Ice Cream lovers …

• QuakerOats

  Love all kinds >> current favorite, by a wide margin, is the chocolate covered pretzel in vanilla from Ruggles. Hard not to eat the entire container once you start.
• I Wear Pants

  New Baltimore has pretty tasty ice cream. I think Jeni's is fantastic as well.
• Sonofanump

  gerb131;1516324 wrote:Vanilla or peanut butter.
  Place in Sandusky can't remember it now but the peanut butter is the best I've had

  Tofts?
• Sonofanump

  I actually prefer frozen custard from Stricklands. Black raspberry or banana.
• Iliketurtles

  

  Sonofanump;1516401 wrote:Tofts?

  Yeah it has to be Tofts. Great place to go to before Cedar Point.
• thavoice

  reclegend22;1516362 wrote:Chocolate and vanilla swirl with sprinkles from Mr. Freeze in Perrysburg, Ohio. The best ice cream in the state. Never had better.
  
  The worst: Chocolate and vanilla cone from the general store in Deerville, Ohio. There was a fucking small band-aid inside of it. I'm pretty sure that town is where they shot The Hills Have Eyes.

  SPent a month in the area that one of the original Hills Have Eyes was shot...and it wasnt in Ohio!!!
• Fab4Runner

  

  Toft's, Jeni's, Graeter's, Handel's, and Mr. Freeze are all delicious.
  
  As for a couple that have not been mentioned, I will go with Kenmore Freeze in Akron and Paul's in Shelby.
  
  Oh and my favorite flavors are chocolate, vanilla, swirl and cookie dough.
• Laley23

  

  Mr. Freeze in Perrysburg, OH. Used to ride my bike there 3 times a week when it was open for it. Still make the stop whenever I work in BG/Perrysburg.
• Commander of Awesome

  

  Graeters is the GOAT /discussion
  
  When I was living on the east coast, a friend of mine was going to cincy and asked me where to go eat/things to do. I said, just go to graeters, you're welcome. She rolled her eyes then proceeded to tell me about ice cream in new england that was the best yadda yadda. Anyways, she made it to Graeters (og location I believe) and became an instant believer. She said, she didn't want to like it, but couldn't help it.
  
  Haven't had store bought ice cream in a really long time, but I recall really liking Texas Gold's cookies 'n' cream.
• thavoice

  Ironman92;1516369 wrote:I had a "milkshake" from a dairy bar in Vinton County....worst ice cream product I've ever had.
  
  My aunt owns a popular and historic ice cream shop in Jackson and the "bubble" can hold it's own against about any ice cream product

  What is this "milkshake" think ya speak of?
  
  I prefer partially gelatinated non-dairy gum-based beverages
• thavoice

  Iliketurtles;1516317 wrote:Dietsch's Brothers in Findlay, Ohio best ice cream in the world. Black Raspberry Chocolate Chunk is my favorite from them. Anytime I come back up to visit friends/family I always make sure to get some to take back home.
  
  Also a big fan of Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough.

  Great place, been there a couple of times!
  
  Place I love to go to is Scoops at Lake James in Indiana. Great little icre cream shop with great flavors.
  
  
  
  Also a great place in downtown piqua but I cannot remember what it is called.
• Heretic

  

  Commander of Awesome;1516428 wrote:Haven't had store bought ice cream in a really long time, but I recall really liking Texas Gold's cookies 'n' cream.

  Texas Gold is probably the best store-bought I've had. I really haven't had much ice cream since I started the whole diet/fitness deal a couple years ago. One of the few things I regret cutting from my average diet. A couple weeks ago while visiting my mom, I snagged a single-serve Ben and Jerry's chocolate fudge brownie sort of deal from her freezer and that was probably the first ice cream I had in some time.
• GOONx19

  

  Katie's Korner is my favorite in Trumbull County.
• dlazz

  thavoice;1516429 wrote:
  I prefer partially gelatinated non-dairy cum-based beverages

  Nobody is surprised
• lhslep134

  

  GOONx19;1516438 wrote:Katie's Korner is my favorite in Trumbull County.

  As a kid I LOVED their bubble gum flavor with actual gumballs in it.
• reclegend22

  

  Anyone ever been to Deb's Golden Bear full-menu ice cream parlor in Applecreek? Used to pass it all the time on my way to my grandfather's who lived in New Philly. Always wanted to stop as a kid, but never did because my Dad was an asshole. J/k. Just never stopped. We always went to the Dairy Queen-styled place called Frank's Treat Time in Crestline instead.
• #1DBag

  

  The Vermonster at Ben & Jerry's
• BRF

  

  Ice Cream.......
  
  It's the devil's brew.
  
  Swing by and pick me up for that drive, Belly.
  
  Just don't order a cone.
  
  I can't stand seeing a man licking a cone.
• sportchampps

  Hey belly I'll save u a 40 mile drive brickers is closed in Hudson FedEx kinkos took over their spot
• reclegend22

  

  sportchampps;1516608 wrote:Hey belly I'll save u a 40 mile drive brickers is closed in Hudson FedEx kinkos took over their spot

  Now that's funny. Haha. Too bad.
• Dr Winston O'Boogie

  

  Mitchell's in greater Cleveland is my favorite of all time. I love Graeters, but I vote Mitchell's number 1.
• OSH

  

  Jeni's is great.
  
  I am more of a milkshake fan though, B Spot's Peach Cobbler milkshake is the best I've had.
• Belly35

  

  sportchampps;1516608 wrote:Hey belly I'll save u a 40 mile drive brickers is closed in Hudson FedEx kinkos took over their spot

  nooooooooooooooo Did they closed or just moved someplace? Where?
  
  It been a few years ... Did they really closed... Please tell they moved into that new Hudson shopping area?
• Fab1b

  

  I'll take damn near any Ben & Jerry's! Love Culver's frozen custards, Braum's banana splits, Rita's gelato, Steak n Shake shakes,) oh hell damn near any ice cream is good.
• Ironman92

  

  reclegend22;1516382 wrote:Never been to Jackson, but the Bubble sounds delicious, whatever it is. Is that it in the pic above?
  
  Also, slight correction to my post above. My cone with HIV sprinkles was purchased in Deersville in Harrison County, not Deerville. Just googled that sophisticated cosmopolis and it is inhabited by 79 people, which explains everything. What a fucking hole. Beware of getting any food there.

  Yeah....that pic is the traditional bubble and if you get one for there it will look just like that except they'll give you more crushed nuts.
  
  They use high end products and toppings and it's not too cheap but it is awesome.
  
  Scoop of French vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce over that, another scoop of ice cream, ample topping of smooth marshmallow, scoop of ice cream, some more marshmallow and a generous portion of crushed nuts which are made fresh every morning in their peanut roaster which is nearly 100 years old......they have a significant business selling the nuts in many varieties. Jackson County isn't good for much....but the bubble is a must try.