Andy Petite to retire Friday

• september63

  

  Is he a HOF'er? Would he have been had he not been involved with HGH?
• Al Bundy

  september63;663431 wrote:Is he a HOF'er? Would he have been had he not been involved with HGH?

  
  He's not a hall of famer. He spent the majority of his career with the team that had the most wins in that time period, and he only finished with 240. His career ERA of 3.88 is nothing special. He was a good pitcher, but not HOF.
• mhs95_06

  No and No
• Sonofanump

  No especially if Jack Morris is not in.
• darbypitcher22

  

  He has the most post season wins of any pitcher of all time... how can he not be in?
• Ironman92

  

  Pettitte was a pretty crafty pitcher for a pretty long time.....admire how well he did without having dominant stuff.
• Al Bundy

  darbypitcher22;663819 wrote:He has the most post season wins of any pitcher of all time... how can he not be in?

  
  He has the most post season wins because of the expanded playoffs. For historical comparison, World Series wins is what needs to be compared.
• fiction

  

  really good pitcher, but never really a very top of the rotation kind of guy. not a hall of famer, but a great career.
• killdeer

  

  Baseball HOF remains the most exclusive club.
  
  
  Pettitte......No, great player, but not HOF'er. His association with HGH certainly does not help his case, as it is clear that all Performance Enhancer's are given the stop sign....