Why does Notre Dame have trouble winning?

• pooter

  Why do they??? They consider themselves thee prestige program... Lou Holtz was predicting a National Title game in the preseason... Every new coach since Holtz is the savior.... but turn out to be the lamb.... What is the problem????
• rock_knutne

  Wow, another ND thread!:s
• newarkcatholicfan

  

  [size=x-large]O V E R R A T E D B Y T H E M E D I A [/size]A N D T H E I R B L I N D F A N S
• sleeper

  

  Because they aren't very good? That'd be the easiest and most accurate answer.
• Cleveland Buck

  

  Another ND thread huh? Just what we needed. Thanks.
• devil1197

  Because year after year they are highly overrated.
  
  When you have 6 win talent with coaching and players, you shouldn't be ranked in the preseason polls even if its at #25.
• BCSbunk

  The biggest problem is talent, and before I get the hordes of ND fans allow me to explain. If you go to rivals right now check all the top O-line man at my last check about 4-5 days ago not a single top star o-line was signed by Notre Dame.
  
  I do not suggest that Notre Dame is talentless. They have some great skill players Clausen Floyd and Tate but thier line play is not at a top level at all. In the Stanford game the de's for Stanford looked like all-americans getting past the very slow O-lineman of Notre Dame.
  
  The game of football is won on the lines of scrimmage, cliche I know, but true. They do not have the talent on the lines to create the synergy needed to be one of the top teams. Weis was able to recruit some high profile skill players but you need lineman too.
  
  If the new coach has great success with winning I will conceed that it is not Notre Dames standards. At this point I do not believe a new coach will do much for them.
• Skyhook79

  

  They can't seem to score more points than their opponent?
• Mr Pat

  BCS, ever hear of Sam Young?
• killer_ewok

  

  Bad hires. Coaching.
• cbus4life

  Coaching.
• BCSbunk

  Mr Pat wrote: BCS, ever hear of Sam Young?

  Does the Browns having Joe Thomas make their line even average?
• Mr Pat

  Never said made them average. You said they haven't signed one single top star o-line recruit, which was wrong.
• BCSbunk

  Mr Pat wrote: Never said made them average. You said they haven't signed one single top star o-line recruit, which was wrong.

  You should reread what I said. I said I went 4-5 days ago and not one top star recruit. Not that they have never gotten one. Line play is their weakness. Their line is below average.
• DaBrowns41

  Have you seen the defenses they've been putting on the field?
  
  When Tom Zbikowski is one of the best defensive players you've had in the last 10 years, you know you've been struggling.
  
  They've had a few great players here and there like Justin Tuck, Trevor Laws, Victor Abiamiri, Chinedum Ndukwe, Gerome Sapp, Anthony Weaver, and Rocky Boiman...
  
  But that's all since 2000. Most of those guys were 2nd rounders at best, and a couple of them just developed well as 6th and 7th round draft picks.
• dwccrew

  

  Coaching
• CinciX12

  

  ccrunner609 wrote: 1. THe mythical recruiting classes
  
  2. THe stupid TV deals
  
  3. They arent in a conference (they wouldnt win one conference in the country)
  
  4. hiring overhyped coaches
  
  5. the lore of a tradition that does nothing for them

  I believe you just defined jealousy. Good for you and your 8th grade education.
• Hamp89

  A lot of it is coaching.
• rock_knutne

  CinciX12 wrote:Good for you and your 8th grade education.

  I hope not, he claims to be a school teacher.
• dwccrew

  

  rock_knutne wrote:

  CinciX12 wrote:Good for you and your 8th grade education.

  I hope not, he claims to be a school teacher.

  Explains why the US education system is getting worse and worse every year. Also supports the old saying, "Those who can, do. Those who can't, teach."
• Mr Pat

  BCSbunk wrote:

  Mr Pat wrote: Never said made them average. You said they haven't signed one single top star o-line recruit, which was wrong.

  You should reread what I said. I said I went 4-5 days ago and not one top star recruit. Not that they have never gotten one. Line play is their weakness. Their line is below average.

  So the reason they struggled this year is because this class doesn't have one top star recruit? His O-Line recruits were almost all highly rated.
  
  I agree though that line play is their weakness but I attribute that to coaching again.