Archive

What about T.Pryor?

  • Automatik
    bo shemmy3337;705340 wrote:Hes 30-4 as a starter, 2-1 in BCS games, owns several OSU records, and undefeated against Michigan. Thats not opinion, its fact.

    Those are team numbers and I still feel an average QB would have put up very similar numbers.

    So the passing records are team numbers? What about rushing stats? Which "average" QB could have done the same?

    Bauserman? So he can make drive saving 1st downs with his legs?
  • LJ
    bo shemmy3337;705342 wrote:I will give you the highlights but all those numbers were there before he got there. Troy Smith did just as good IMO yet he is viewed as no TP.

    TP had better stats his Jr year than Smith did the year he won the Heisman
  • bo shemmy3337
    Automatik;705344 wrote:So the passing records are team numbers? What about rushing stats?

    Yes passing has a lot to do with the great WR's he has and yes he is a good runner but the team would not be bad off if he never went to OSU IMO.
  • LJ
    bo shemmy3337;705348 wrote:Yes passing has a lot to do with the great WR's he has and yes he is a good runner but the team would not be bad off if he never went to OSU IMO.

  • bo shemmy3337
    LJ;705346 wrote:TP had better stats his Jr year than Smith did the year he won the Heisman

    Again, he is good no question about it but there is no way he is the sole reason they win games. They won a lot of games before he ever stepped foot on that campus.
  • thedynasty1998
    I tend to side with bo schemmy on the Pryor argument. OSU loses a max of 2 games last year with anyone at QB. They are just so superior across the board of other Big 10 teams that an average QB would have a great career record.
  • LJ
    bo shemmy3337;705351 wrote:Again, he is good no question about it but there is no way he is the sole reason they win games. They won a lot of games before he ever stepped foot on that campus.

    So?
  • Automatik
    bo shemmy3337;705348 wrote:Yes passing has a lot to do with the great WR's he has and yes he is a good runner but the team would not be bad off if he never went to OSU IMO.

    Not as bad off, but still not as good as they are/were with him.
  • charliehustle14
    bo shemmy3337;705342 wrote:I will give you the highlights but all those numbers were there before he got there. Troy Smith did just as good IMO yet he is viewed as no TP.

    He is re-writing the OSU offensive record books, even with the 5 game suspension. On top of that, he's winning titles and bowl games. Yet you wonder why everyone is high on him? He's a physical freak who has gone from an athlete to a pretty decent QB, that's why.
  • bo shemmy3337
    LJ;705353 wrote:So?

    So I am saying he has not changed OSU and he is not the reason they do what they do. They would have been just fine without him. The QB would not have put up the numbers he has but they would have made up for it in other ways. The team is great every year and it is not because of him.
  • LJ
    bo shemmy3337;705356 wrote:So I am saying he has not changed OSU and he is not the reason they do what they do. They would have been just fine without him. The QB would not have put up the numbers he has but they would have made up for it in other ways. The team is great every year and it is not because of him.

    They would not have won the Rose Bowl or Sugar Bowl without him.
  • bo shemmy3337
    Automatik;705354 wrote:Not as bad off, but still not as good as they are/were with him.

    You really think he has made the team better than what they were before he got there? They beat Michigan the 4 years before he got there. They won a national tittle in 03 and won the big ten or at least a share of it all 4 years before he got there as well.
  • LJ
    bo shemmy3337;705358 wrote:You really think he has made the team better than what they were before he got there?

    Yes.
  • bo shemmy3337
    LJ;705357 wrote:They would not have won the Rose Bowl or Sugar Bowl without him.

    Your going off of the current team who has no backup, if he never came OSU would have got another stud and would have been just fine. It is not like OSu entire future was riding on his choice to come to OSU. It is not like Lebron leaving Cleveland.
  • charliehustle14
    bo shemmy3337;705356 wrote:So I am saying he has not changed OSU and he is not the reason they do what they do. They would have been just fine without him. The QB would not have put up the numbers he has but they would have made up for it in other ways. The team is great every year and it is not because of him.

    You can't hold a QB back just because he plays for a great team. Roethlisberger has played on some great teams and surely a lot of other QB's could win for the Steelers with the defense and offensive playmakers they have, but that doesn't take away from Roethlisberger being a pretty damn good NFL QB.
  • LJ
  • Automatik
    bo shemmy3337;705356 wrote:So I am saying he has not changed OSU and he is not the reason they do what they do.

    I'm saying that I've never heard any OSU fan claim that lol. Do you know what reaching is? Because thats what you're doing. Fishing for negative shit to say that really isn't warranted.

    If you want to bash Pryor for being a dumbass I'm all for that.
  • LJ
    bo shemmy3337;705361 wrote:Your going off of the current team who has no backup, if he never came OSU would have got another stud and would have been just fine. It is not like OSu entire future was riding on his choice to come to OSU. It is not like Lebron leaving Cleveland.

    How many "stud" QB's for OSU can you name in the past 20 years?
  • bo shemmy3337
    Automatik;705364 wrote:I'm saying that I've never heard any OSU fan claim that lol. Do you know what reaching is? Because thats what you're doing. Fishing for negative shit to say that really isn't warranted.

    If you want to bash Pryor for being a dumbass I'm all for that.


    I am not bashing or reaching, I just do not think he is the GOAT like so many do.
  • Automatik
    bo shemmy3337;705366 wrote:I am not bashing or reaching, I just do not think he is the GOAT like so many do.

    Who said he was the GOAT? Now you're just making stuff up.

    But wait...."OSU fans were saying it omg!"
  • charliehustle14
    bo shemmy3337;705366 wrote:I am not bashing or reaching, I just do not think he is the GOAT like so many do.

    Oh well who gives a shit? You're a Michigan fan so what would you know about OSU football players and their meaning to the program.
  • bo shemmy3337
    LJ;705365 wrote:How many "stud" QB's for OSU can you name in the past 20 years?

    It doesn't have to be a QB AJ hawk was the man for years, someone would have stepped up and they would have been the star of the team but either way they would still be winners IMO.
  • thedynasty1998
    I think I'm in the middle. I think Pryor is a good college QB. However, I do think he gets too much credit and is labeled as great too often.
  • bo shemmy3337
    Automatik;705367 wrote:Who said he was the GOAT? Now you're just making stuff up.

    But wait...."OSU fans were saying it omg!"

    Many people act like he is the GOAT which is the point behind my argument
  • bo shemmy3337
    thedynasty1998;705370 wrote:I think I'm in the middle. I think Pryor is a good college QB. However, I do think he gets too much credit and is labeled as great too often.

    This