Archive

Anyone still think T.Pryor will be better than T.Smith???

  • 77Legend
    I know there were a lot of posters who thought TP would be better than TS. Anyone still feel that way?
  • sjmvsfscs08
    Show me someone who thinks that and I'll show you an idiot.
  • Trueblue23
    sjmvsfscs08;567818 wrote:Show me someone who thinks that and I'm show you an idiot.

    LOL This post made me laugh.
  • sjmvsfscs08
    Trueblue23;567909 wrote:LOL This post made me laugh.

    We're playing a drinking game in my apartment. For every bad throw by Pryor we take a drink...
  • Fly4Fun
    sjmvsfscs08;567915 wrote:We're playing a drinking game in my apartment. For every bad throw by Pryor we take a drink...

    There have been a few bad throws, there have also been too many dropped passes of really good throws... I'm looking at you Posey.
  • Fly4Fun
    Hines just blew up Robinson.

    I agree that it should have been a flag... but I'll take it.

    Plus, it was in the middle of a bunch of linemen... tough for the refs to see that one. From above it's pretty easy to tell though.
  • LJ
    actually as good as T Smith? No. But if he had Gonzo, Ginn, Holmes, he would have the same type of numbers that Smith put up.
  • sjmvsfscs08
    LJ;567951 wrote:actually as good as T Smith? No. But if he had Gonzo, Ginn, Holmes, he would have the same type of numbers that Smith put up.

    Valid point.
  • Lovejoy1984
    All I know is Pryor saved this game.
  • Leonardo
    I don't think he is but Terrelle Pryor hasn't graduated yet either.
  • LJ
    sjmvsfscs08;567987 wrote:Valid point.

    hell, even WR's that know what to do on scramble drill and can hold onto the ball would be an upgrade
  • 77Legend
    There were a few posters who said it. Just a question. I was just making a comparison. Smith for the arm and Pryor for the legs. But overall, T.Smith.
  • believer
    Smith >>>>> Pryor

    Not even close.
  • Scarlet_Fever
    He has never progressed where I had hoped with his passing. He is very inconsistant and still makes some really stupid throws. Of course Troy's JR. season he gave the Penn State game away. ( I realize Pryor has had much more tiime at this point). I will say this. If Pryor can have a Monster Senior season and bring a title home. People may view that differently or at least a lot closer.
  • centralbucksfan
    Lets see, he is going to shatter every OSU QB record, including Smith by the time he is finished. His team is currently 10-1. He won a Rose Bowl, and was MVP. Smith never won a BCS game as a starter. Is he better right now then Smith was as a SENIOR? No. Will he be next year? Thats yet to be determined.
  • SportsAndLady
    This thread is a joke
  • believer
    centralbucksfan;568052 wrote:Is he better right now then Smith was as a SENIOR? No. Will he be next year?
    True. There's always next year.
  • sjmvsfscs08
    centralbucksfan;568052 wrote:Lets see, he is going to shatter every OSU QB record, including Smith by the time he is finished. His team is currently 10-1. He won a Rose Bowl, and was MVP. Smith never won a BCS game as a starter. Is he better right now then Smith was as a SENIOR? No. Will he be next year? Thats yet to be determined.

    This isn't track and field. None of the accolades or records mean anything.
  • darbypitcher22
    Terelle is going to have to have a NC game appearance for people to say he was better than Troy.

    Oh yeah, probably better throw in a Heisman as well
  • centralbucksfan
    sjmvsfscs08;568057 wrote:This isn't track and field. None of the accolades or records mean anything.

    Nope, but wins do. And he WINS. Period.
  • sjmvsfscs08
    centralbucksfan;568062 wrote:Nope, but wins do. And he WINS. Period.

    No, wins don't. There are 84 other players on the team.
  • Pick6
    sjmvsfscs08;568075 wrote:No, wins don't. There are 84 other players on the team.

    without pryor, this team would be lucky to win 7 games. We would lose to Miami, Iowa, PSU, Wisconsin, and add in another random loss such as illinois, michigan, or purdue
  • sjmvsfscs08
    Pick6;568081 wrote:without pryor, this team would be lucky to win 7 games. We would lose to Miami, Iowa, PSU, Wisconsin, and add in another random loss such as illinois, michigan, or purdue

    Big deal. He's the starting quarterback, every team can say that.
  • Ankle Breaker
    centralbucksfan;568052 wrote:Lets see, he is going to shatter every OSU QB record, including Smith by the time he is finished. His team is currently 10-1. He won a Rose Bowl, and was MVP. Smith never won a BCS game as a starter. Is he better right now then Smith was as a SENIOR? No. Will he be next year? Thats yet to be determined.
    This pretty much sums up how I feel about the question. I wouldn't trade Pryor for very many QB's in the entire country.
  • elbuckeye28
    centralbucksfan;568052 wrote:Lets see, he is going to shatter every OSU QB record, including Smith by the time he is finished. His team is currently 10-1. He won a Rose Bowl, and was MVP. Smith never won a BCS game as a starter. Is he better right now then Smith was as a SENIOR? No. Will he be next year? Thats yet to be determined.

    I agree with most of this, but Troy Smith did win the Fiesta Bowl against Notre Dame.