Adam Dunn: Great player or Greatest player?

• RiverRat13

  I'll go with greatest player.
• Laley23

  

  Easily the GOAT!
• justincredible

  

  Greatest player. BTW, I am going to move this to the Pro Sports forum. We've got one of those now.
• RiverRat13

  Oops. Sorry.
• stroups

  

  Defensively - he was a solid as I have ever seen
  
  Offensively - he lacked power but made up for it by just making contact and his superb base running skills
  
  I would say the greatest player in my lifetime
• jordo212000

  

  He's been called the songbird of his generation
• Sage

  

  Adam Dunn is my favorite worst player.
• RiverRat13

  stroups wrote: Defensively - he was a solid as I have ever seen
  
  Offensively - he lacked power but made up for it by just making contact and his superb base running skills
  
  I would say the greatest player in my lifetime

  Hmmm... Incomplete answer. You forgot to address his scrappyness factor. I'll help:
  
  Scrappyness:
  Adam Dunn>Ryan Freel