Ohio Chatter DEV

september63

Troy Smith's career thus far or Brady Quinn's?

wes_mantooth

Brady Quinn by far.

Brady was a 1st rounder.....Troy was not supposed to be a good nfl qb..according to the experts.

gerb131

Push

Prescott

The Browns gave up a 2nd round pick and a 1st round pick to get Quinn.That is too much for what Quinn gave them on the field.

Y-Town Steelhound

Um....is this even a debate?

Brady Quinn was a first rounder, Troy Smith was a fifth rounder.

Brady Quinn has a losing record as a starter, Troy Smith has an even record

Brady Quinn's career passer rating is 66.8, Troy Smith's is 80.0

Brady Quinn has thrown 9 career interceptions, Troy Smith has thrown 4

Brady Quinn was coached by all world offensive schematic genius Charlie Weis, Troy Smith was not

Brady Quinn was highly touted out of high school, Troy Smith was not

Brady Quinn is a 3rd string quarterback, Troy Smith is a 1st/2nd string quarterback.

I'd say Brady's career has been much more disappointing given his expectations...

stroups

Is this a real question?

Fly4Fun

Not really up for debate... Brady Quinn has easily been the bigger disappointment. And I am not sure if you can call Troy's career a disappointment at all... he was a 5th round quarterback pick. The fact that he's at the very worst a serviceable backup quarterback means he is doing well for himself.

Automatik

Is BQ 3rd string behind Tebow?

stroups

Im actually interested if somebody can make a case for bq..... I got nothing

wildcats20

Automatik;593069 wrote:Is BQ 3rd string behind Tebow?

No BQ is 2nd string.

http://www.denverbroncos.com/team/depth-chart.html

september63

I just wanted opinions so the ND Homers could see what rational fans thought.

mallymal614

ernest_t_bass

I thought Troy was starting. How is he a disappointment?

september63

The 49ers have demoted Troy Smith and are going back to Alex Smith this week.

Laley23

Curious, as I havent been on the College FBall board recently. But do people actually think Quinn has been more successful, or in the case of the question, less of a disappointment?

I follow ND, and Quinn has blown.

Ender Wiggin

.....................This isnt a real topic is it?

Get the fuck outta here with this trash.

Troy Smith won the games the 49ers SHOULDVE won.

I dont take Singletarys judgement as anything as he will be fired in a few months.

DaBrowns41

wes_mantooth;592960 wrote:Brady Quinn by far.

Brady was a 1st rounder.....Troy was not supposed to be a good nfl qb..according to the experts.

Well, before the National Championship game, Troy Smith was ranked higher than Quinn on most big boards.

But, after the NC game, Troy's height and lack of accuracy became an issue all of a sudden.

Quinn's not a terrible QB, but he's never going to amount to anything. He'll be a career backup. I bet Arizona would much rather have him than John Skelton, Derek "LOL" Anderson, or Max Hall, right now. Smith is just terribly inaccurate. You never saw it at Ohio State because all he did was throw bombs down field, and hit his fast receivers over the middle of the field.

killer_ewok