Archive

Will Josh Freeman be the best African American QB ever?

  • MANAZE
    Anyone watch Josh Freeman play? He might be the best African American QB ever if he continues and doesn't mess up like all the other AA QBs since Cunningham.
  • miller45452003
    NO WAY!! Spergion Wynn has already topped the best black QB all time!:P
  • charliehustle14
    VY is playing well again, but Freeman has been pretty impressive so far.
  • SQ_Crazies
    A little too early for this don't you think? How many times have you seen a guy play well until teams have a few week or half a season of tape on them?

    And he's got some BIG names to pass. Cunningham, Culpepper, Moon, McNabb...even Vick. And I'm sure I left someone out.
  • Al Bundy
    SQ_Crazies wrote: A little too early for this don't you think? How many times have you seen a guy play well until teams have a few week or half a season of tape on them?

    And he's got some BIG names to pass. Cunningham, Culpepper, Moon, McNabb...even Vick. And I'm sure I left someone out.
    Doug Williams was good. He was just on bad teams most of his career except that one good year in Tampa and when he won Superbowl in Washington.
  • Laley23
    Warren Moon, McNabb, Culpepper, Cunningham. He has a ways to go.
  • SQ_Crazies
    A loooooooong way...
  • killdeer
    as long as we are ranking quarterbacks based solely on their physical attributes...
    Will Ben Roethlisberger be the best Fat Bearded QB ever?
  • detectivegibbles
    killdeer wrote: as long as we are ranking quarterbacks based solely on their physical attributes...
    Will Ben Roethlisberger be the best Fat Bearded QB ever?
    Nope, Ron Jaworski.
  • Sonofanump
    If you have seen Warren Moon play this would not be a conversation.
  • CharlieHog
    Sonofanump wrote: If you have seen Warren Moon play this would not be a conversation.

    hell just look at his stats
  • Laley23
    Also, hes gonna have to win 2 SB and also make the HOF just to be considered better than Vince Young.
  • OSH
    Culpepper should not even be in the discussion.
  • MANAZE
    Laley23 wrote: Also, hes gonna have to win 2 SB and also make the HOF just to be considered better than Vince Young.
    VY is a pussy that couldn't handle playing in the NFL. what he comes back for two games and now he is the best again? It is the team around him making him look good. Young is nothing more than a cunt.
  • Automatik
    Who said hes the best? He doing rather well since his return. Have you seen VY's winning percentage as a starter?
  • wes_mantooth
    I would say Warren Moon is the best ever, but Freeman is off to a nice start.
  • Fred Flintstone
    Moon or Cunningham
  • Crimson_Streak
    Mcnair anyone?
  • jpake1
    Havn't seen nearly enough to make a statement like that. I just know he has his work cut out for him.
  • Laley23
    MANAZE wrote:

    VY is a pussy that couldn't handle playing in the NFL. what he comes back for two games and now he is the best again? It is the team around him making him look good. Young is nothing more than a cunt.
    You do realize I just paraphrased what VY said before this season started right? The dude is looney and projected hed be the first black QB to win a SB and would be in the HOF one day.
  • HeathAlum21
    Why is this a topic?
  • SQ_Crazies
    Well Manaze, what do you think?
  • Lovejoy1984
    14/33 93 yards, 0 TD's 3 INT's. QB rating of 12.1

    Pretty much goat Status.
  • SQ_Crazies
    He led them in rushing with like 20 yards too--so he does play on a bullshit team right now. But still...was a little premature when this thread was made.

    Threw 5 picks last week.
  • donkeykong
    Laley23 wrote: Warren Moon, McNabb, Culpepper, Cunningham. He has a ways to go.
    this^