who is better Vince Young or Cam Newton?

• dwccrew

  

  norwalk;590313 wrote:VY, not even close. Not only did Texas go through a tough Big12, he beat tOSU (Love or hate the Buckeyes they had a top 5-10 team) and then beat a loaded USC team in their backyard. I just don't see the level of competition being there for Cam. Newton is without a doubt up there for having one of the top seasons ever, I personally think VY did more against better competition.

  Agreed.
  

  2quik4u;590419 wrote:yep keep trying to compare a bunch of two loss sec teams to a team that had two heisman trophy winners 2 national titles and won 34 straight games

  
  Agreed.
  

  lhslep134;590601 wrote:Dude you're reading way too much into this. I haven't and am not discrediting Texas or Vince Young or USC. I said if USC's defense was so "vaunted" they wouldn't have given up 40+ points, that's all I said. I didn't say USC wasn't great or wasn't one of the all time great teams, but Vince didn't play against the USC offense, he played against a USC defense that got exposed, which you CANNOT deny.
  
  
  All I was doing was crediting LSU and Alabama's defense and saying that it's absurd to think that Cam Newton hasn't been tested. I don't think the SEC is the best conference, but they do have arguably more talent than any other conference on the defensive side of the ball.

  
  USC wasn't exposed, it's that they were playing a stud like VY. He singlehandedly slashed the USC defense up that night.
  
  People must have some short term memories, what VY did that year was incredible. Newton is great, no doubt, but VY did it from start to finish and did it against better opponents. I'll take Ohio State and USC of 2005 over Alabama, Arkansas and LSU of 2010.
• norwalk

  I don't think anyone is slighting Newton, he is a stud and like I said earlier he singlehandling will lead Auburn over Oregon. Just as VY did against SC. Heck, I still put Tommy Frazier up there as one of the greatest college QB's of all time even though his stats were nowhere near todays quarterbacks.
• lhslep134

  

  dwccrew;590925 wrote: USC wasn't exposed, it's that they were playing a stud like VY. He singlehandedly slashed the USC defense up that night.

  
  Yes, they were exposed. OSU had a great defense and only gave up 23 points (the UT offense didn't score the safety). USC gave up 40+ to the same stud QB. USC wasn't one of the all time great teams on defense, they were one of the all time great teams on offense, which Vince DIDN'T PLAY AGAINST.
  
  Were OSU and USC better teams than LSU, Arkansas, and Alabama? Absolutely. Better defenses? Not really. OSU's defense that year is comparable to LSU's this year, and I'll take Alabama's defense over USC's, considering they gave up 28 to ASU that year and 42 to Fresno State.
  
  Maybe you're the one with short term memories about how mediocre USC's defense was that year.
• Tiger2003

  

  Vince Young hands down. I really don't think it's even that close. Yes what Cam Newton has done this season is pretty amazing but week in and week out Young did something new that had us all in awe. I'll never forget the play he did vs OK State when he did a pump fake then ran for another 60 some yards.
  
  VY had the greatest ever back to back Rose Bowl games ever and one was the National Title Game.
  
  
  Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
• dwccrew

  

  lhslep134;591131 wrote:Yes, they were exposed. OSU had a great defense and only gave up 23 points (the UT offense didn't score the safety). USC gave up 40+ to the same stud QB. USC wasn't one of the all time great teams on defense, they were one of the all time great teams on offense, which Vince DIDN'T PLAY AGAINST.
  
  Were OSU and USC better teams than LSU, Arkansas, and Alabama? Absolutely. Better defenses? Not really. OSU's defense that year is comparable to LSU's this year, and I'll take Alabama's defense over USC's, considering they gave up 28 to ASU that year and 42 to Fresno State.
  
  Maybe you're the one with short term memories about how mediocre USC's defense was that year.

  
  And Newton is playing an out of this world defense with Oregon? LOL, if Newton leads his team to a national title, maybe he'll be just as good as VY, until then, he hasn't done much to convince many on here.
  
  That USC defense was good enough to have continued a 34 game win streak, I'd say they were ok.
• bigkahuna

  Nobody came close to VY's numbers that year. D-Rob is very close to Cam this year in stats. Auburn has had a great year with Cam as the play caller. Vince Young himself had a great year. Like someone else said, it depends on Cam's performance in the NC game.
• lhslep134

  

  dwccrew;591752 wrote:
  That USC defense was good enough to have continued a 34 game win streak, I'd say they were ok.

  
  They played 34 games in a season?!!??! Holy crap that's news to me.
  
  
  
  
  
  
  The only thing that matters is the final 12 games of that winning streak, games in which their defense is mediocre.
• Tiger2003

  

  lhslep134;591906 wrote:
  
  
  The only thing that matters is the final 12 games of that winning streak, games in which their defense is mediocre.

  
  Well their mediocre defense must have done something right to help win those 12 games. Yes I know the offense was very explosive but the defense pitched in too.
  
  
  Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
• Red_Skin_Pride

  

  Tiger2003;591174 wrote:Vince Young hands down. I really don't think it's even that close. Yes what Cam Newton has done this season is pretty amazing but week in and week out Young did something new that had us all in awe.

  This. It wasn't so much his numbers, although they were certainly worthy of talking about. It was his presence. Forget his NFL career, if we're talking about just what he did at Texas, the last half of his sophmore year and all of his junior year, what set VY apart was his PRESENCE. The guys just oozed leadership on that team, and people that watched him could just tell that when the chips were down, he was going to make the play that won you the game. He is what they call a "winner", plain and simple, in college. You take VY off of that team, and USC beats them by 21 points or more and that's assuming they even make it to the NC game (which they wouldn't have. Probably about 8-4 or 9-3). Was there ever any doubt that he was going to win the game on the final drive of the NC game? After watching him the previous year and a half in many games, I told the people I was with that USC was done, because there's no one in America who could stop him in that offense, that year. I and was proven right.
• charliehustle14

  Before I even clicked on this thread, I knew Tebow would be brought up a couple times. And yep, I was right.
  
  Young > Newton or Tebow
  
  Tebow had an incredible career and his stat sheet is stuffed, but VY is one of the most electric and prolific players to play QB at the college level IMO. Cam Newton is a heck of a player too, but not even he matches VY's electricity.
• lhslep134

  

  Tiger2003;592073 wrote:Yes I know the offense was very explosive but the defense pitched in too.

  
  Not really. Their offense masked their mediocre defense, not unlike Auburn and Oregon this year.