Archive

Most Successful American Idolist?

  • chicago510
  • SnotBubbles
    vball10set;1093828 wrote:
    FAP FAP FAP!!!!
  • Y-Town Steelhound
    vball10set;1093921 wrote:I didn't realize this. Where did you get this information?
    internet
  • bigdaddy2003
    I would say Underwood.

    I can tell you I doubt it will be anyone from this years crop. They always say it's the best season talent wise but this year I just can't get that interested in a lot of the contestants. Every year there are a couple that I enjoy and think have a solid chance of winning and I just can't do it this year.
  • SnotBubbles
    bigdaddy2003;1093981 wrote:I would say Underwood.

    I can tell you I doubt it will be anyone from this years crop. They always say it's the best season talent wise but this year I just can't get that interested in a lot of the contestants. Every year there are a couple that I enjoy and think have a solid chance of winning and I just can't do it this year.
    What is this, season 12? It's amazing they've only produced 3 legit musicians in 12 seasons. It goes to show just how unimportant AI is to the industry.
  • vball10set
    Y-Town Steelhound;1093978 wrote:internet
    ok...link?
  • Y-Town Steelhound
    vball10set;1093990 wrote:ok...link?

    http://www.lemonparty.org
  • GOONx19
    Depends on how you define success. Underwood has sold more albums. Clarkson has made more money.
  • sherm03
    Clarkson has fat arms. Underwood wins in my book.
  • Steel Valley Football
    dontcare;1093847 wrote:I'll bet Faith Hill and Martina McBride throw-up in their mouth every time Karaoke Carrie wins an award......

    They are all three the same in that regard. None of the three write their own songs, iirc.
  • Ironman92
    Clarkson until Carrie won and then Carrie up until about last year and Clarkson might have a slight edge overall.....but Carrie will regain her lead with her next released work....that and she's smokin
  • vball10set
    Y-Town Steelhound;1094026 wrote:http://www.lemonparty.org
    Youngstown represent :D
  • vball10set
    Steel Valley Football;1094054 wrote:They are all three the same in that regard. None of the three write their own songs, iirc.
    link?
  • Little Danny
    GOONx19;1094037 wrote:Depends on how you define success. Underwood has sold more albums. Clarkson has made more money.
    Underwood has beaten her in both categories. See post #9.
  • GOONx19
    Little Danny;1094133 wrote:Underwood has beaten her in both categories. See post #9.
    Those numbers are only for the 2010-2011 fiscal year. But yes, I was wrong, and Underwood has indeed just taken over the career earnings spot.
  • Steel Valley Football
    vball10set;1094130 wrote:link?

    www.vballsux.com should help you any problems you might have. Unless your a chick then it's ok.
  • LJ
    Steel Valley Football;1094355 wrote:www.vballsux.com should help you any problems you might have. Unless your a chick then it's ok.

    You're
  • GOONx19
    Grammar: the difference between knowing your shit and knowing you're shit.
  • ZWICK 4 PREZ
    Ruben Studdard
  • ernest_t_bass
    vball10set;1093828 wrote:

    WOW!
  • vball10set
    Steel Valley Football;1094355 wrote:www.svfsuxoffvball.com should help you any problems you might have. Unless your a chick then it's ok.
    No thanks, unless you're a chick, then it's ok.
  • ernest_t_bass
    Underwood.
  • McFly1955
    Lame poll - the answer is Taylor Hicks.


    Woo - Soul Patrol - Woo
  • se-alum
    Laley23;1093928 wrote:Simon Cowell said that a lot. It was a reason he didnt endorse people who played instruments as often as he maybe couldve. He was looking for more of a Pop Singer
    Pretty sure during Carrie's audition, Simon said something along the lines of being glad Carrie was a country singer. He praised her the entire competition. Pretty sure they were looking for anyone that could sell records.
  • vball10set
    se-alum;1094687 wrote:Pretty sure during Carrie's audition, Simon said something along the lines of being glad Carrie was a country singer. He praised her the entire competition. Pretty sure they were looking for anyone that could sell records.
    :thumbup: