Ohio Chatter DEV

OneBuckeye

All Decade Team

Readers
Team: Smithville 2008-2009
Player: Tyler Bates

1st Team: Bates, Rottman, Frank, Kornowski, Peters

http://www.the-daily-record.com/news/article/4774710

Dorken's

Team of the decade: Triway, 2005-06

Player: 1. Linc Rottman, Triway, '06

Starting five: 1. Linc Rottman, Triway, '06; 2. Kenny Kornowski, Smithville, '09; 3. Danny Peters, Wooster, '02; 4. Josh Garrison, Triway, '01; 5. Jake Frank, Northwestern, '01.

Second five: 6. Jamie Breneman, Triway, '06; 7. Joey Brightbill, Hillsdale, '01; 8. Kendall Schabach, Hiland, '01; 9. Kyle Gillette, Loudonville, '05; 10. Tyler Bates, Smithville, '09.

Plant's
Team of the decade: Triway, 2005-06

Player: 1. Kenny Kornowski, Smithville, '09

Starting five: 1. Kenny Kornowski, Smithville, '09; 2. Danny Peters, Wooster, '02; 3. Linc Rottman, Triway; 4. Jamie Breneman, Triway; 5. Josh Garrison, Triway, '01.

Second five: 6. Jake Frank, Northwestern, '01; 7. Joey Brightbill, Hillsdale, '01; 8. Dylan Kaufman, Hiland, '12; 9. Kyle Gillette, Loudonville, '05; 10. Kendall Schabach, Hiland, '01.

Bolinger's
Team of the decade: Triway, 2005-06

Player: 1. Linc Rottman, Triway, '06

Starting five: 1. Linc Rottman, Triway, '06; 2. Kenny Kornowski, Smithville, '09; 3. Jake Frank, Northwestern, '01; 4. Joey Brightbill, Hillsdale, '01; 5. Danny Peters, Wooster, '02.

Second five: 6. Jamie Breneman, Triway, '06; 7. Josh Garrison, Triway '01; 8. Daniel Zacour, Central Christian, '05; 9. Kendall Schlabach, Hiland, '00; 10. Dylan Kaufman, Hiland, '12.

http://www.the-daily-record.com/news/article/4774707
http://www.the-daily-record.com/news/article/4774709
http://www.the-daily-record.com/news/article/4774819

Thoughts?

Hb31187

Is this all decade for a certain area or division? Because if not...LOL

THE4RINGZ

Pretty accurate picks by the DR staff.

OneBuckeye

Hb31187 wrote: Is this all decade for a certain area or division? Because if not...LOL

Greater Wayne-Holmes county area...

OneBuckeye

THE4RINGZ wrote: Pretty accurate picks by the DR staff.

I agree... the readers must have a thing against Triway, and it's curious that all the reader love went to Bates, someone that didn't show up in the staff teams. Also interesting is there are no Orrville players. With the great basketball history and tradition at Orrville I find that surprising.

RedRider1

OneBuckeye wrote: I agree... the readers must have a thing against Triway, and it's curious that all the reader love went to Bates, someone that didn't show up in the staff teams. Also interesting is there are no Orrville players. With the great basketball history and tradition at Orrville I find that surprising.

Orrville basketball had a bad decade, at least comparatively. No regional appearances and a lot of zero or one win tournaments. A lot of forgettable teams and efforts.

Tim Hiller & Brandon Short were the only 2 players that you could make a case for. But who do you remove from the top 10?

wcalfan

OneBuckeye wrote:
THE4RINGZ wrote: Pretty accurate picks by the DR staff.
I agree... the readers must have a thing against Triway, and it's curious that all the reader love went to Bates, someone that didn't show up in the staff teams. Also interesting is there are no Orrville players. With the great basketball history and tradition at Orrville I find that surprising.

Please tell me that this was an early April Fool's joke. Bates Player of the Decade? What a disgrace to all of the great players of the decade.

OneBuckeye

RedRider1 wrote:
OneBuckeye wrote: I agree... the readers must have a thing against Triway, and it's curious that all the reader love went to Bates, someone that didn't show up in the staff teams. Also interesting is there are no Orrville players. With the great basketball history and tradition at Orrville I find that surprising.
Orrville basketball had a bad decade, at least comparatively. No regional appearances and a lot of zero or one win tournaments. A lot of forgettable teams and efforts.

Tim Hiller & Brandon Short were the only 2 players that you could make a case for. But who do you remove from the top 10?

No one, but it helps put the bad decade they have had into more persepective.

wcalfan wrote:
OneBuckeye wrote:
THE4RINGZ wrote: Pretty accurate picks by the DR staff.
I agree... the readers must have a thing against Triway, and it's curious that all the reader love went to Bates, someone that didn't show up in the staff teams. Also interesting is there are no Orrville players. With the great basketball history and tradition at Orrville I find that surprising.
Please tell me that this was an early April Fool's joke. Bates Player of the Decade? What a disgrace to all of the great players of the decade.

I think there may have been some bias in the reader voting.

THE4RINGZ

Obviously more readers who voted are fans of the WCAL. That is why I said in my original post that it was accurate by the DR staff. No, Onebuckeye, I don't believe there was any anti-Triway biased, I think it was a combination of fans not getting to see them play and the fact that Smithville went deeper in the play-off more recently.

Smthville has had a great run the past couple of years and I congratulate them on that. IMO they need to string a few more years of consistant winning and going deep into the playoffs to be considered one of the elite programs in the area.

Wooster Rooster

I think it is pretty clear one partiuclar player in the fan voting had a campaign manager and a good one at that lol. The writers did a good job of setting thing straight

tha_facilitator

someone's family was really concerned about getting a certain player of the decade IMO.....

The Campaign Manager

I wasn't "the campaign manager" but I actually voted for Tyler, along with Linc, Danny, Kenny, and Tim.

I don't think Tyler was the best scorer at all but to call him a disgrace to the other players is mean. From looking at the nominations, Tyler was the only player to average 17ppg 6 rpg and 6 apg for a season in the entire decade.....While doing so for the top ranked team in the state and getting a lot of the defenses' attention (along with Kenny obviously). I actually think that Danny Peters was the best player myself, but some people are mean.

It shouldn't be a big deal if somebody's family and friends and teammates vote for him, because everyone had the opportunity to. I think that every person's list can be argued. I'll take Bolyard over Brenneman any day. I would even take many players over Frank and Garrison.

The Triway team wouldn't have beaten Smithville or last year's Hiland team in my opinion either.

RedRider1

This isn't going to turn in to another "Hate on Bates" thread is it?

I guess this is what can happen when you leave it up to fan polling. Didn't NBA fans just vote Allen Iverson as a starter for the East? It should be taken with a grain of salt.

THE4RINGZ

Bates had a great career.

THE4RINGZ

Wait "hate on Bates" you aren't referring to my fellow Huskie Brother Roy are you?

Riderwannabe

its a joke,he was ok,but not poy,

Old Rider

Kornowski or Rottman (Linc) would be my pick for POTD. The POTD chosen/receiving the most votes, had to move away from a school (that had ony a couple players mentioned on the entire list....aka. Orrville) to get playing time.
Bates was a decent player at best...wow I wonder who all got to hear the "campaign manager's" descriptive plea to vote for his candidate!!!!

I bet it is hanging on the fridge at home, already laminated, and a party has been thrown.

Old Rider

The sports writers were right on I thought...Triway (either runner-up team) was the best team(s) of the decade!!!

tha_facilitator

did anyone who voted for bates look at the number of turnovers he committed per game?

thePITman

I really like Tyler Bates. He's a good friend of mine, and I think he was a really good player. But Player of the Decade? No, he wasn't.

Linc Rottman
#4 career scorer @ Triway
#7 career rebounder @ Triway
#1 career assister @ Triway
At least 1-time (maybe 2-time) DR Player of the Year
2-time (I think) DII Northeast Inland District POY
1st Team DII All-Ohio
Led his team to back-to-back DII state championship games

At least the sports writers got it right, IMO...

riders1

thePITman wrote: I really like Tyler Bates. He's a good friend of mine, and I think he was a really good player. But Player of the Decade? No, he wasn't.

Linc Rottman
#4 career scorer @ Triway
#7 career rebounder @ Triway
#1 career assister @ Triway
At least 1-time (maybe 2-time) DR Player of the Year
2-time (I think) DII Northeast Inland District POY
1st Team DII All-Ohio
Led his team to back-to-back DII state championship games

At least the sports writers got it right, IMO...

As much as it hurts to say it I have to agree with Pitman and go with triway and Rottman as the POD, bates not even close. Who's hands would you rather see the ball in in the last minute Rottman or Bates. Was it really more turnovers than points in his last game?

RedRider1

^^I beleive that was the stat.

And I'll 3rd that vote. Rottman was the best player on the best team in the last decade.

CCRolly

Triway should've been the Team of the Decade. But I'll still take Danny Peters with the ball in the last minute over anyone else.

thePITman

CCRolly wrote:Triway should've been the Team of the Decade.

They were the Team of the Decade on all 3 of the sports writers' lists, at least. There's no question, in my mind. Not only looking at it from an "accomplishments" standpoint, here is how the teams would have matched up.

Kornowski would have gone up against 6'10" Weber (playing college basketball).
Caldwell would have gone up against Jock Rottman (playing college basketball).
Bates would have gone up against Linc Rottman (Player of the Decade).
Beau Carpenter would have gone up against Jeff McCartney (playing college basketball).
And Frizell would have gone up against Senior Jamie Breneman!

And our bench was deep and big. Smithville was, what, 5-deep? Not to mention, our team had the experience of playing at the highest level having made it to the state championship the year before. Now, had Orr played for Smithville that year, they would have been a better team and probably won state... and the Team of the Decade debate would be a little closer, IMO.

I digress. I'm not putting down Smithville one bit, because they were a great team!! I just agree with all the sports writers that Triway was the Team of the Decade. Both teams were very fun to watch, though, and congratulations to both of them with all they accomplished!

ricola

that triway team was awesome. and has a hiland backer I don't think there's any way last year's Hiland team beats them. had they not run into a future Big Ten and NBA player at Dunbar theylikely would have been state champs at least one year

Archive

Daily Record All-Decade Team and Players