American Idol... the top 5 and elimination nite.

• bases_loaded

  

  Haley is the money maker...I can hear ProActive calling her already.
  
  I can't stand seeing James face.
  
  Haley is nice to look at and like her voice.
• bases_loaded

  

  James is gone....
  
  
  
  
  Spoiler alert
• GoPens

  

  Another example of how the people who watch this show have no clue what talent is. James gone. Either of the girls should have left. I'm done for this year. I'll watch The Voice instead.
• bases_loaded

  

  GoPens;766949 wrote:Another example of how the people who watch this show have no clue what talent is. James gone. Either of the girls should have left. I'm done for this year. I'll watch The Voice instead.

  
  Or its all fixed for ratings. He will get a gig no matter what
• Belly35

  

  Scotty for the money
• tuskytuffguy

  Total.......Fucking........Bullshit.
• Little Danny

  

  Obviously country music fans have tuned and have shown up with the votes this year. Consider that Scotty and Lauren likely split votes from that demographic. This contest is going to boil down to one of those two, undeservedly so IMO.
  
  The deal with Scotty is not just that he sings country, but how he just has that one (doing my best Elvis impersonation) "Thank You Very Much" tone. He is a one trick pony!!! As James said as he left the stage, he's done stuff nobody has ever done in the history of the show. He is a much better singer and all around performer.
  
  As for Lauren, as I said earlier, she is nothing special. There are literally thousands of these blond haired blue eyed country girls who can sing as well as she does all over the country. They haven't made it big, but they are singing at the local level, maybe even have an album or two that has been cut. Some of them are still in college or even in high school. The purpose of this show I thought was to find the next superstar. She is not a superstar IMO.
• Tiger2003

  

  I love the Scotty haters. I swear we have some producers on here.
• bases_loaded

  

  James is Adam Lambert straight
• Tiger2003

  

  bases_loaded;766979 wrote:James is Adam Lambert straight

  
  That is exactly what I told the fiancé.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  bases_loaded;766979 wrote:James is Adam Lambert straight

  
  lulz
  

  Tiger2003;766982 wrote:That is exactly what I told the fiancé.

  
  lulz x 2
• HitsRus

  

  As for Lauren, as I said earlier, she is nothing special

  +1
  
  How this girl survives beyond Pia, James, and even Casey is beyond me.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  Lauren is fat.
• Tiger2003

  

  ernest_t_bass;767088 wrote:Lauren is fat.

  
  And you're a piece of shit. What's your point?
• bigdaddy2003

  

  She isn't fat. She is like 6 feet tall. At best she is husky.
• ClayAikenation

  

  Shut the fuck up
• Tiger2003

  

  bigdaddy2003;767100 wrote:She isn't fat. She is like 6 feet tall. At best she is husky.

  
  She has lost alot of weight since coming on the show. Sure looks like she is losing all of her baby fat. My fiancé thinks she is prettier then Haley.
• bigdaddy2003

  

  ClayAikenation;767102 wrote:Shut the fuck up

  
  Who?
• ernest_t_bass

  

  Tiger2003;767093 wrote:And you're a piece of shit. What's your point?

  
  QQ
• september63

  

  James's last song has night was horrible. At times he sounds no better than a guy screaming at the top of his lungs. You couldnt even understand a word or two. Now for they crying, it was OK the first time he became emotional, but it doesnt work when you do it every damn week.!!!
  
  Good Riddance Crybaby!!
• Mister Twister

  America has spoken. And what they have said is that they are fucking stupid.
• bases_loaded

  

  Mister Twister;767197 wrote:America has spoken. And what they have said is that they are fucking stupid.

  
  See the White House
• se-alum

  

  I said it a month ago, James has little mainstream appeal, and we've most likely heard from him for the last time.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  Mister Twister;767197 wrote:America has spoken. And what they have said is that they are fucking stupid.

  bases_loaded;767209 wrote:See the White House

  
  QFT!
• THE4RINGZ

  

  I hated to see anyone go last night. I do picture an all country final two.