CBS Sportsline and SI.com dont have Tebow or McCoy in their top 5 for the Heisman

• George Costanza

  USA Today has Tebow #1 and McCoy #3
  
  ESPN's Heisman Predictor has Tebow #1 and McCoy #3
  
  Those are the only 2 I have seen that has them in the top 5.
  
  Are both in real danger of not even getting an invite?
• wildcats20

  

  Nor should they.
  
  McCoy maybe, but without Shipley he isn't the QB he is. Tebow has had a very subpar year.
• centralbucksfan

  wildcats20 wrote: Nor should they.
  
  McCoy maybe, but without Shipley he isn't the QB he is. Tebow has had a very subpar year.

  Please, McCoy has been doing what he has for multiple years. The comment above is like saying Joe Montanna wouldn't be the QB he was without Jerry Rice!
  Weak year for the Heisman. Wouldn't surprise me if Tebow on...it wont' be deserving unless he has some huge games the last few games...it will be just a lifetime achievement award basically.
• George Costanza

  Depends on who's site you look at.
  
  CBS says that he will win if he has a good game and beats Alabama.
  
  This year is a situation where the voting will no doubt go down to the last Saturday.
• CharlieHog

  This site is the best when it comes to the Heisman.
  
  http://heismanpundit.com/
  
  HP HEISMAN POLL (11/17)
  Total Pts (and 1st place votes)
  
  1. M. Ingram--59 (10)
  2. C. McCoy--35 (1)
  3. T. Gerhart--33 (1)
  4. C.J. Spiller--23
  5. Tim Tebow--16