Archive

For this season, what order would you choose a starting QB to start for your team?

  • rydawg5
    1. Tom Brady (Pats)
    2. Aaron Rogers (Packers)
    3. Peyton Manning (Colts)
    4. Drew Brees (Saints)
    5. Phillip Rivers (Chargers)
    6. Big Ben (Steelers)
    7. Matt Ryan (Falcons)
    8. Michael Vick (Eagles)
    9. Tony Romo (Cowboys)
    10. Kevin Kolb (Cardinals)
    11. Eli Manning (Giants)
    12. Matt Schaub (Texans)
    13. Josh Freeman (Bucs)
    14. Kyle Orton (Broncos)
    15. Jay Cutler (Bears)
    16. Joe Flacco (Ravens)
    17. Sam Bradford (Rams)
    18. Matt Stafford (Lions)
    19. Matt Hasselback (Titans)
    20. Mark Sanchez (Jets)
    21. Matt Cassel (Chiefs)
    22. Ryan Fitzpatrick (Bills)
    23. Donovan Mcnabb (Vikings)
    24. Colt McCoy (Browns)
    25. Chad Henne (Dolphins)
    26. David Garrard (Jags)
    27. im missing someone.
    28. Jason Campbell or Raiders QB
    29. Charlie Whitehurst or Seahwaks QB
    30. Alex Smith or 49ers QB
    31. Cam Newton (Panthers)
    32. Andy Dalton (Bengals)
  • Ironman92
    I'll go

    Brady
    Rodgers
    Brees
    Roethlisberger
    Vick
    Manning
    Ryan
  • brutus161
    Ironman92;869608 wrote:I'll go

    Brady
    Rodgers
    Brees
    Roethlisberger
    Vick
    Manning
    Ryan

    Not having Rivers on you list, makes it null and void.
  • Ironman92
    brutus161;869612 wrote:Not having Rivers on you list, makes it null and void.

    Rivers is next.....I don't want him leading my team over the guys I mentioned. If he'd have ever won anything of importance then I couldn't argue much.....debated over he and Ryan
  • Ironman92
    brutus161;869612 wrote:Not having Rivers on you list, makes it null and void.

    And you not participating should make your comment null and void.
  • GoChiefs
    Rogers
    Brady
    Brees
    Manning
    Rivers
    Ryan
    Vick
  • Ironman92
    GoChiefs;869635 wrote:Rogers
    Brady
    Brees
    Manning
    Rivers
    Ryan
    Vick

    How far down do you have Ben?
  • Laley23
    1. Rodgers
    2. P. Manning
    3. Brady
    4. Brees
    5. Rivers
    6. Ryan
    7. Vick
    8. Big Ben
  • I Am Ahab
    Brady
    Manning
    Brees (Rodgers)
    Rodgers (Brees)
    Rapistberger
  • End of Line
    Brady
    P. Manning
    Rodgers
    Brees
    Big Ben
    Rivers
    Vick
    Schaub
    Ryan
    Cassell
  • brutus161
    Ironman92;869628 wrote:And you not participating should make your comment null and void.

    Brady
    Rivers
    Rogers
    Manning
    Brees
    Ben
    Ryan
    Vick
    Shaub
    McCoy (just because I think he is going to have a great year)
  • GoChiefs
    Ironman92;869638 wrote:How far down do you have Ben?

    You will never see him on a list from me. :D
  • georgemc80
    Rogers
    Brady
    Brees
    Vick
    Schaub
    Rivers
    Big Ben

    For this season, I am not confident in Peyton Manning due to possible injury...If he comes back 100% healthy he jumps into the top 3.
  • justincredible
    Mark Sanchez, because I don't live in fantasy land and he's the only option the Jets have.

    For serious, I do think Sanchez is going to have a great year but my top 3 would be:

    Rodgers
    Brady
    Manning
  • Commander of Awesome
    Rodgers
    Brady
    Rivers
  • Iliketurtles
    1)Brady
    2)Rivers
    3)Rodgers
    4)Manning
    5)Brees
    6)Romo
    7)Big Ben
    8)Ryan
    9)Schaub
    10)Vick
    11)Eli
    12)Flacco
    13)Kolb
    14)Bradford
    15)Stafford
    16)Freeman
  • sportchampps
    Rodgers
    Vick
    Brees
    Manning
    Rivers
    Romo

    I have Romo up there due to his easy scheaduel
  • justincredible
    sportchampps;871318 wrote:easy scheaduel

    Apparently spelling it isn't so easy. :p
  • robj55
    justincredible;871396 wrote:Apparently spelling it isn't so easy. :p

    haha nice
  • thedynasty1998
    Brady
    Rodgers
    Rivers
    Manning
    Vick
    Brees
    Schaub
    Freeman
    Ben
    Ryan
  • Ironman92
    Not sure how my list is the only one questioned.
  • Non
    1. Roethlisberger
    2. Rodgers
    3. Brady
    4. Manning
    5. Rivers

    I honestly don't think the other great QBs would last behind the Steelers offensive line.

    Rodgers is mobile but he still doesn't take the beating that Ben takes with defensive players hanging all over him and smashing him in the face.

    Maybe by getting rid of the ball sooner it would take away some of the hits but there still would be enough to get injured.
  • rydawg5
    Ironman92;871860 wrote:Not sure how my list is the only one questioned.

    It's a personal choice, so for someone to question your personal choice is idiotic.
  • Laley23
    Non;871863 wrote:1. Roethlisberger
    2. Rodgers
    3. Brady
    4. Manning
    5. Rivers

    I honestly don't think the other great QBs would last behind the Steelers offensive line.

    Rodgers is mobile but he still doesn't take the beating that Ben takes with defensive players hanging all over him and smashing him in the face.

    Maybe by getting rid of the ball sooner it would take away some of the hits but there still would be enough to get injured.

    You need to watch the Colts more often. That O-Line is one of the worst Ive ever seen....and it got worse in the offseason. Gonna be a long year again for Manning and Co.

    Nothing against Ben, but he wouldnt last in the Colts O-Line with how long he holds the ball. Peytons quick release is the only thing that keeps him alive.
  • Non
    Laley23;872009 wrote:You need to watch the Colts more often. That O-Line is one of the worst Ive ever seen....and it got worse in the offseason. Gonna be a long year again for Manning and Co.

    Nothing against Ben, but he wouldnt last in the Colts O-Line with how long he holds the ball. Peytons quick release is the only thing that keeps him alive.

    It would be an interesting experiment seeing Peyton with the Steelers.

    The Steelers have some good offensive weapons so with either a strong offensive line in front of Ben or a QB with a quick release, they would be pretty dangerous.

    As far as the Colts, I think they'll surprise and be right there again. Steelers, Colts and Patriots I have a hard time counting out.