Curtis Granderson or Grady Sizemore?

• Footwedge

  Remenber when this used to inspire a debate?
• Laley23

  

  It still would, then Granderson made adjustments and can rocket balls off lefties. Grady never made a single adjustment his whole career. Granderson completely changed his swing and is now in prime position to go for an MVP award. Too bad Grady is so stubborn.
• royal_k

  

  Yeah, this used to be a legit debate. But Laley hit hit on the head. And you throw in Grady's injuries and you have 2 completely different players now.
• dat dude

  I remember those days. Being a Tigers' fan, I always sided with Granderson. Definitely pulled it all together.
• HitsRus

  

  How much of that is coaching. Might have to blame Wedge and Shelton. Last year, Grady was hurt, and I'm not sure he's fully recovered. I'm not making excuses for him...just sayin'.
• Writerbuckeye

  

  Are we discussing who's the better baseball player or who is better at taking pictures of himself in front of a mirror? If it's the latter, Grady wins hands down.
  
  
• kayo

  Hits - You know I like you, man, but you've got to give it a rest. As noted above, Granderson made changes to his swing and it has paid benefits. Had Sizemore's plummet came on the heels of a swing change you would've been all over the coaches (see Brandon Phillips). Sizemore is as lost now as Granderson was early last year - there's no saying he won't get back to where he was.
• riders1

  

  Granderson, the Grandyman can!