American Idol -the Girls

• ManO'War

  

  I like the Siobhan chick.
  
  The mullet kid needs a new cut and some confidence.
• pkebker

  Terrible luck for Lily, she was excellent. I think the large voting block for the show (middle/high school girls) found her too weird. I really hope some record label picks her up, because she was great!
  
  Katy needs to go immediately...
• thavoice

  figured lilly wouldnt make it. she is small niche of style.....and that other chick from ohio i think got those votes.
  
  that other girl was hot...was wishn she woulda went through.
  
  Ive only been wactchin the chicks so dont know if they dudes are any goood.
• bigdaddy2003

  

  This season sucks. Big Mike and Crystal will be the final.
• pkebker

  Who all thinks Kara and Ellen have to go? I think they are terrible judges and are more interested on getting the attention on themselves rather than on the contestants...
• dtdtim

  pkebker wrote: Who all thinks Kara and Ellen have to go? I think they are terrible judges and are more interested on getting the attention on themselves rather than on the contestants...

  Me. I've hated Kara from day 1, and her crying after big black guy's performance on Wednesday was the final straw. I've always been a fan of Ellen's but I'm actually starting to hate her a little watching her on Idol. BTW, anyone noticed her neck? WTF is wrong with it? It looks like a Sharpei died underneath her chin.
  

  ManO'War wrote: I like the Siobhan chick.
  
  The mullet kid needs a new cut and some confidence.

  Mullet kid=Carol Brady called, she'd like her hair back.
  
  I think Vote For the Worst is hilarious and I agree with them, Siobhan definitely has vote for the worst potential. She's actually one of the better ones this season which isn't saying much as compared to Underwood or Clarkson or Hudson, she isn't that good. I think Crystal is my favorite thus far...I think she goes far in the Top 12.
• pkebker

  Why is there a thread for just American Idol girls...why not just make an American Idol thread...
• Eric Taylor

  Is the Country Dude still in the mix?
  
  I have hardly watched any of this since the auditions.
  
  Last year I watched quite a bit because there was talent across the board.
  
  American Idol will crumble next year without Simon and wouldnt surprise me if it is cancelled not long after.
• Nate

  Lee, Crystal, Siobahn and Andrea will be top 4.
• pkebker

  I don't think Siobahn will make it that far. She is too different, and doesn't have the looks, to get the large votes towards the end...
• pkebker

  And you forgot Big Mike, he definitely is a contender
• Nate

  I think Big Mike will fall out eventually. Siobahn has an amazing voice. Weird? Yes but her voice is top notch. I also think Casey James will be a Top 5. He has the teeny bopper vote.
• bigdaddy2003

  

  I forgot about Andrew. The final 3 will be Andrew, Crystal, and Big Mike.
• pkebker

  My final four will be Lee, Crystal, Mike, and Andrew (he has potential, he just needs to start making good song choices). The winner will be Big Mike
• september63

  

  Crystal will win. She is helped by being able to play a musical instrament or two.
• HitsRus

  

  I'm going with Siobahn, Chrystal, Big Mike, Casey and Lee as top 5. Casey is living on his appeal to women. If he doesn't pick it up, he'll be gone before the top 5.
• bigdaddy2003

  

  I just can't see Andrew not making it to the top 5.
• HitsRus

  

  ^^^I thought he should have gone home last nite. He hasn't done anything very well since the Paula Abdul song. He was my favorite guy early on...but he's lost me.
• bigdaddy2003

  

  Yeah, I guess you are right. I don't know. I just like his voice. It's just such a down season. I thought Todrick did good enough to stay. I think Paige should have gone home but she didn't. I think Alex Lambert was a good choice to head home.
• pkebker

  If Alex Lambert didn't have a mullet he would have stayed...
• Nate

  I thought Andrew's version of Fall Out Boy - Sugar, We're Going Down Swinging was AWESOME and he did another song I really liked but I can't remember what it was.
• bigdaddy2003

  

  ^ Yeah, I think he is one of the only creative singers left. They loved David Cook for taking a song and changing the arrangement but they are giving Andrew less credit. I mean Genie In A Bottle may have not been the best song choice but it was still creative. It sucks that Simon is leaving after this season but it may be for the best considering how bad it has been lol.
• Nate

  I think with Simon leaving, the show doesn't have much left. Between him and Randy, they are the only ones I actually listen to.
• bigdaddy2003

  

  Keebler wrote: I think with Simon leaving, the show doesn't have much left. Between him and Randy, they are the only ones I actually listen to.

  Yeah, I think they thought getting Ellen was going to boost their ratings but people realize she has no credibility. She was kind of funny during Hollywood week but since then she has dropped all comedy and actually tried to be a judge and I just don't think that is what they wanted her for.
• Nate

  bigdaddy2003 wrote:

  Keebler wrote: I think with Simon leaving, the show doesn't have much left. Between him and Randy, they are the only ones I actually listen to.

  Yeah, I think they thought getting Ellen was going to boost their ratings but people realize she has no credibility. She was kind of funny during Hollywood week but since then she has dropped all comedy and actually tried to be a judge and I just don't think that is what they wanted her for.

  Totally agree. I don't think they could hire anyone to take Simon's spot to save the show.