Archive

Would you kill me??

  • Heretic
    justincredible;1376940 wrote:Weed that's...too good?

    Well, you know, too big of a step up for one person to handle at once. Kind of like if one day, you were partying with regular college cheap stuff. And the next day, you spent all day smoking with Snoop and Willie Nelson. You might not live. It would be the most glorious death ever, but I'd prefer to gradually build my way up to the elite-good stuff.

    Anyway, what was this thread about? Whatevs, it's about toking now. The OP would approve.
  • Heretic
    like_that;1376984 wrote:FIFY

    Come on heretic.
    You raise a good point. Especially since my supply is about out and I at least haven't heard back yet from "my people".

    So I'm taking donations.
  • Fly4Fun
    I don't believe in a god for a multitude of reasons. However, the one thing I thought interesting was that the question presumes that humans have an internal moral code where it is possible that morality is entirely society based (like most things, it is most likely a combination of the two).

    Also, I find it amusing that fathobbit admits that he would kill someone if commanded to by a pillar of fire (an example of something that would convince him). Some suffering from psychosis, such as schizophrenia, can easily have hallucinations (generally auditory) but other forms as well including visual. So he is saying that it is justified for someone suffering from a psychotic break to kill someone?

    I agree that someone suffering from such mental disorders needs mental help (more than just being stuffed in a prison). But I don't think I could in my right mind actually condone that kind of behavior.
  • FatHobbit
    Fly4Fun;1376995 wrote:Also, I find it amusing that fathobbit admits that he would kill someone if commanded to by a pillar of fire (an example of something that would convince him).
    I do not believe in god either, but I am open to the possibility that a god exists. I never said I would be convinced by a pillar of fire, only that I would be more likely to believe something visual than random voices in my head. Obviously if I had a mental condition that leaves me open to mistakenly killing DA.
    Fly4Fun;1376995 wrote:Some suffering from psychosis, such as schizophrenia, can easily have hallucinations (generally auditory) but other forms as well including visual. So he is saying that it is justified for someone suffering from a psychotic break to kill someone?
    If I had a mental condition and killed DA at a hallucinations request it would not be justified, but I would be crazy so I probably wouldn't care.
  • Fly4Fun
    FatHobbit;1377001 wrote:I do not believe in god either, but I am open to the possibility that a god exists. I never said I would be convinced by a pillar of fire, only that I would be more likely to believe something visual than random voices in my head. Obviously if I had a mental condition that leaves me open to mistakenly killing DA.
    I'm open to the possibility as well. I just currently have yet to see, hear or read anything that would make me think so and I doubt I will. Now if I die and end up in some kind of afterlife, then I'd probably start to reconsider my current stance.
    FatHobbit;1377001 wrote:If I had a mental condition and killed DA at a hallucinations request it would not be justified, but I would be crazy so I probably wouldn't care.
    How are you not saying it would be justified? You're saying that you would do it because it was obviously alright since God commanded you. That is a justification right there.
  • justincredible
    Heretic;1376991 wrote:You raise a good point. Especially since my supply is about out and I at least haven't heard back yet from "my people".

    So I'm taking donations.
    My supply is almost out and I don't have "people" so I don't want to hear it.
  • Big_Mirg_ZHS
    justincredible;1377005 wrote:My supply is almost out and I don't have "people" so I don't want to hear it.
    Someone say weed??
  • justincredible
    How about this? We kill DA and take his stash.
  • gorocks99
    justincredible;1377012 wrote:How about this? We kill DA and take his stash.
    Seconded. Motion carries. After party at my house, I'll supply the hot-n-ready.
  • FatHobbit
    Fly4Fun;1377003 wrote:How are you not saying it would be justified? You're saying that you would do it because it was obviously alright since God commanded you. That is a justification right there.
    I guess I'm saying if I'm crazy, it's not justified. If God really is talking to me, it would be justified. lol
  • Fly4Fun
    FatHobbit;1377035 wrote:I guess I'm saying if I'm crazy, it's not justified. If God really is talking to me, it would be justified. lol
    And in that difference is the entire point of the question. It is infinitely more likely that a person receiving a message from God is either a liar or suffering from some kind of psychosis.
  • Commander of Awesome
    Fly4Fun;1377041 wrote:And in that difference is the entire point of the question. It is infinitely more likely that a person receiving a message from God is either a liar or suffering from some kind of psychosis.
  • Devils Advocate
    justincredible;1377012 wrote:How about this? We kill DA and take his stash.
    [/IMG]
  • Devils Advocate
    Fly4Fun;1377041 wrote:And in that difference is the entire point of the question. It is infinitely more likely that a person receiving a message from God is either a liar or suffering from some kind of psychosis.


    Link?

    Lotz of people think that god is on their side.




    The point is if you are crazy or faithful enough to hear God's bidding, you would bid the enire county,if that was what wuz bade.


    So which is it f4f, are you a Bader or a badee?
  • Fly4Fun
    Devils Advocate;1377106 wrote:Link?

    Lotz of people think that god is on their side.




    The point is if you are crazy or faithful enough to hear God's bidding, you would bid the enire county,if that was what wuz bade.


    So which is it f4f, are you a Bader or a badee?
    I don't understand the question.
  • O-Trap
    Based on my own Dispensational views, I would instead question my own sanity, but I would not kill you.
  • believer
    O-Trap;1377142 wrote:Based on my own Dispensational views, I would instead question my own sanity, but I would not kill you.
    Which Dispensational scheme would that fall under? ;)
  • Devils Advocate
    O-Trap;1377142 wrote:Based on my own Dispensational views, I would instead question my own sanity, but I would not kill you.

    Awwwwww.... Cmon Oman, I would have expected at least a mini essay form you on this.
  • O-Trap
    believer;1377146 wrote:Which Dispensational scheme would that fall under? ;)

    Well, virtually all of them, other than NON-Dispensational. ;)
    Devils Advocate;1377148 wrote:Awwwwww.... Cmon Oman, I would have expected at least a mini essay form you on this.
    Nah. I'm pretty sure nobody wants to read that from me. I'm sure I've made myself clear enough in the past that it isn't necessary.
  • Apple
    Why would God ask someone to kill someone else? He's GOD. He can do anything Himself!
  • Heretic
    justincredible;1377005 wrote:My supply is almost out and I don't have "people" so I don't want to hear it.
    I re-up'd my supply, so I'm good now!
  • FatHobbit
    Apple;1377478 wrote:Why would God ask someone to kill someone else? He's GOD. He can do anything Himself!
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binding_of_Isaac
  • FatHobbit
    Heretic;1377505 wrote:I re-up'd my supply, so I'm good now!
    That sounds like an invitation.
  • Devils Advocate
    Apple;1377478 wrote:Why would God ask someone to kill someone else? He's GOD. He can do anything Himself!
    And yet he gave his only son\thread :rolleyes:
  • Sonofanump
    Devils Advocate;1376759 wrote:
    This is not what I pictured in my mind that you looked like.