Archive

QB fantasy advice for Champioship

  • miller45452003
    I'm stressed over this. This is for all the marbles ($500) and bragging rights for the year. Who do I start...

    McNabb VS Broncos
    OR
    Eli Manning VS Panthers

    My guts telling me Manning due to his hot play as of late and his push to make the playoffs .

    Open to suggestions!! Thanx
  • se-alum
    I agree w/ Manning.
  • Tony Romo
    ^
    ||
    ||
    ||
    This guy.
  • LeagueMVP
    McNabb
  • Fidmeister
    I learned last season there's only one Manning you can count on to be your fantasy quarterback and it sure as fuck isn't Eli.

    Don't forget that the Broncos are struggling and the Eagles never run it.
  • ohiobucks1
    I'd take Eli
  • trackandccrunner
    I'd find a new QB I don't think either one of these will have a good day... but if one does it will be McNabb.
  • stroups
    I would take Eli

    In my slot positions I have to pick between
    Cadillac Williams vs. the Saints

    or

    Hines Ward vs. the Ravens
  • hasbeen
    I would start McNabb. The Panthers have been playing well.

    Stroups - I'd play Hines.
  • capninsano
    McNabb and Hines....I don't think it's really that close.
  • DaBrowns41
    The Panthers defense actually isn't half bad.

    McNabb is the smart choice in this one, and it's not even close, IMO.
  • sleeper
    Here's one for you guys:

    Romo or McNabb
  • trackandccrunner
    Sleeper, I'd go Romo I look for him to continue to shine in December.
  • Nate
    Manning
  • hasbeen
    trackandccrunner wrote: Sleeper, I'd go Romo I look for him to continue to shine in December.
    I agree.
  • Walt
    I keep hearing rumblings that Peyton Manning may rest or at least not play the entire game tomorrow.

    Should I start him or start my back-up - Roethlisberger?
  • sportswizuhrd
    Jerome Harrison vs Raiders
    Maurice Morris vs Niners (he had alot of points last week vs ARI).
  • hasbeen
    Walt wrote: I keep hearing rumblings that Peyton Manning may rest or at least not play the entire game tomorrow.

    Should I start him or start my back-up - Roethlisberger?
    Manning will play depending in flow of the game. I think it is a safer bet to play Ben. Don't be surprised if Manning has decent stats regardless of his PT.
    sportswizuhrd wrote: Jerome Harrison vs Raiders
    Maurice Morris vs Niners (he had alot of points last week vs ARI).
    Harrison. I think he outscores Morris.
  • miller45452003
    Walt wrote: I keep hearing rumblings that Peyton Manning may rest or at least not play the entire game tomorrow.

    Should I start him or start my back-up - Roethlisberger?
    I'd say Roethlisberger. Baltimore's secondary is all banged up. I think there 2 starting cb's are out along with Ed Reed. Ben should provide large #'s. I hate the guy, but when it comes to winning the coin, you gotta play him.
  • DaBrowns41
    You started McNabb, I hope.
  • Walt
    I went with my gut and started Manning. Ben didn't have a great day but he scored 14 points in my league compared to only 7 for Manning when they benched him. Right now I'm down 5 in the championship so it looks like I cost myself a few hundred dollars.
  • DaBrowns41
    Walt wrote: I went with my gut and started Manning. Ben didn't have a great day but he scored 14 points in my league compared to only 7 for Manning when they benched him. Right now I'm down 5 in the championship so it looks like I cost myself a few hundred dollars.
    It was really a tough call for you.

    However, the guy starting Eli/McNabb should have easily picked McNabb, though I have a feeling he didn't.

    I would never have Eli as on of my Fantasy QB's.
  • miller45452003
    DaBrowns41 wrote:
    Walt wrote: I went with my gut and started Manning. Ben didn't have a great day but he scored 14 points in my league compared to only 7 for Manning when they benched him. Right now I'm down 5 in the championship so it looks like I cost myself a few hundred dollars.
    It was really a tough call for you.

    However, the guy starting Eli/McNabb should have easily picked McNabb, though I have a feeling he didn't.

    I would never have Eli as on of my Fantasy QB's.
    This would be me. And I did start McNabb. Good thing...he helped me cruise to my $500
  • DaBrowns41
    miller45452003 wrote:
    DaBrowns41 wrote:
    Walt wrote: I went with my gut and started Manning. Ben didn't have a great day but he scored 14 points in my league compared to only 7 for Manning when they benched him. Right now I'm down 5 in the championship so it looks like I cost myself a few hundred dollars.
    It was really a tough call for you.

    However, the guy starting Eli/McNabb should have easily picked McNabb, though I have a feeling he didn't.

    I would never have Eli as on of my Fantasy QB's.
    This would be me. And I did start McNabb. Good thing...he helped me cruise to my $500
    You're a smart man. :D
  • royal_k
    miller45452003 wrote:
    DaBrowns41 wrote:
    Walt wrote: I went with my gut and started Manning. Ben didn't have a great day but he scored 14 points in my league compared to only 7 for Manning when they benched him. Right now I'm down 5 in the championship so it looks like I cost myself a few hundred dollars.
    It was really a tough call for you.

    However, the guy starting Eli/McNabb should have easily picked McNabb, though I have a feeling he didn't.

    I would never have Eli as on of my Fantasy QB's.
    This would be me. And I did start McNabb. Good thing...he helped me cruise to my $500
    Good move and congratulations.