. i know it's a low glamour position but IMO he should be considered of the players I've seen.
• ytownfootball

  

  Bo Jackson
• cam93

  Archie
• Gardens35

  Paul Hornung was one of the best.
• steel_curtain

  Archie Griffen definitly didn't deserve the second heisman, he did deserve the first one.
  
  Bo Jackson, Barry Sanders, or Herschel Walker
• vball10set

  tough to argue with a guy that can't even spell Archie's name correctly,so why bother....
  
  IMO - Jim Thorpe,Bo Jackson,Archie Griffin,Paul Hornung
• derek bomar

  

  Tommy Frasier was a beast
• Huskers

  Tommie Frazier.
• steel_curtain

  vball10set wrote: tough to argue with a guy that can't even spell Archie's name correctly,so why bother....
  
  IMO - Jim Thorpe,Bo Jackson,Archie Griffin,Paul Hornung

  Can you honestly say he deserved the second one?
  
  I'd like to hear reasoning why he should not just your usual shit.
• Crimson_Streak

  Charles Woodson
• Cha'DIch

  Jim Brown
• rock_knutne

  Cha'DIch wrote: Jim Brown

  Ernie Davis
• vball10set

  LMAO--is that all you got?? honestly,curtain--it's just too easy!!! if I thought it'd be worth it,I could go and discredit every single Heisman winner with this stat or that--but domers like you are just too thick headed,so why bother...
• devil1197

  Craig Krenzel.
• devil1197

  steel, OSU used the fullback a ton that year down near the endzone.
  
  Griffin had 1,450 yards his SR year.
  Johnson had 1,059 and 25 TD's (OSU season record at time). Most of those TD's were in short yardage where Griffin got them there.
• ytownfootball

  

  steel,
  
  Your opinion is great and all but, assuming you didn't have a vote for the Heisman it doesn't mean shit.
  
  Hate much?
• grass_licker

  art sleister or maurice clarrette
• Strapping Young Lad

  

  Herschel
• ytownfootball

  

  grass_licker wrote: art sleister or maurice clarrette

  My god boy, you butchered the hell out of those two.
• darbypitcher22

  

  Archie isn't the best of all time but certainly should be considered as one.
  
  I think you've gotta go with Bo Jackson or Herschel Walker, or Red Grange
• Strapping Young Lad

  

  Haha Mo, the best ever....
• steel_curtain

  devil1197 wrote: steel, OSU used the fullback a ton that year down near the endzone.
  
  Griffin had 1,450 yards his SR year.
  Johnson had 1,059 and 25 TD's (OSU season record at time). Most of those TD's were in short yardage where Griffin got them there.

  Thats fine, and I am well aware of Pete Johnson, but I still don't think you can give someone the heisman with 4 touchdowns.
• steel_curtain

  ytownfootball wrote: steel,
  
  Your opinion is great and all but, assuming you didn't have a vote for the Heisman it doesn't mean shit.
  
  Hate much?

  Which is just as valuable as your opinion on the matter.