Best NBA player in New York City

• lhslep134

  

  I thought about this, well just a Melo vs. D Will, but I couldn't come up with a convincing answer
• hoops23

  

  Give me DWill 10 out of 10 times.
  
  He can score as efficiently as Melo, but he's also a great distributor. And I think he averaged a little more than 2 RPG less than Melo as a PG....
• lhslep134

  

  Carmelo is also like the 4th best scorer in the league in terms of ability, maybe higher. D Will might be able to score efficiently against other guards, but not as well as Melo does overall.
• Rotinaj

  

  Tebow.
• Pick6

  

  Tyson Chandler. DPOY baby
• killer_ewok

  

  Linsanity!
• hoops23

  

  killer_ewok;1219506 wrote:Linsanity

  
• BigAppleBuckeye

  

  DWill for sure ... the Knicks would trade Carmelo to the Nets for DWill in a heartbeat if they could. Nets stole their thunder with that trade (on the same day they got Carmelo), and they are destroying them this offseason.
• killer_ewok

  

  hoops23;1219509 wrote:

  
  I was kidding. I thought the exclamation point was over the top enough to convey that. Even though I am a huge Lin fan, Carmelo is my actual answer.
• hoops23

  

  killer_ewok;1219517 wrote:I was kidding. I thought the exclamation point was over the top enough to convey that. Even though I am a huge Lin fan, Carmelo is my actual answer.

  
• SportsAndLady

  

  Joel Anthony is the correct answer.
• killer_ewok

  

  hoops23;1219518 wrote:

  
  LOL
• killer_ewok

  

  lhslep134;1219317 wrote:Carmelo is also like the 4th best scorer in the league in terms of ability, maybe higher. D Will might be able to score efficiently against other guards, but not as well as Melo does overall.

  
  Agreed.
• robj55

  

  lhslep134;1219317 wrote:Carmelo is also like the 4th best scorer in the league in terms of ability, maybe higher. D Will might be able to score efficiently against other guards, but not as well as Melo does overall.

  Melo is like 6'8'' and shot 42% last year and was worse than that until the end of the year when he got hot for a few weeks, that's efficient?
• lhslep134

  

  robj55;1219814 wrote:Melo is like 6'8'' and shot 42% last year and was worse than that until the end of the year when he got hot for a few weeks, that's efficient?

  I'm not talking about stats I'm talking about if you told me I had a possession where I needed to score, I would take Carmelo's more efficient scoring ability than DWill's. Not a knock on DWill, just extolling Melo's ability.
  
  But if you asked me who I want for an entire game? Or season? I think my answer is DWill
• Heretic

  

  SportsAndLady;1219522 wrote:Joel Anthony is the correct answer.

  For every "best in/of" question known to man.
  
  MVP! MVP!
• Laley23

  

  Williams. Easily.
• vball10set

  ^^^He got my vote.