Reds @ Indians..... Game 3

• wildcats20

  

  Midstate01;1206666 wrote:MLB will take the error away right??

  I was just thinking that...
  
  There is NO WAY you can give a player an error when it was clearly a shit call.
• wildcats20

  

  Then again, I don't know why Joey didn't just turn and jog to the bag.
• justincredible

  

  Midstate01;1206666 wrote:MLB will take the error away right??

  I would hope so. Joey shouldn't be charge with an error on that.
• justincredible

  

  This game is horse shit.
• wildcats20

  

  They need to inform the league office that they are playing the rest of the game under protest.
  
  
  
  Not that that will do anything.
• BRF

  

  Midstate01;1206650 wrote:Oh it's over.

  Good call, my Reds fan!
• Midstate01

  

  wildcats20;1206672 wrote:They need to inform the league office that they are playing the rest of the game under protest.
  
  
  
  Not that that will do anything.

  
  We were gonna lose regardless. But that call was complete shit.
• BRF

  

  wildcats20;1206672 wrote:They need to inform the league office that they are playing the rest of the game under protest.

  In the old days, you had to say that before the next pitch. Not sure how that works these days.
• wildcats20

  

  Midstate01;1206674 wrote:We were gonna lose regardless. But that call was complete shit.

  I don't disagree, but 5-0 is a hell of a lot more doable than 8-0.
• Midstate01

  

  Shitsburgh just tied it up with the twins
• Midstate01

  

  wildcats20;1206677 wrote:I don't disagree, but 5-0 is a hell of a lot more doable than 8-0.

  
  I agree there.
• Footwedge

  Unfortunately the error will stand. But in my view, the ss should get the errorr, not Votto. Come on, the throw was not that bad.
  
  It's too bad that a play like that can't be reviewed. But in baseball, you can't really review something like that because there are no dead balls like other sports.
• mhs95_06

  mhs95_06;1206583 wrote:The Reds need to score 8 to have a chance to win, depending on how many runs Dusty leaves Bronson in there for. I'm afraid the Indians lefties will tattoo Bronson.

  Even 8 won't win it now, after 3 unearned runs off Simon after one of the worst calls I've ever seen an ump make that prolongs the Indians 7th. Santana was obviously a force out at 2nd both before Cozart adjusted the position of the ball in his glove and after. Atrocious call! Its the same ump that wouldn't call any strikes until the Reds' 9th on Monday when they needed one to tie, then he called ones he hadn't been calling all night, plus some that were out of the zone!
• wildcats20

  

  Footwedge;1206681 wrote:Unfortunately the error will stand. But in my view, the ss should get the errorr, not Votto. Come on, the throw was not that bad.
  
  It's too bad that a play like that can't be reviewed. But in baseball, you can't really review something like that because there are no dead balls like other sports.

  False.
  
  Timeout was called right after the play. That is a dead ball. They do it for home runs. They could do it for much, much more.
  
  That is an embarrassment to the umpiring profession.
• mhs95_06

  wildcats20;1206667 wrote:I was just thinking that...
  
  There is NO WAY you can give a player an error when it was clearly a **** call.

  Just like you shouldn't be able to collar a hitter with a K and 0/1 on a called strike 3 that is obviously 10" outside!
• Footwedge

  BRF;1206676 wrote:In the old days, you had to say that before the next pitch. Not sure how that works these days.

  Playing a games under protest can't be filed on a judgement call...no matter how bad the judgement. Misinterpretation of the rules was grounds for a protest.
  
  In any event, there's no doubt that the tribe is much better than the Peglegs. Last weekend was GOAT freak of nature in the annals of baseball.
• Footwedge

  wildcats20;1206686 wrote:False.
  
  Timeout was called right after the play. That is a dead ball. They do it for home runs. They could do it for much, much more.
  
  That is an embarrassment to the umpiring profession.

  It's not false. No whistle blew. What if a runner was on second and tried to score on that play? The throw to the plate is late and a merry go round ensues?
  
  You do not understand the point I'm trying to make.
• Midstate01

  

  Footwedge;1206690 wrote:Playing a games under protest can't be filed on a judgement call...no matter how bad the judgement. Misinterpretation of the rules was grounds for a protest.
  
  In any event, there's no doubt that the tribe is much better than the Peglegs. Last weekend was GOAT freak of nature in the annals of baseball.

  
  It's 35-30 right now.. Score wise for the 2 series.
• mhs95_06

  Footwedge;1206681 wrote:Unfortunately the error will stand. But in my view, the ss should get the errorr, not Votto. Come on, the throw was not that bad.
  
  It's too bad that a play like that can't be reviewed. But in baseball, you can't really review something like that because there are no dead balls like other sports.

  A throw in the dirt, or a pitch in the dirt always goes against the thrower, but yet fielders of bouncing balls regularly get errors on hit balls in the dirt that are more difficult than a lot of the throws in the dirt that go against the thrower!
• wildcats20

  

  Footwedge;1206692 wrote:It's not false. No whistle blew. What if a runner was on second and tried to score on that play? The throw to the plate is late and a merry go round ensues?
  
  You do not understand the point I'm trying to make.

  TIME OUT WAS CALLED AKA DEAD BALL.
• Midstate01

  

  36-30
• Midstate01

  

  wildcats20;1206696 wrote:TIME OUT WAS CALLED AKA DEAD BALL.

  
  Time was called. Baker came out. Thus a time out had to have been issued.
• wildcats20

  

  Midstate01;1206699 wrote:Time was called. Baker came out. Thus a time out had to have been issued.

  Exactly.
  
  But no, there are no dead balls in baseball :rolleyes:
• hoops23

  

  They should have changed the shot clock back to 5 seconds
• Midstate01

  

  hoops23;1206702 wrote:They should have changed the shot clock back to 5 seconds

  
  Truf