Mel KiperJr or Todd McShay

• Skyhook79

  

  Who is the better NFL Draft Guru?
• Trueblue23

  

  I can't stand either of them..
  
  But I'll take McShay.
• j_crazy

  

  Mayock.
• rydawg5

  M L K P R
• tuskytuffguy

  Neither. Worthless windbags. I really don't care to hear where someone thinks people will get drafted.
• rydawg5

  ^ internet mean guy
• Laley23

  

  As soon as either one learns to respect someone elses opinion Ill go with them. Right now, neither ever thinks they are gonna be wrong.
• j_crazy

  

  I'm telling you, Mike Mayock is the best. he's just not on ESPN.
• OneBuckeye

  

  Between the two Kiper all day. You have to respect the OG. McShay knows how to push Kipers buttons and does it on purpose. Another reason to go with kiper.
• ohiobucks1

  

  Kiper. He actually works hard
• DaBrowns41

  Over the years, Kiper has gotten more picks right then McShay.
  
  Mayock over the last 2-3 years has gotten more picks correctly than either Kiper or McShay, however.
• thedynasty1998

  

  I used to really dislike Kiper, but I've gained a respect for him over the years. He is really bright and knows what the NFL teams are looking for. I like them both, but think Kiper is a little bit better.
• mtrulz

  Mel Kiper Jr, he has his own topic on SportsCenter's Bottomline. That says enough.
• Society

  mtrulz wrote: Mel Kiper Jr, he has his own topic on SportsCenter's Bottomline. That says enough.

  OMG! He has his own topic! Unfuckingbelievable! He has to be the best. No questions asked.
  
  Pathetic.
• Mr Pat

  Society wrote:

  mtrulz wrote: Mel Kiper Jr, he has his own topic on SportsCenter's Bottomline. That says enough.

  OMG! He has his own topic! Unfuckingbelievable! He has to be the best. No questions asked.
  
  Pathetic.

  What a jerk. As for the topic, Kiper. McShay is a turd.
• Non

  

  I like Kiper better but it's hard to explain why. I know what I mean but not sure others do.
  
  McShay is like Kiper of 25 years ago. He has all the scouting reports and tries to sound educated by going with the measurables and everything that someone who is trying to be a draft expert would try to pass off to the public.
  
  Kiper has become more flexible with teams just looking for good football players, productive players and things of that nature.
• Non

  

  I like Mayock, too. He gives a lot of great insight during the combine.
• hoops23

  

  Off of this list, Mel Kiper, no doubt.. Kiper does all of his own work and studies the film himself.. McShay has a team of guys working with him.. Then he tries to sound like a pompous ass everytime he and Kiper are together...
  
  I'd love to punch McGay in the fucking face one day, no doubt...no doubt...
• crab42

  I respect the amount of work and the time that Kiper puts into it... His wife has to be a special lady or she really enjoys those paychecks. Kiper is just a walking encyclopedia of draft knowledge.
• bigkahuna

  Kiper gets under my skin, but Mcshay doesn't.
  
  Kiper just comes off as pompus and his hair pisses me off
• mtrulz

  Society wrote: OMG! He has his own topic! Unfuckingbelievable! He has to be the best. No questions asked.
  
  Pathetic.

  Go stalk somebody else.
• cat_lover

  Mel Kiper Jr. His hair is awesome.
• Quint

  

  Kiper. . . McShay is an idiot.