Anyone still think T.Pryor will be better than T.Smith???

• hoops23

  

  People forget that Pryor has a SR year.
  
  He's gotten better each year, so it's possible.
  
  However, I loved Troy Smith. He was clutch and big time... Except in 1 game.
• gerb131

  

  [video=youtube;GGXzlRoNtHU][/video]
  
  Thats all TP does is win and thats all that counts.
• krambman

  

  Talk is cheap none of you haters could fit my shoes w ten socks on. Bums. Go Bucks

  http://twitter.com/#!/TPeezy2
• ernest_t_bass

  

  krambman;568411 wrote:http://twitter.com/#!/TPeezy2

  
  He sounds like a fucking idiot.
• gerb131

  

  ernest_t_bass;568430 wrote:He sounds like a fucking idiot.

  
  Why? All he does is win and its ohhh he threw 2 picks blah blah blah blah. Its the same shit from us Ohio St fans he can't ever just be TP.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  gerb131;568432 wrote:Why? All he does is win and its ohhh he threw 2 picks blah blah blah blah. Its the same shit from us Ohio St fans he can't ever just be TP.

  
  Lol... I'm talking about his entire twitter page, not that comment. I mean that his English is turrible.
• gerb131

  

  ernest_t_bass;568434 wrote:Lol... I'm talking about his entire twitter page, not that comment. I mean that his English is turrible.

  
  Oh yea well what you expect lol. They speak dutch in PA. But my comment wasn't directed at you in particular but he does get hated on for how much he has meant to Oh St.
• krambman

  

  ernest_t_bass;568434 wrote:Lol... I'm talking about his entire twitter page, not that comment. I mean that his English is turrible.

  
  Most people's English is terrible on twitter because they only give you 140 characters. It drives me nuts!
  
  Even Shaq who has a BA in General Studies, and MBA, and is working on his PhD has terrible grammar on Twitter.
• LJ

  

  ccrunner609;568519 wrote:Bingo
  
  TP is better at every stage of development then Troy as a Junior. His stats are better and has won more games. End of thread.

  
  You are right. TP's Jr year stats are better already.
• Bigdogg

  TP is on track to finishing top 5 all time passing in a season this year. Next year he can finish #1 all time career. What do you guys want out of him?
• Y-Town Steelhound

  

  He has done well. However I don't know anyone who could objectively say with a straight face that Terrelle Pryor is a better quarterback than Troy Smith. Troy wasn't the athletic freak Pryor is but he was fast and especially his senior year he utilized that speed to buy more time in the pocket and find the open guy.
  
  Now it's obvious that Troy's offensive weapons were better than Pryor's but it's not like Pryor is playing with a bunch of bums. The biggest thing for me in where they are different is throwing the football. Troy Smith had an absolute cannon. Not only could he throw it deep but he threw frozen ropes on his short to intermediate passes. He was also a lot more accurate than Pryor. Those are the things that stand out to me.
• gerb131

  

  Y-Town Steelhound;569256 wrote:He has done well. However I don't know anyone who could objectively say with a straight face that Terrelle Pryor is a better quarterback than Troy Smith. Troy wasn't the athletic freak Pryor is but he was fast and especially his senior year he utilized that speed to buy more time in the pocket and find the open guy.
  
  Now it's obvious that Troy's offensive weapons were better than Pryor's but it's not like Pryor is playing with a bunch of bums. The biggest thing for me in where they are different is throwing the football. Troy Smith had an absolute cannon. Not only could he throw it deep but he threw frozen ropes on his short to intermediate passes. He was also a lot more accurate than Pryor. Those are the things that stand out to me.

  Copy that. Troy has a cannon.
• believer

  

  Stats aside will someone PLEASE tell me that Pryor is a better team leader than Troy Smith. That's right...you can't.
  
  That fact alone tells me that Smith is the better QB.
• gerb131

  

  believer;569260 wrote:Stats aside will someone PLEASE tell me that Pryor is a better team leader than Troy Smith. That's right...you can't.
  
  That fact alone tells me that Smith is the better QB.

  
  He has led some nice game winning drives in the last 2 years....I don't know about his prescence in the huddle.
• Pick6

  

  I actually think Pryor is a pretty good leader.
• ytownfootball

  

  Any opinion is pure speculation given the fact he has a season left.
• dwccrew

  

  centralbucksfan;568052 wrote: Smith never won a BCS game as a starter. Is he better right now then Smith was as a SENIOR? No. Will he be next year? Thats yet to be determined.

  Smith beat Notre Dame in the Fiesta Bowl. They have the same record as starters in BCS games.
  

  Pick6;568081 wrote:without pryor, this team would be lucky to win 7 games. We would lose to Miami, Iowa, PSU, Wisconsin, and add in another random loss such as illinois, michigan, or purdue

  You could have said the same thing about about Smith as a starter.
  

  Ankle Breaker;568174 wrote:This pretty much sums up how I feel about the question. I wouldn't trade Pryor for very many QB's in the entire country.

  
  That isn't the question though, it is a comparison between Smith and Pryor. And I would take Cam Newton over Pryor (minus all the allegations) and probably Andrew Luck as well. But other than that, I'd have Pryor as the 3rd or 4th best QB in the nation.
  
  At this point, Pryor IMO is not at Smith's level (in college), but he has an entire season to out perform Smith.
• Trueblue23

  

  There are quite a few QBs in the country I'd take over Pryor.
• Steel Valley Football

  I think Braxton Miller will make us forget about both of them by his junior year.
• sleeper

  

  Pryor is one of the top QB's in the nation easily, but T. Smith is one of the best college QB's OF ALL TIME.
  
  Give me T. Smith any day.
• ptown_trojans_1

  

  I think Pryor is just behind Troy in the decision making and mental aspects of the game at this point in his career. It was the little things that made Troy awesome, great awareness, great decisions, and not making mental mistakes. Pryor has been too inconsistent this year as one play he will look awesome and the next like a freshman.
  
  Troy's junior season started slow (no Texas game), but then played fantastic down the stretch, especially in the 2005 Michigan game. Pryor to me is not at that level yet. He is close, but if he can capture the mental parts of the game and stop making stupid throws and mistakes, he will even with and probably pass Troy next year.
• Pick6

  

  Steel Valley Football;569461 wrote:I think Braxton Miller will make us forget about both of them by his junior year.

  
  he will have to stay uninjured long enough for that to happen
• Pick6

  

  Bigdogg;568569 wrote:TP is on track to finishing top 5 all time passing in a season this year. Next year he can finish #1 all time career. What do you guys want out of him?

  
  anything short of the second coming of God is not good enough for these people
• vball10set

  Steel Valley Football;569461 wrote:I think Braxton Miller will make us forget about both of them by his junior year.

  THIS +1000
• Mr. 300

  

  Why he's got the bestest ever ranking above all others. He has made incredible strides since arriving on campus as the most recruited player of all time out of PA. The coaching staff opens up the offensvie play calling more and more each game as TP shows he has the grasp of picking up his reads and going through his progressions. Why he has to be the front runner for the Heisman next year. Might as well just name him the greatest college quarterback to ever play the game. He's that good.
  
  Now, can he actually lead his team to a national championship next year?