Archive

Led Zeppelin or Pink Floyd?

  • Heretic
    ccrunner609 wrote:
    The_Crosby_Show wrote:
    wes_mantooth wrote: I can't get into Floyd, but I love Zeppelin.
    Same here.
    smoke a J and put it on, you will like it alot.
    Damn straight! :D

    Seriously, this is brutal to judge. Both bands are utterly amazing in their own ways. I might barely be leaning towards Zeppelin, but I'm not sure.
  • Little Danny
  • wes_mantooth
    Heretic wrote:
    ccrunner609 wrote:
    The_Crosby_Show wrote:
    wes_mantooth wrote: I can't get into Floyd, but I love Zeppelin.
    Same here.
    smoke a J and put it on, you will like it alot.
    Damn straight! :D

    Seriously, this is brutal to judge. Both bands are utterly amazing in their own ways. I might barely be leaning towards Zeppelin, but I'm not sure.
    NO!!! Rather shoot heroin and listen to this....



    or do some X and listen to this

  • majorspark
    Definitely Zeppelin.
  • Gardens35
    Floyd in a walk.
  • Mister Twister
    Pink Floyd.

    Top 5 - Dogs, The Nile Song, Summer '68, Run Like Hell, and Echoes!
  • Sonofanump
    ccrunner609 wrote: Money
    I'll take Breathe, Time and Us & Them over Money any day of the week.
  • zambrown
    I love them both, often just depending on my mood. Speaking of which...
    ccrunner609 wrote:
    The_Crosby_Show wrote:
    wes_mantooth wrote: I can't get into Floyd, but I love Zeppelin.
    Same here.
    smoke a J and put it on, you will like it alot.
    Ahhhhhh, back in the day, I would have to totally agree on this point. ;)
  • Cat Food Flambe'
    Brutal choice here - but Floyd had more musical range, and gets the nod.
  • hang_loose
    Like them both but got to go with Zeppelin. Zeppelin IV ... especially!!!
  • h2thaizzo
    I really enjoy both groups, probably 1 and 2 as far as my favorite ever is concerned. My thing with Floyd is that their music is so damn dark and depressing. I have to be in one of those moods, bad day, fucking miserable, or the rare occasion where i'm stoned in order to really get into them they way that I'm always into Zeppelin. Another thing I really like about Led Zeppelin is that they seem so versatile to me. Stairway To Heaven, Whole Lotta Love, D'yer Maker, Fool in the Rain, I think those are some of the songs I really enjoy of them, and none really sound alike to me.
  • ohiotiger33
    Oh man. Can't beat Floyd for me, but Led is awesome.
  • DeyDurkie5
    ccrunner609 wrote:
    The_Crosby_Show wrote:
    wes_mantooth wrote: I can't get into Floyd, but I love Zeppelin.
    Same here.
    smoke a J and put it on, you will like it alot.
    don't tell me you smoke...
  • 2quik4u
    Which ones pink?
  • Woollums9
    Anything off of the Animals Cd is wayyyyyyy better than some of the songs Ernest listed as PFs best. I voted for Pink because they did write their own songs compared to where Zep took some blues songs and rerecorded them into a rock and roll style. but my fav all time for this goes as :
    1. PF
    2. Zep
  • noreply66
    hard to pick there
  • Devils Advocate
    Unfair question... It's kinda of like asking do ya like firm young perky Boobies or perfect silicone skin stretchers...:rolleyes:
  • ernest_t_bass
    Woollums9 wrote: Anything off of the Animals Cd is wayyyyyyy better than some of the songs Ernest listed as PFs best.

    [size=xx-large]MY[/size] FAVORITE SONGS
  • vball10set
    Plant,Page,Bonham & Jones--Zed Leppelin,baby!!!
  • justincredible
    Tough choice but I had to go with Floyd.
  • Woollums9
    Woah calm down ETB. Your post said "Top 5 songs" so I was taking that it meant those were the top 5 songs by the group.....not your favorite 5. My misunderstanding I guess
  • ernest_t_bass
    Woollums9 wrote: Woah calm down ETB. Your post said "Top 5 songs" so I was taking that it meant those were the top 5 songs by the group.....not your favorite 5. My misunderstanding I guess
    Arggh. LOL, you're not the only one to comment, so I thought I'd let everyone know they were MY favorite, lol.
  • Sonofanump
    Here are the top 53 songs by Led Zeppelin. Feel free to discuss the list or my insanity:

    1) Over the Hills and Far Away
    2) Kashmir
    3) Ten Years Gone
    4) Immigrant Song
    5) Hey, Hey What Can I Do
    6) Tangerine
    7) Stairway to Heaven
    8) Misty Mountain Hop
    9) Rock and Roll
    10) The Ocean
    11) Houses of the Holy
    12) Babe I'm Gonna Leave You
    13) The Wanton Song
    14) Whole Lotta Love
    15) Black Dog
    16) The Battle of Evermore
    17) Dazed and Confused
    18) Nobody's Fault but Mine
    19) Heartbreaker
    20) What Is and What Should Never Be
    21) All My Love
    22) Achilles Last Stand
    23) How Many More Times
    24) The Rain Song
    25) In the Evening
    26) Trampled Under Foot
    27) Gallows Pole
    28) Going to California
    29) In My Time of Dying
    30) Communication Breakdown
    31) Lemon/Traveling Riverside
    32) That's the Way
    33) Ramble On
    34) Celebration Day
    35) Bron-Yr-Aur Stomp
    36) When the Levee Breaks
    37) The Song Remains the Same
    38) No Quarter
    39) Fool in the Rain
    40) The Rover
    41) For Your Life
    42) Custard Pie
    43) D’yer Mak’er
    44) Wearing and Tearing
    45) Caroselambra
    46) Good Times Bad Times
    47) Out on the Tiles
    48) Bring it on Home
    49) Friends
    50) Bonzo’s Montreux
    51) Since I’ve Been Loving You
    52) Your Time is Gonna Come
    53) We’re gonna groove
  • power i
    Floyd when I'm dropping acid, Zeppelin the rest of the time.
  • Websurfinbird
    Voted for Zep, but both are great. Hard to find good rock like that these days ... IMO