Archive

NFL 2012 - who has the best season for a qb?

  • said_aouita
    Which QB has the best statistical (individual) season?
  • OneBuckeye
    Brady, Brees or Stafford. I will go with Brady as his WRs have been upgraded big time.
  • Commander of Awesome
    I thought Rivers was going to an MVP candidate last season, lolfail. Its between Brady or Rodgers for me this season.
  • Skyhook79
    What are you going by? Yds,TD's,%, QBR,QB rating,fewest Int's, wins? Also Cam Newton not being in the poll is wrong.
  • BR1986FB
    Gabbert...j/k

    And seriously, RG3? I liked him alot but c'mon? Should not be on this list.
  • Commander of Awesome
    Probably would have said the same about Newton last season.
  • BR1986FB
    Commander of Awesome;1121899 wrote:Probably would have said the same about Newton last season.
    Don't get me wrong, I think he's going to be great but I don't think he'll have a Newton-like rookie season. If he does, Holmgren is going to look like a bigger dufus than he already does.
  • said_aouita
    Skyhook79;1121896 wrote:Also Cam Newton not being in the poll is wrong.
    Going by last year you are right. Yer gonna hate it but I substituted S Bradford for him.
  • BR1986FB
    said_aouita;1121902 wrote:Going by last year you are right. Yer gonna hate it but I substituted S Bradford for him.
    You left Newton off but put RG3 on? C'mon, man...
  • said_aouita
    BR1986FB;1121898 wrote:Gabbert...j/k

    And seriously, RG3? I liked him alot but c'mon? Should not be on this list.
    I was considering making this poll only between Luck, RGiii and P Manning* but figured everyone would pick PM.
    *The 3 qb's who have been in the news the most during the offseason /\.

    Like mentioned above, Cam N should have been on the list. Also this being an Ohio website I was considering A Dalton.

    Shoulda had other as a choice. If yer qb ain't in the poll, just post 'em.
  • shook_17
    lol seriously considering andy dalton? either cam newton or aarron rodgers.
  • Skyhook79
    said_aouita;1121902 wrote:Going by last year you are right. Yer gonna hate it but I substituted S Bradford for him.
    Makes sense.
  • Raw Dawgin' it
    Brady - their D still sucks so their O be on the field a lot.
  • LJ
    BR1986FB;1121901 wrote: If he does, Holmgren is going to look like a bigger dufus than he already does.
    Impossible. The complaining that the Redskins used personal relationships with the Rams front office to get the deal done when he did the same exact thing to get Hasselbeck in 2001 sealed the deal on that.
  • Commander of Awesome
    Raw Dawgin' it;1121946 wrote:Brady - their D still sucks so their O be on the field a lot.
  • said_aouita
    Skyhook79;1121942 wrote:Makes sense.
    I'm sure you could make a new poll with cam as a choice. I like St Louis.
  • georgemc80
    What no Schaub? He is statistically better than Romo, RG3, Bradford, Luck, E. Manning, and Rothliesberger
  • DeyDurkie5
    colt mccoy


    /deydurkied
  • Automatik
    Arod or Brady.
  • sleeper
    Drew Brees. Hands down.
  • Ironman92
    Duffy Waldorf
  • ichsnjb
    Brees, Brady, and Roethlisberger.