Rank These QBs

• Ironman92

  

  Rank from best to worst
  
  Andy Dalton
  Colin Kaepernick
  RG3
  Alex Smith
  Cam Newton
  Joe Flacco
  Carson Palmer
• Ironman92

  

  Mine...
  
  Newton
  Kaepernick
  Flacco
  Smith
  Palmer
  Dalton
  RG3
• like_that

  

  I would flip rg3 and dalton.
• Ironman92

  

  like_that;1543237 wrote:I would flip rg3 and dalton.

  I had trouble with the last 4.
• se-alum

  

  Newton
  Smith
  Kaepernick
  Flacco
  RG3
  Dalton
  Palmer
• Classyposter58

  

  Newton
  Kaepernick
  Flacco
  RG3
  Smith
  Dalton
  Palmer
• Laley23

  

  Cam
  Flacco
  Smith
  Kap
  Palmer
  RG3
  Dalton
  
  But they are all way down on my list if you have every QB ranked in the NFL.
• Ironman92

  

  Laley23;1543260 wrote:Cam
  Flacco
  Smith
  Kap
  Palmer
  RG3
  Dalton
  
  But they are all way down on my list if you have every QB ranked in the NFL.

  Cam is working his way up mine....big, strong, fast and can pass. Cusp of top 10....maybe 10th.
  
  We've debated Manning/Brady....Romo/Roethlisberger
  
  These aren't the cream of the crop but I thought it might be a decent thread. Was interested if others had Cam above all these.....where to put Smith and what everyone thought of Palmer.
• SportsAndLady

  

  Right now, would you trade a 1st round pick for RG3?
• Ironman92

  

  I would not. I don't have much trust in RG3. Seems like he's already lost a step, doesn't seem to be a good leader and just gets destroyed 2-5 times a game....but I'm not very good at those trade for pick scenarios.
• Laley23

  

  Cam is for sure moving up. Id say close to top 10, but still outside. The others are on the wrong side of the midway point.
• Ironman92

  

  No order:
  
  Brady
  Manning
  Brees
  Rodgers
  Rivers
  Romo
  Roethlisberger
  Stafford
  
  Eli?
  Luck?
  Ryan?
  Cutler?
  Wilson?
  Foley?
  Bradford?
  
  
  I'd have Colin K in my top 1/2....probably Flacco as well. Not sure where to put Eli and Foley.
• Mulva

  

  I'd definitely put Cam in my top 10 right now. I'd go something like...
  
  Rodgers
  Manning
  Brees
  Brady
  Wilson
  Rivers
  Romo
  Cam
  Ben
  Luck
  
  Ryan and Stafford just missing out.
  
  As far as this list...
  
  Cam
  RGIII
  Flacco
  Kaep
  Smith
  Dalton
  Palmer
• Ironman92

  

  Most of you like RG3 more than me it looks. I just don't see it this year. Will he ever get to full speed after his knee injury?
  
  I'd take Kaepernick over him all day.
• Iliketurtles

  

  Newton
  Smith
  Kaep
  Palmer
  Flacco
  RG3
  Dalton
  
  I don't know if I would have Cam in my top 10 yet but its definitely getting close.
• Commander of Awesome

  

  Ironman92;1543233 wrote:Mine...
  
  Newton
  Kaepernick
  
  who gives a fuck bc the rest from here is garbage:
  RG3
  Flacco
  Smith
  Palmer
  Dalton

  That's mine.
• Heretic

  

  Cam Newton
  Colin Kaepernick
  Alex Smith
  RG3
  Joe Flacco
  Carson Palmer
  Andy Dalton
  
  Probably the toughest call for me was 2-3. Went with the streakier, younger guy with more upside over the solid, but unspectacular, game manager.
  
  Kind of the same with RG3's placement. Pretty much the feeling that he's not 100% and his performance this year shows that is what puts him above the bottom trio of One Great Postseason, Great Fantasy Stats In Mid 2000s But No Big Wins and Blah Ginger.
• Terry_Tate

  

  Cam Newton
  Colin Kaepernick
  RG3
  Alex Smith
  Andy Dalton
  Joe Flacco
  Carson Palmer
• Commander of Awesome

  

  Terry_Tate;1543687 wrote:Cam Newton
  Colin Kaepernick
  RG3
  Alex Smith
  Andy Dalton
  Joe Flacco
  Carson Palmer

  Faildy gonna get a Flacco type deal then? Please say yes.
• Heretic

  

  Speaking of Failacco, he's a real team player.
  
  http://sports.yahoo.com/news/ravens-flacco-lashes-against-wildcat-190531421--nfl.html
  
  Called out his organization for occasionally using the Wildcat to generate plays because of how the team has really been struggling because it makes them look like a high school offense, he wants to be behind taking all the snaps AND he feels that instead of bringing in new kinds of offensive plays, they should work to fix what is wrong with the base stuff.
  
  1. Gets 120M
  2. Suffers decline in performance; meanwhile team also is playing worse.
  3. Cries about how team is implementing "Flacco-Free" offensive plays.
  4. ???????
  5. PROFIT!
• Terry_Tate

  

  Commander of Awesome;1543692 wrote:Faildy gonna get a Flacco type deal then? Please say yes.

  I hope he doesn't play a meaningful snap for the Bengals after this season, which probably means you can bank on him getting a decent contract.
• said_aouita

  

  SportsAndLady;1543270 wrote:Right now, would you trade a 1st round pick for RG3?

  Great question. Obv I'm a rg3 homer....he's not healthy. RG3 also has been getting his ass kicked this year.
  Something needs to change but still willing to risk a late #1st rd pick on him.
  
  He was looking a lot better a few weeks ago. Past couple not so much.
  
  Also wondering who will be the new head coach.
• like_that

  

  said_aouita;1544141 wrote:Great question. Obv I'm a rg3 nut hugger....he's not healthy. RG3 also has been getting his ass kicked this year.
  Something needs to change but still willing to risk a late #1st rd pick on him.
  
  He was looking a lot better a few weeks ago. Past couple not so much.
  
  Also wondering who will be the new head coach.

  Fify. Also, something needs to be changed, but unfortunately they still don't have a first round pick to help themselves LOL.
  
  Also shannahan is a good coach, if the redskins use him as a scape goat that is a fail.
  
  This is just a recycled story for Dan Snyder. He tries to take short cuts to winning a SB by putting a lot of money in FA or mortgaging the franchises future for one player. Every single time he has done this, it has come back to bite him in the ass.
  
  I said it before id love for the browns to actually get their heads out of their asses and get to the playoffs, but not if it's for a flash in the pan season and then return back to mediocrity the following season.
• said_aouita

  

  like_that;1544174 wrote: I said it before id love for the browns to actually get their heads out of their asses and get to the playoffs, but not if it's for a flash in the pan season and then return back to mediocrity the following season.

  Pretty original fify. derp. smh
  
  
  
  
  What is considered a "flash in the pan" season for the Browns, when they finished 2nd in the division in 2007 or back during 2002?
  
  No doubt not taking risks and rebuilding at coma pace is working well for Cleveland.
• like_that

  

  said_aouita;1544331 wrote:Pretty original fify. derp. smh
  
  
  
  
  What is considered a "flash in the pan" season for the Browns, when they finished 2nd in the division in 2007 or back during 2002?
  
  No doubt not taking risks and rebuilding at coma pace is working well for Cleveland.

  Yes, and your "go browns" posts are very original lolfail.
  
  If the Browns traded 3 picks for RG3 they would be worse off than they are now. Hope this helps.
  
  Continue being butthurt because all that penis gobbling of RG3 has backfired on you.