Predict the 2014 NFL Draft QB prospects in 5 years

• BR1986FB

  Your options are:
  
  NFL Star
  NFL Starter
  NFL Backup
  Out of the League
  
  Here are a few names. Feel free to add more....
  
  Bridgewater
  Bortles
  Manziel
  Murray
  Carr
  McCarron
  Savage
  Mettenberger
  Thomas
  Boyd
  Garoppolo
  
  Note: Borrowed this idea.
• CCRolly

  

  Bridgewater - NFL backup
  Bortles - NFL starter
  Manziel - NFL star
  Murray - NFL starter
  Carr - NFL backup
  McCarron - out of NFL
  Savage - out of NFL
  Metzenberger - out of NFL
  Thomas - out of NFL
  Boyd - out of NFL
  Goropolo - out of NFL
• like_that

  

  BR1986FB;1611969 wrote:Your options are:
  
  NFL Star
  NFL Starter
  NFL Backup
  Out of the League
  
  Here are a few names. Feel free to add more....
  
  Bridgewater
  Bortles
  Manziel
  Murray
  Carr
  McCarron
  Savage
  Mettenberger
  Thomas
  Boyd
  Garoppolo
  
  Note: Borrowed this idea.

  What's your definition of star? Dalton was a pro bowl alternate but I would only classify him as a starter on this scale.
• BR1986FB

  like_that;1611973 wrote:What's your definition of star? Dalton was a pro bowl alternate but I would only classify him as a starter on this scale.

  Dalton would be a "starter" on this poll. Ginger scrub is holding the Bengals back from playing for anything significant. AJ Green's carrying his jock for him.
  
  Think guys like Brees, Rodgers, Brady, etc. Russell Wilson would also be considered a "starter" on this poll. Good QB but he's typically not going to be the guy to carry his team on his shoulders.
• like_that

  

  BR1986FB;1611975 wrote:Dalton would be a "starter" on this poll. Ginger scrub is holding the Bengals back from playing for anything significant. AJ Green's carrying his jock for him.
  
  Think guys like Brees, Rodgers, Brady, etc. Russell Wilson would also be considered a "starter" on this poll. Good QB but he's typically not going to be the guy to carry his team on his shoulders.

  Yeah Wilson is def a "starter."
  
  As for the guys you listed tbw, bortles, and manziel I see all as starters. I can see one of them becoming a star though.
  
  For my backups I have McCarron, Metenberger, and Logan Thomas. The rest are out of the NFL.
• robj55

  

  I have a feeling Carr will be better than all of them.
• like_that

  

  I meant to place Carr in the backup list.
• Lovejoy1984

  

  Manziel will be better than every QB who has ever laced them up by this time next year. Rendering all other discussion pointless.
• sleeper

  

  All of them out of the league. This crop SUCKS.
• Lovejoy1984

  

  Bridgewater- Backup
  Bortles Starter
  Manziel Starter
  Murray Starter
  Carr- Star
  McCarron Backup
  Savage OOL
  Mettenberger Backup
  Thomas- OOL, or Another position
  Boyd OOL
  Garoppolo- Backup
• sportchampps

  Bridgewater - backup
  Bortles - starter
  manziel - out of league
  Murray - backup
  Carr - Really good starter
  Mettenberger - backup
  
  rest will be ool
• Footwedge

  HighRoller74;1612046 wrote:Manziel will be better than every QB who has ever laced them up by this time next year. Rendering all other discussion pointless.

  
  As Abbott said to Costello..."now you've got it".
• Sonofanump

  Mettenberg- Colorado medicinal bar.
• rydawg5

  Bridgewater - Backup
  Bortles - Starter
  Manziel - Starter
  Murray - Starter
  Carr - out of NFL
  McCarron- out of NFL
  Savage - oh yeah
  Mettenberger - backup
  Thomas - out
  Boyd - out
  Garoppolo - out
• Footwedge

  Bridgewater out of football
  Bortles...cut this summer after training camp
  Manziel. First ballot HOF
  Murray Carr*
  McCarron*
  Savage*
  Mettenberger*
  Thomas*
  Garroppolo*
  
  *See Bridgewater
  
  Boyd. The only quarterback other than Manziel that will make it in the pros.
• SportsAndLady

  

  Footwedge;1613198 wrote:Bridgewater out of football
  Bortles...cut this summer after training camp
  Manziel. First ballot HOF
  Murray Carr*
  McCarron*
  Savage*
  Mettenberger*
  Thomas*
  Garroppolo*
  
  *See Bridgewater
  
  Boyd. The only quarterback other than Manziel that will make it in the pros.

  Don't feed the troll
• Laley23

  

  SportsAndLady;1613210 wrote:Don't feed the troll

  But I feel obligated to let everyone know its impossible for JFF to be in the HOF in 5 years. He has to play a snap to be eligible, and then be out of the league for 5 years...Literally impossible as of now.